A chilling new clue has emerged in the desperate search for 18-year-old Rodrigo “Rico” Montes, the vibrant high school senior from northwest Indiana whose disappearance after a late-night cookout has gripped the community in heartbreak and suspicion. Blood discovered under the I-80/94 overpass near Central Avenue — just east of where the black pickup truck plunged upside down into Deep River — is now believed to belong to the missing teen. Police have collected samples and are rushing DNA tests that could finally unravel the mystery of what really happened in the early morning hours of March 23, 2026. This potential breakthrough has sent shockwaves through Lake Station and beyond, raising fresh questions about the driver’s account, the sequence of events after the crash, and whether Rico fought for his life on the riverbank before the waters claimed him.
Driver dies after speeding on wet road, crashing into a river in Carson -  CBS Los Angeles

The discovery came not from official search teams at first, but from Rico’s own family, who refused to sit idle while authorities mobilized. Armed with flashlights in the darkness shortly after the submerged truck was spotted around 4 a.m., relatives scoured the area near the crash site at 27th Avenue and Wyoming Street. What they found under the towering interstate overpass was a horrifying sight: blood stains on the ground, positioned close enough to the river to suggest a desperate struggle or escape attempt gone wrong. Family members immediately alerted police, and investigators quickly cordoned off the location as a possible secondary crime scene or critical piece of evidence in what is now being treated with heightened urgency.

Rico Montes was last seen alive as a passenger in that fateful pickup truck after enjoying a casual cookout with friends on Sunday night, March 22. A senior at River Forest High School in Hobart, he was described by everyone who knew him as “very nice, very caring” — a dedicated wrestler with a bright smile, a kind heart, and plans for life after graduation that would never come to fruition. He had texted or told loved ones he had secured a ride home with someone he trusted. That trust, it seems, may have been tragically misplaced. Rico never walked through the front door. His brother Adolfo grew worried as the hours ticked by, contacting police after midnight and even calling local hospitals in a frantic search for answers.

The truck — believed to belong to the juvenile driver — was discovered overturned and fully submerged in the cold waters of Deep River by an off-duty deputy who happened to be related by upcoming marriage to the Montes family. The deputy was out looking overnight and spotted the vehicle around 4 a.m., triggering an immediate response from Lake Station police, fire crews, and divers from the Indiana Department of Natural Resources. When first responders arrived, the cab was empty. No sign of Rico inside the crumpled wreckage. That absence set off days of intensive searching: sonar sweeps, drone flights, boat patrols, and dive teams combing the murky riverbed. The community rallied with volunteers, prayers, and candlelight vigils, clinging to hope that Rico had somehow escaped the submerged vehicle and was waiting to be found alive.

Holding out Hope: NW Indiana high school student missing after truck crashes  in river - YouTube

Then came the blood under the I-80/94 overpass. Located just east of the main crash site, the stains suggest Rico may have been ejected, crawled out, or been pulled from the truck during or after the impact. The overpass area, with its concrete pillars, limited lighting at night, and proximity to the riverbank, could have become a scene of chaos and panic. Was Rico injured on impact and trying to reach help? Did he and the driver argue — as the driver later claimed — and did that escalate into something physical on the roadside? Or did something far more sinister unfold in those dark minutes before the truck went into the water?

The juvenile driver, whose name is protected due to his age, has told authorities a story centered on a “short argument” inside the vehicle that allegedly caused him to lose control. He reportedly walked away from the scene on foot, made his way home without immediately calling emergency services, and later appeared at Rico’s family home with his own parents, seemingly disoriented and in need of a mental health evaluation. He claimed not to know where Rico was. That explanation has never sat well with the Montes family. “If it was the other way around,” one relative said, “I know Rico wouldn’t have left his friend behind.” Now, the blood discovery adds explosive weight to those doubts. If the DNA matches Rico, it could place him outside the truck, possibly injured and vulnerable on the bank, raising the terrifying possibility that help was not summoned in time — or worse.

Forensic experts are working around the clock on the DNA analysis. Results could take days or weeks depending on lab backlog, but authorities have prioritized the samples given the high-profile nature of the case. If the blood is confirmed as Rico’s, it could reshape the entire investigation: confirming he survived the initial crash long enough to exit the vehicle, potentially altering charges against the driver from reckless homicide toward more serious counts involving failure to render aid, leaving the scene, or even aggravated circumstances. Toxicology on both teens, vehicle forensics (including speed, impact angle, and seatbelt usage), and any phone data from that night will be crucial in piecing together the timeline.

