Anna Camp Steals the Show in YOU Season 5 as the Unforgettable Lockwood Twins

When YOU Season 5 premiered on April 24, 2025, fans were eager to see how Joe Goldberg’s (Penn Badgley) story would conclude after five seasons of obsession, murder, and manipulation. While the final season delivered a satisfying end to Joe’s reign—landing him in jail with no chance of freedom—it was a pair of new characters who truly stole the spotlight: Raegan and Maddie Lockwood, played by the phenomenal Anna Camp. As the half-sisters of Joe’s wife, Kate Lockwood, the twins brought a chaotic, magnetic energy to the season, earning Camp widespread praise and cementing her performance as one of Netflix’s best casting choices in recent memory.

From the moment Raegan and Maddie appeared on screen, it was clear that Camp was operating on another level. The twins are polar opposites—Maddie, the polished and calculating socialite, and Raegan, the unhinged wildcard with a penchant for dropping the C-word in ways that could make any mother faint. Their dynamic added a fresh layer of drama to a season that, at times, struggled to maintain the intensity of its predecessors. Amidst a somewhat lackluster finale, as some fans described it, the Lockwood twins emerged as the season’s most gripping characters, delivering iconic lines and serving “gawgeous” looks that have since inspired countless TikTok edits and fan art.

Anna Camp, already celebrated for her roles in Pitch Perfect, True Blood, The Help, and House of Lies, showcased her unreal range in this dual role. Playing twins is no easy feat, requiring an actor to create two distinct personalities while maintaining a believable sibling connection. Camp nailed it, seamlessly switching between Maddie’s icy sophistication and Raegan’s feral unpredictability. One particularly memorable scene, dubbed “the mirror moment” by fans, sees the twins confronting each other in a tense, emotionally charged exchange that Camp herself highlighted as a proud moment. “Just to finally be on set and learn both sets of lines and get both hair and makeup done and both wardrobe changes—it was something that was really exciting for me, a challenge,” Camp told Page Six at the New York City premiere of YOU Season 5.

Everyone is just loving Anna Camp in YOU

The actress also revealed a behind-the-scenes tidbit that endeared her even more to fans: she requested double the pay for playing double the characters. “As soon as I got the call, I said, ‘Well, I’m going to have to learn double the lines, will I get double the money?’” Camp shared with a laugh. While the producers declined, she added, “I had to ask!” Although her salary for the season hasn’t been disclosed, fans argue that the love she’s received online—through viral TikTok edits and glowing reviews—should be payment enough. “Anna Camp killed this role for real!!!” one TikTok user commented under a fan edit, while another tweeted, “Anna Camp gives one of the best dual performances in a year full of dual performances #YouNetflix.”

Camp’s portrayal of the Lockwood twins has sparked a wave of Emmy buzz, with fans and critics alike calling for her to be recognized. “Can we also talk about Anna Camp’s performance in #YouSeason5!? Give that woman the Emmy now!” one fan wrote on X, while another exclaimed, “Anna Camp’s portrayal of Maddie & Raegan is SO fucking good, one of the best characters out of all seasons of YOU. Give her ALL the awards.” It’s not hard to see why she’s being hailed as the unannounced MVP of the season. While Joe and his latest obsession, Bronte/Louise, remained the narrative focus, Camp’s electric performance as the twins brought a much-needed jolt of energy, proving that even in a show centered on a serial killer, supporting characters can leave the biggest impression.

The impact of Raegan and Maddie has even inspired calls for a spin-off, with one particularly creative fan pitching a series titled US. The concept? Maddie discovers that Raegan’s personality is fighting for control, setting the stage for a psychological drama exploring the twins’ fractured dynamic. Given the depth Camp brought to both characters, this idea isn’t far-fetched. The Lockwood twins have already proven they can carry a story, and their unresolved tensions—combined with Camp’s ability to embody two distinct personas—make US a tantalizing prospect. “Netflix, if you’re reading this, make it happen!” the fan pleaded, echoing the sentiments of many who aren’t ready to say goodbye to the twins.

Anna Camp’s inclusion in YOU Season 5 will undoubtedly go down in history as a masterstroke of casting. Raegan and Maddie Lockwood brought chaos, glamour, and raw emotion to a season that needed their spark. Camp’s fearless performance not only elevated the show but also reminded us why she’s one of the most versatile actresses working today. As fans continue to rewatch her scenes and flood social media with praise, one thing is clear: the Lockwood twins may have been supporting characters, but they left a leading legacy.