Is Negan a Hero or Villain? Robert Kirkman Weighs In on The Walking Dead’s Most Controversial Character!

The Walking Dead #105 is a real eye-opener. Originally printed in 2012, it’s the first issue to go inside the Sanctuary, a former steel mill converted into a base for Negan’s Saviors. Just issues after bashing in Glenn’s brains with his barbed wire-wrapped baseball bat, a cordial Negan takes Carl Grimes on a tour of the Sanctuary and introduces the boy to his harem of lingerie-clad wives. Negan then forces Carl to remove the bandage covering his missing eye, makes him sing a song while menacing him with his bat Lucille, and has Carl watch as he maims an insubordinate Savior with a scalding hot iron.

It’s shown that Negan coerces women into being his “wives” rather than have them work for points to survive like the rest of the Saviors. “When I choose a new wife, the process is completely voluntary,” Negan explains. “It’s an honor to be with me, to no longer have to trade points to trade for goods and services. But it comes with a price: total devotion. And that can sometimes be a hard pill for others to swallow. But swallow it they must… or it’s the iron for you.”


 

When Negan’s “wife” Amber is caught with her former boyfriend Mark, he provokes Negan’s ire — and his iron.

Negan reminds Amber that her position is “completely voluntary,” telling the crying girl, “I don’t want anyone here if they don’t want to be.” But if Amber leaves him for Mark, Negan warns, “You’ll forfeit your privileges and go back to whatever job you had before Sherry brought you to us, but you can.”

What she can’t do, he screams, is cheat on him. “So what’s it going to be? You going back to Mark? Back to earning points? Working for your supper? Or are you staying?” A sobbing Amber is bullied into staying and Mark is scarred publicly to “forever bear the shame of his actions on his face.”

“I’d say more than anything else, at least on social media, the harem became one of the most controversial aspects of this comic,” Kirkman writes in the colorized reprint version of The Walking Dead Deluxe #105. “Even more than some of the upcoming bits with The Whisperers, which always surprised me. I certainly have a line I won’t cross. No pun intended.”

“You can look to Garth Ennis’ Crossed series to see a far more brutal and unforgiving exploration of the apocalypse,” Kirkman continued, referring to the comic that depicts graphic acts of stomach-turning depravity. “The Walking Dead is EXTREMELY tame by comparison, but that was by design. The harsh elements that did make it in, I always tried to make sure they were a reflection of life. I’d always argue no matter how dark things got in this series, you could always pick up a newspaper and read far more gruesome things happening for real.”

“The world is a dark place, and I didn’t want to shy away from portraying that for fear of offending anyone,” Kirkman concluded.

The Walking Dead Deluxe #105 is on sale now from Image Comics.

Related Posts

Chiefs’ Travis Kelce Prepares to Tackle the Big NFL Question—His Relationship with Taylor Swift!

Kansas City Chiefs’ star tight end Travis Kelce has long been a household name in the NFL, celebrated for his athletic prowess, charismatic personality, and clutch performances…

Taylor Swift’s Humanitarian Response to Texas Floods and $100 Million Funds Helps them to Get a New Life.

In the wake of the devastating floods that ravaged Texas in early 2025, pop superstar Taylor Swift emerged not only as a global music icon but also…

Travis Kelce Causes Turmoil After Firing Restaurant Staff Over Shocking Taylor Swift Incident.

In the heart of Kansas City, where the culinary scene thrives alongside the fervor of Chiefs fandom, a storm has been brewing at 1587 Prime, the upscale…

Brains, Laughs, and Chaos! — High Potential Season 2 Brings Morgan Gillory’s Genius Back to ABC! 🔍😜 Kaitlin Olson shines as Morgan, cracking cases and cracking jokes in LA’s toughest precinct. Expect bigger stakes, new faces, and a 2025 season that’ll steal your heart. 👇 One prodigy. Zero filter. The ultimate detective adventure begins.

Season 2 of High Potential is charging onto ABC with a promise of bigger cases, wilder schemes, and a deeper dive into the chaotic, brilliant life of…

Taylor Swift Congratulates Jason Kelce and Wife on First Son After Three Daughters, Massive Gift Reveals a Secret.

In a heartwarming moment that has captured the attention of fans worldwide, global pop superstar Taylor Swift has extended her congratulations to former NFL star Jason Kelce…

Now on Netflix: The Magnolias Are Blooming Again — With Stakes Higher Than Ever! 🍹 Sweet Magnolias Season 5 reunites Maddie, Helen, and Dana Sue for another heartfelt chapter in Serenity’s story. With New York dreams, a dreamy wedding, and young love tested, this season is 2026’s must-watch comfort drama. 👇 One margarita night. Three fearless women. Endless heartwarming twists.

The quaint, sun-dappled town of Serenity, South Carolina, is gearing up for another chapter of heartfelt drama, enduring friendships, and small-town charm. Sweet Magnolias, Netflix’s beloved “comfort…