Star Wars Improves On Sci-Fi Epic It Steals From

star wars dune
With the success of Dune: Part Two has come a new generation of would-be intellectuals who can’t wait to let everyone know, “This George Lucas guy stole like, everything from Frank Herbert!” The implication being that Star Wars is nothing but kiddie fluff compared to the serious sci-fi classic Dune. What no one wants to admit though is that Star Wars actually improved upon Dune—in many ways.

Luke Skywalker Is Much More Relatable Than Paul Atreides

lisan al gaib
To say that the book Dune is as elitist as its fans would be mean but sadly accurate. Frank Herbert’s books deal with people in power, Dukes, Barons, Reverend Mothers, etc. Paul Atriedes starts out as royalty and becomes a God, basically. Not super relatable.

Meanwhile, Luke Skywalker starts out as a nobody, a blue-collar farm boy on a planet nobody cares about. By the end of A New Hope, he’s a hero of the Rebellion, and that’s about it. He doesn’t become royalty or get people kissing his feet or anything.

Dune Deals In Abstractions, While Star Wars Shows The Actual Hardships

star wars star trek
Where Star Wars doesn’t hesitate to show us the actual people affected by the Empire’s tyrannical reign, Dune is content to use the masses as something the people in power are fighting over, a statistic or a commodity rather than real flesh-and-blood people. Star Wars is full of broken-down machinery, people breaking the law just to survive, and the grime and grit indicative of a galaxy in decay.

It has just as much to say about power and corruption, but it says it in a much more relatable way.

There’s Nothing Wrong With Simplicity


Relatable and, yes, simple, but is that inherently bad? Star Wars opts to go with the classic Good Guys vs. Bad Guys narrative, whereas Dune wants us to know that the Harkonnens are bad, and so is Paul, and so are the Bene Gesserit, and on and on. Anyone living in the real-world already knows that everybody sucks, do we need a book to tell us?

Star Wars, on the other hand, is a fairytale. It takes Dune’s evil empire and gives us an opposing force to root for. You don’t have to worry about Luke’s power going to his head and causing him to lead a holy war that will result in billions of lost lives. Is the GigaChad Rebellion taking on the Incel Empire a dumbed-down, black-and-white narrative compared to Dune’s complex political message? Yeah, and it’s more effective, too.

If you want more complexity, there are always the prequels with their trade wars and the fall of the Jedi. Even there, however, good guys and bad guys exist. That’s because Star Wars celebrates heroes, whereas Dune warns against them.

The Lovable Dork Hides Heavy Themes

Return of the Jedi
Don’t get us wrong, hero worship can become unhealthy—the cult of personality and whatnot. However, what George Lucas knew was that if you want to get your message across, you have to give the audience a relatable protagonist or a “hero” to follow on their cinematic journey. Luke Skywalker wastes time with his friends, drives a floating hotrod, and whines like a typical teenager. Kids relate to Luke in a way that they never could with Paul.

Luke Skywalker is so likable that by the time Lucas has him fully radicalized and part of a left-wing terrorist cell, we’re still rooting for him. When Luke Skywalker goes all ACAB and blows up the biggest police station in the galaxy, we cheer and clap. What true Star Wars fans know and Dune fans fail to realize is that Star Wars had some pretty heavy themes hidden behind the cool pew-pew lasers and the lovable dork main character.

Also… Lightsabers

liam neeson
So yes, Star Wars did lift a bunch of stuff from Dune, but it arguably used those elements to tell a better, more relatable story. Oh, and it gave us lightsabers. The only cool tech Dune had was a suit that recycles your waste into water for you to drink. Lightsabers FTW!

Related Posts

The Kelly Clarkson Show Season 7 Premiere Set to Ignite with Star-Studded Lineup and a Secret Surprise

The Kelly Clarkson Show is gearing up to return with a bang for its seventh season, officially set to premiere on Monday, September 29, 2025, on NBC….

The Voice Season 28 Introduces Groundbreaking Rule: Carson Daly Joins Coaches in Shaping Contestants’ Fate

In a historic shake-up for The Voice, the iconic singing competition is set to roll out a game-changing rule for its 28th season, premiering on September 22,…

Taylor Swift Playfully Scolds Travis and Jason Kelce in Front of NFL Team, Proving She’s the “Roof” of the House

On August 30, 2025, Taylor Swift, the global pop superstar, showcased her commanding presence and playful authority as the soon-to-be wife of Kansas City Chiefs tight end…

🚨🤯 The Western Legend May Ride Again! Whispers of a Longmire Revival Grow Louder as Warner Bros. Holds the Reins, Cast Rumors Swirl, and Fans Brace for What Could Be the Biggest Surprise in Modern TV History 🤠💥

When Longmire vanished from Netflix on January 1, 2025, after a decade-long streaming run, fans mourned the loss of the neo-Western crime drama that had captured hearts…

Lauren Alaina Faces Mom-Shaming Over Breastfeeding Choices for Baby Beni Doll, Fires Back at Critics with Grace and Grit

In a raw and relatable moment, American Idol alum and country music star Lauren Alaina took to social media on July 7, 2025, to address the wave…

Luke Bryan’s Family Celebrates New Addition as Niece Welcomes Baby Boy, First Photos Revealed

In a heartwarming moment for the Bryan family, country music superstar Luke Bryan became a great-uncle again on January 21, 2025, when his niece Kris Cheshire welcomed…