If we were watching Shrek, she’d be Lord Farquaad’s daughter. That’s the joke fans can’t stop making about the upcoming Snow White remake, and it’s sending the internet into a frenzy. The controversy surrounding Disney’s live-action Snow White has been brewing for months, but a new wave of backlash erupted when images and clips from the movie surfaced online. Critics argue that the casting choice isn’t just unrealistic—it’s completely rewriting the essence of the original fairy tale.

The Shrek Comparison That Took Over Social Media

In DreamWorks’ Shrek, Lord Farquaad is a self-important, delusional ruler who believes he’s on the same level as a king, despite his actual status. His arrogance and insecurities make him a perfect comedic villain. Fans are now drawing parallels between him and the creative choices behind the new Snow White. The viral joke? “If we’re watching Shrek, she’d be Lord Farquaad’s daughter.”

This comparison, while humorous, reflects a deeper frustration among audiences. Just as Lord Farquaad overestimated his own position, many believe that Disney has overestimated its ability to completely redefine Snow White without considering the audience’s expectations.

“The Fairest of Them All?” Fans Say “At Least Make It Believable”

The heart of the debate lies in the fundamental premise of Snow White: she is described as “the fairest of them all.” This isn’t just a throwaway line—it’s the entire reason the Evil Queen sees her as a threat. Beauty, in this context, isn’t just about physical appearance but also a representation of innocence, kindness, and a classic fairy tale aesthetic.

The internet, however, is divided. Some fans argue that beauty standards are evolving and that the term “fairest” should be interpreted more broadly. Others insist that certain elements of a fairy tale should remain untouched, just as we wouldn’t expect Cinderella to ditch her glass slipper for sneakers in a modern retelling.

The comparison to Wonder Woman star Gal Gadot—who plays the Evil Queen in this adaptation—has only fueled the discussion. Viewers are asking: How can Snow White be more beautiful than the Evil Queen when Gal Gadot is right there? One viral comment summed it up:

At least make it believable. But the fact is, you’re watching Snow White, so dump.

Disney’s Risky Bet: Are Fans Ready for a Reimagined Snow White?

Disney has made bold choices with recent remakes, but some have been met with resistance. The Little Mermaid (2023), starring Halle Bailey, sparked debates over whether classic characters should be reimagined with modern casting choices. Now, Snow White is at the center of the same firestorm.

Rachel Zegler, who plays Snow White, has also made headlines for her comments about the original film. She’s been vocal about how outdated she finds the 1937 version, calling it problematic and emphasizing that the new Snow White will be independent, not a damsel in distress. But some fans feel that rather than paying homage to the beloved classic, Disney is outright dismissing what made it special in the first place.

What Does This Mean for Disney’s Future?

Hollywood is in a tricky place. Studios want to update classic stories for modern audiences, but they also risk alienating longtime fans who cherish these films for what they originally were. While diversity and inclusivity are important, many argue that storytelling integrity should remain intact.

The Snow White debate is about more than just casting—it’s about whether Hollywood is losing sight of what makes a story timeless. And if audience reactions to early glimpses of the film are anything to go by, Disney might have an uphill battle convincing fans that this is the Snow White they’ve been waiting for.

So, what do you think? Is this a refreshing take on an old classic, or is Disney missing the mark? Let us know in the comments!