“She doesn’t know what to believe”: Does O.J. Simpson’s Daughter Believe Her Father Was Guilty of Murdering Nicole Brown? – Here’s What We Know

What did O.J. Simpson’s children think of their father as being the prime suspect in their mother’s murder?

She doesn’t know what to believe”: Does O.J. Simpson’s Daughter Believe Her Father Was Guilty of Murdering Nicole Brown? – Here’s What We Know

O.J. Simpson was on trial for one of the most sensational cases of the last century. The former NFL star was accused of a double homicide, and in a remarkable turn of events, he walked away a free man.

The trial became highly publicized, and it divided the general masses, with many believing that Simpson was guilty. While public opinion could have been easily swayed, what did his children really think about the trial at the time, and in the years since?
OJ SimpsonO.J. Simpson was accused of a double homicide (Source: Wikimedia Commons)

What do O.J. Simpson’s children with his ex-wife think about his case?

O.J. Simpson rose to prominence as one of the greatest running backs of all time, and he spent 11 years in the NFL with the Buffalo Bills. He enjoyed a lot of success during his stint in the NFL. Unfortunately, his life took a very different turn, and Simpson became a household name for a very different reason.

In 1994, the NFL player was accused of a double homicide. He was the prime suspect in the murders of his ex-wife, Nicole Brown Simpson, and their friend, Ronald Goldman. The case riveted the nation from the very beginning, with the police trying to apprehend him after a car chase that was televised live to the public. The trial ended with Simpson walking away with a non-guilty verdict.

Nicole Brown Simpson and her friend were stabbed to death outside her house in Brentwood. The killings sent shockwaves throughout the nation due to their sheer brutality. Simpson had two children with her: Sydney and Justin, but what did they think of their father being charged with murder?
OJ SimpsonO.J. Simpson’s children with his ex-wife reveal what they thought (Source: Wikimedia Commons)
At the time of the crime, Sydney was 8, and Justin was 5. Bossip had reported that Sydney thought her father was guilty. However, her ex-boyfriend, Stuart Alexander Lee, gave a different version to Radar.

They speculate that it was a drug deal gone bad. May she rest in peace, but [Nicole’s] throat was cut like a Colombian necktie. Sydney doesn’t believe O.J. did it, but she doesn’t know what to believe. The media changes, and how the police changed the whole situation … Either way, her mother died,” he said.

It is not easy to talk about one’s own mother’s murder, and it is the same for Simpson’s children too. Regardless, Sydney and Justin loved their father, who died of prostate cancer recently.

O.J. Simpson also had support during the trial

The Buffalo Bills star had two children, Jason and Arnelle, from his first marriage to Marguerite. The couple had another child who drowned in the pool in 1979, the year they parted ways.

Jason did not speak up much during or after the trial, even though he showed up at the courthouse a few times. Arnelle, however, was Simpson’s rock, as she supported her father throughout the process. She even testified in court, recalling how distraught he was after Nicole Brown Simpson died.
OJ SimpsonO.J. Simpson found support too (Source: Wikimedia Commons)
Even his first wife, Marguerite, believed in his innocence. Jet Magazine reported that she did not think her husband had anything to do with the murders.

O.J. Simpson’s trial was hailed as the ‘trial of the Century’ and it even saw the Kardashian family get involved. Moreover, as he was acquitted of all charges, Simpson’s case shed light on how race played a role in criminal procedures.

Related Posts

That duet between Kelly Clarkson and Teddy Swims? Unreal.

On a crisp October evening in 2025, the stage at Nashville’s Bridgestone Arena was ablaze with anticipation for the annual “Music City Nights” concert, a star-studded event…

The night Texas fell silent. On a glowing stage, Blake Shelton joined hands with his hero Randy Travis, igniting cheers from 20,000 fans.

On a warm September night in 2025, under the vast Texas sky at Austin’s Darrell K Royal-Texas-Memorial Stadium, the air was thick with anticipation. The occasion was…

A Little Girl Writes a Letter to Her Favorite Singer—Then Blake Shelton Shows Up at Her Birthday Party!

In a small, sun-dappled town in rural Oklahoma, where the horizon stretches endlessly across fields of wheat and the community gathers at the local diner for gossip…

Pete Hegseth’s Stunning Response to Dying Boy’s Wish Leaves Family in Tears!

A Final Wish, A Lasting Gift The hospital room was quiet that evening, the rhythmic beeping of machines the only sound that filled the sterile air. A…

Millionaire Family Refused to Shake Blake Shelton’s Hand — His Next Move Cost Them $1B

In the glittering world of high-stakes business and celebrity crossovers, where fortunes are made and lost in boardrooms and gala ballrooms alike, a single gesture—or lack thereof—can…

Waiter Laughed at Blake Shelton’s “Cheap Shoes”—Seconds Later, the Room Went Silent

In the heart of Nashville, Tennessee, where the neon lights of honky-tonks flicker against the night sky and the air hums with the twang of country guitars,…