In a twist that has sent Emily in Paris fans into a frenzy, a leaked plot detail from the highly anticipated Season 5 of the Netflix hit has surfaced, igniting speculation across social media. The bombshell? Emily Cooper, the effervescent American expat played by Lily Collins, is reportedly pregnant, and the identity of the baby’s father remains shrouded in mystery. Online communities are buzzing, placing their bets on two leading men from Emily’s tangled romantic web, as the show prepares to dive deeper into its signature blend of drama, romance, and chic escapism. With production kicking off in Rome and Paris, this leak has only heightened the anticipation for what promises to be the most scandalous season yet.
The Emily in Paris universe has never shied away from jaw-dropping plot twists, and Season 5 appears poised to up the ante. Created by Darren Star, the mastermind behind Sex and the City, the series has captivated audiences with its frothy mix of fashion, love triangles, and cultural clashes since its debut in 2020. Season 4 saw Emily navigating her heart’s desires between French chef Gabriel (Lucas Bravo) and Italian fashion heir Marcello (Eugenio Franceschini), while her former flame Alfie (Lucien Laviscount) lingered in the background. The season ended with Emily relocating to Rome to head Agence Grateau’s new office, sparking a romance with Marcello and leaving her Parisian ties—including Gabriel—in flux. Now, the leaked pregnancy plotline has fans questioning whether Emily’s new life in Rome will be upended by an unexpected baby and a paternity mystery that could reshape her future.
The leak, which first surfaced on social media platforms, has triggered a firestorm of fan theories. Many believe Gabriel, the brooding chef with whom Emily has shared undeniable chemistry since Season 1, is the frontrunner as the father. Their on-again, off-again romance has been a cornerstone of the series, complicated by Gabriel’s past engagement to Camille (Camille Razat) and a false pregnancy scare in Season 4. Despite their breakup in Season 4, Gabriel’s lingering feelings for Emily, coupled with his expressed desire to become a father, make him a prime candidate. Fans point to the emotional depth of their connection, arguing that a baby could be the dramatic catalyst to reunite them, even as Emily builds a life in Rome.
On the other hand, Marcello, the charming Italian who swept Emily off her feet in Season 4, has emerged as a strong contender. Their whirlwind romance, marked by picturesque Roman getaways and a healthier work-life balance for Emily, represents a fresh start. Fans rooting for Marcello argue that a pregnancy with him would cement Emily’s new chapter in Italy, aligning with the show’s shift toward exploring her growth beyond Paris. The chemistry between Emily and Marcello, described by Lily Collins as a “real spark” in interviews, has fueled speculation that he could be the father, offering a more stable and emotionally mature partnership compared to Gabriel’s chaotic history.
Social media platforms like Reddit and X have become battlegrounds for fans debating the paternity question. Some users speculate that the show might throw a curveball, with Alfie re-entering the picture despite his new relationship at the end of Season 4. Others wonder if the leak itself is a red herring, designed to mislead fans before a different twist is revealed. The absence of Camille, whose departure from the series was confirmed by actress Camille Razat in April 2025, has also shifted the narrative focus, leaving room for Emily’s pregnancy to take center stage as the primary romantic conflict.
Season 5’s production, which began in Rome in May 2025 and will move to Paris later in the summer, promises to blend the eternal allure of both cities. The show’s creator, Darren Star, has teased that Emily will maintain a presence in both Rome and Paris, suggesting a narrative that spans borders and cultures. This dual setting could complicate the pregnancy storyline, as Emily juggles her professional ambitions at Agence Grateau with personal decisions about her future. The addition of new cast member Minnie Driver as Princess Jane, a friend of Sylvie’s who married into royalty, hints at further high-society drama that could intersect with Emily’s predicament.
The leaked plot also raises questions about how Emily’s pregnancy will affect her character arc. Throughout the series, Emily has been portrayed as a work-driven optimist, often prioritizing her career over personal relationships. A baby could force her to confront new challenges, from balancing motherhood with her role as head of the Rome office to navigating co-parenting with either Gabriel or Marcello. Fans are eager to see whether the show will lean into a more mature exploration of Emily’s growth or maintain its lighthearted, escapist tone. Lily Collins has hinted at a desire for Emily to achieve a better work-life balance, suggesting that the pregnancy could be a pivotal moment for her to “smile without condition,” as she told Netflix’s Tudum.
The cultural backdrop of Rome and Paris adds another layer of intrigue. In Rome, Emily’s pregnancy could be framed against the city’s romantic and historical grandeur, with scenes at iconic landmarks like the Colosseum or Trevi Fountain amplifying the drama. In Paris, the return to familiar haunts like Place de l’Estrapade or Café de Flore could evoke nostalgia, especially if Gabriel is involved. The show’s signature aesthetic—vibrant outfits, luxurious settings, and Instagram-worthy moments—will likely elevate the pregnancy storyline, with Emily’s maternity style becoming a focal point for fashion enthusiasts.
While the leak has sparked excitement, it has also drawn criticism from some fans who fear the pregnancy trope risks echoing Season 4’s Camille storyline, where a false positive test created temporary drama. However, the departure of Camille and the introduction of Marcello as a new love interest suggest that the writers are aiming for a fresh take. The show’s ability to balance campy drama with heartfelt moments has kept it a global hit, with Season 4 ranking high on Netflix’s charts despite mixed critical reviews. Its 61-67% approval ratings on Rotten Tomatoes reflect its polarizing yet addictive appeal, and Season 5’s pregnancy plot could push the boundaries further.
As speculation mounts, the betting pools on social media show no signs of slowing down. Fans have created polls, memes, and fan fiction imagining scenarios where Gabriel storms into Rome to win Emily back or Marcello proposes a fairy-tale life in Italy. Some even hope for a twist where Emily chooses to raise the baby independently, embracing her strength as a single mother. The show’s history of cliffhangers—such as Camille and Gabriel’s failed wedding or Emily’s move to Rome—suggests that the paternity reveal will be drawn out, keeping viewers hooked until the finale.
With no official release date announced, though a late 2025 premiere is likely, Emily in Paris Season 5 is shaping up to be a rollercoaster of emotions. The leaked pregnancy plot has thrust Emily into uncharted territory, promising a season filled with heartbreak, hope, and haute couture. Whether Gabriel or Marcello emerges as the father, or an unexpected twist changes the game, one thing is certain: Emily Cooper’s journey is far from over, and fans will be glued to their screens to see where her heart—and her baby—will lead her next.
