How Meghan Markle and Sister’s Battle Lines Are Drawn in Court Appeal

Samantha Markle’s lawyers are preparing a bid to overturn Meghan Markle’s court victory over libel allegations relating to the Oprah Winfrey interview and the royal’s Netflix show.

The Duchess of Sussex told Oprah she was brought up as an only child while Samantha changed her last name back to Markle “only when I started dating Harry.”

Samantha’s lawyers argued in a civil lawsuit that the comments were “disparaging, hurtful, and false” statements that suggested she is “a stranger, a liar, and a . . . deceptive fame-seeking imposter with avaricious intentions.”

Meghan won the initial case, but Samantha has taken the lawsuit to the 11th Circuit Court of Appeal, where her lawyers have been given a July deadline for filing their initial brief.

Meghan Markle at Ms Foundation Awards Meghan Markle at the Women of Vision Awards on May 16, 2023. Meghan is being sued by her half-sister Samantha Markle. 

They have given an initial indication of where the battle lines will be drawn in a court filing, seen by Newsweek, which reads: “Cumulative inferences and remarks made by [Meghan] have caused a cumulative meaning, which the court did not consider.”

Among the other comments cited are remarks Meghan made in her Netflix show, Harry & Meghan, including: “I was with my mom during the week and with my dad on the weekends. And my dad lived alone, he had two adult children who had moved out of his house.”

“I don’t remember seeing her when I was a kid at my dad’s house,” Meghan continued, “if and when they would come around.”

Judge Charlene Edwards Honeywell’s original ruling dismissed the case, stating that Meghan “barely mentions [Samantha], to say only that at some point during [Meghan’s] childhood, [Samantha] moved out of her father’s house.

“It is not plausible that [Samantha] would be exposed to hatred, ridicule, or contempt as a result of this statement.”

Samantha’s lawyers will tie their appeal to the notion Meghan was constructing a broader attack across multiple interviews on her sister’s status as a figure in a position to comment on her life.

Meghan’s lawyers have indicated they will fight the appeal by arguing the judge followed normal procedure in what they view as a routing libel case: “To the contrary, this is a garden-variety defamation action involving the application of well-established Eleventh Circuit precedent, which the District Court followed.”

Meghan will be hoping this is Samantha’s final roll of the dice and that it fails quickly and cleanly, bringing to an end a saga that has rumbled on since March 2022.

Back then, Meghan’s lawyer, Michael Kump, said in a statement: “This baseless and absurd lawsuit is just a continuation of a pattern of disturbing behavior. We will give it the minimum attention necessary, which is all it deserves.”

The subsequent two years have, however, required a greater degree of attention than perhaps that initial response suggested.

Related Posts

From tragedy came miracles 💖✨ 7 lives — a father, a singer, a teacher, and more — are breathing today because one brave nurse chose to give everything 💞 #KimberLivesOn

In the dim glow of an East Nashville evening, where the hum of distant guitars mingles with the whisper of the Cumberland River, tragedy struck with the…

Pink filled the halls of UAB Hospital today 💖🎈 — a powerful farewell to nurse Kimber Mills, gone too soon but giving others the gift of life through organ donation 🙏

Under a slate-gray Alabama sky heavy with unshed rain, the sterile corridors of the University of Alabama at Birmingham (UAB) Hospital transformed into a vibrant sea of…

Two more suspects caught in the shocking Nashville murder of beloved nurse Kimber Mills 💔 — police say the deadly robbery was far more organized than anyone thought 😨

In a gripping twist that has the Music City humming with a mix of vindication and lingering dread, authorities announced the arrests of two additional suspects in…

Donors furious 😡 after learning Karmelo Anthony’s parents allegedly spent over $500K in donations on luxury trips, a new home & an Escalade 🚨💰

What began as a tragic high school stabbing in the spring has devolved into a full-blown online inferno, with betrayed donors across the nation unleashing a torrent…

The wait is over. 🦴 Booth & Brennan are back — and this time, the bones tell a new story. Don’t blink. Bones: Resurrection premieres soon — are you ready? 👀

The Jeffersonian Institute’s lab has always been a place where bones tell stories—secrets etched in calcium, murders whispered through fractures, histories pieced together from the dust of…

Blood. Betrayal. Redemption Turned to Ruin. 💥 The Pitt – Season 2 Drags Robby Into His Darkest Hour — Where Every Ally Lies

The fluorescent lights of Allegheny General Hospital flicker like a dying heartbeat. When The Pitt returns for its sophomore season on January 15, 2026, the ER that…