Lake Station, a tight-knit community in Lake County along the Deep River corridor, has been shaken to its core. The river, which snakes through industrial and residential zones, is not particularly deep but carries strong currents and poor visibility that make recovery efforts grueling. The crash site itself is along a stretch of road that can feel deceptively quiet at night, with possible curves and limited shoulder space near the water. Locals now drive past the area with heavy hearts, many slowing down to glance at the impromptu memorial of flowers, crosses, and photos of Rico that have sprung up along the roadside and under the overpass.

Rico’s family has spoken publicly through tears and determination. His father’s heart-wrenching question — “Where is my son?” — echoed across local news as the search dragged on. His brother Adolfo described the agony of waiting, the sleepless nights, and the small glimmer of hope that the blood might finally provide concrete answers rather than more uncertainty. The wrestling team at River Forest High School mourned one of their own, sharing stories of Rico’s work ethic, his encouragement of teammates, and the laughter he brought to practices. Hundreds gathered at St. Francis Xavier Church for a prayer vigil, filling the sanctuary with shared grief and quiet resolve.

This case has ignited broader conversations across northwest Indiana and into the Chicago suburbs about teenage driving, peer pressure, late-night decisions, and the deadly consequences of distraction or conflict behind the wheel. Parents are using the tragedy as a painful teaching moment: talk to your kids about calling for help no matter what, about the dangers of arguments escalating in a moving vehicle, and about the lifelong guilt that can follow one split-second choice. The driver’s decision to leave the scene without immediate assistance has drawn particular outrage, even as his age shields some details from public view.

As DNA testing proceeds, investigators from Lake Station police and the Lake County Prosecutor’s Office remain tight-lipped on specifics to protect the integrity of the case. The juvenile justice system will handle proceedings with confidentiality, but the gravity of losing a promising 18-year-old senior — a wrestler, a caring friend, a son and brother — has captured attention far beyond local borders. News outlets from WGN to regional stations have kept the story in the spotlight, amplifying calls for tips and community support.

Marin County crash: Driver in accident that killed 4 teens in April 2025  charged with misdemeanor vehicular manslaughter - ABC7 San Francisco

The blood under the I-80/94 overpass represents more than just a forensic sample; it is a silent witness to those final, terrifying moments. Did Rico scream for help as the truck flipped? Did he manage to drag himself onto the bank only to succumb to injuries or the cold river? Or was there interaction with the driver on solid ground that the official story has yet to fully reveal? Each possibility paints a more haunting picture than the last.

While the Montes family waits anxiously for DNA confirmation, they continue honoring Rico’s memory through advocacy for safer roads and greater accountability for young drivers. Fundraisers and memorial events have poured in, with classmates, coaches, and neighbors stepping up to support the family in their grief. Social media has become a double-edged sword — spreading awareness and prayers on one hand, while fueling speculation and unverified theories on the other.

The driver’s “short argument” narrative, once the central explanation, now feels incomplete in light of the blood evidence. If Rico was outside the vehicle and bleeding near the overpass, the timeline of when and how he entered the river becomes critical. Did the driver attempt any rescue? Did panic override reason? Or was there something more deliberate in the sequence of events that night? These are the questions keeping investigators awake and the community on edge.

Deep River has already given up the truck and, days later, Rico’s body was recovered from its waters. Yet the blood discovery adds a new layer of tragedy and intrigue, suggesting the full story of that night may involve a desperate fight for survival on the river’s edge. As results from the lab loom, the Montes family clings to the hope that science will deliver justice and closure — even if it cannot bring their beloved Rico back.

Rico Montes should be preparing for prom, final exams, or his next wrestling match. Instead, his story has become a cautionary tale etched into the landscape of northwest Indiana: a ride home that ended in submerged silence, a family flashlight search that uncovered blood under an overpass, and a DNA test that could rewrite the narrative of one tragic crash. The community watches, prays, and waits — hoping the blood leads not just to answers, but to accountability that honors a young life taken too soon.

The overpass stands as a silent sentinel now, its shadows holding secrets that science may soon expose. For the Montes family, every hour until those DNA results arrive feels like an eternity. For the driver, the stakes have never been higher. And for everyone who knew Rico, the pain remains raw — a bright senior gone, leaving behind questions that blood alone may begin to answer.