Sweet Magnolias Shocks Fans with Isaac’s Love Story in Season 5: Why the Writers Made Fans Wait This Long

Sweet Magnolias' Season 4 Finale Ending Explained, Season 5 Spoilers

Valentine’s Day may not be one of the major holidays celebrated in Sweet Magnolias Season 4, but everyone in Serenity is still feeling the love — including one character for the very first time.

If you’ve made your way through most of the season by now, you know that we’re talking about Isaac (Chris Medlin), who finally gets some romance in his life, courtesy of an old college frenemy named Michael (Kyle Findley). He comes to Serenity in Episode 8 to assess the damage caused by the hurricane, and his interest in Isaac is obvious from the moment they cross paths — even if it takes the adorably clueless couple until the end of the season before they finally share their first kiss.

Showrunner Sheryl J. Anderson explains that Isaac’s relationship with Michael is all part of the character finally coming into his own after three seasons of not feeling like he belonged.

“It had been our thought in the writers’ room that Isaac wasn’t ready for a relationship because he was still figuring out who he was and how he fits into the tapestry of Serenity,” Anderson tells TVLine. “Even though [his paternity] came out in a different way than he would have preferred, once everybody worked through the revelation about Bill, we thought, OK, now he knows who he is. More importantly, he knows that everybody loves him. It was not the cataclysmic event he was afraid it would be.”

Sweet Magnolias Season 4 Isaac's Boyfriend Michael Kyle Findley

Anderson jokingly refers to this relationship as Isaac’s “reward” for everything he’s gone through. “He gets to have the rom-com arc in the second half of the season,” she says. “It’s not the full-on enemies to lovers trope, but we thought it was be fun to have somebody unexpected come into his life when he hadn’t even started to think about romance.”

Isaac and Michael’s relationship is also a bonus for the show’s LGBTQ+ fans, as it marks the first same-sex love story (with all due respect to Trotter and his husband Ashley, of course).

“It is very important to us that everyone be able to see themselves in Serenity,” Anderson says.

Are you glad that Sweet Magnolias is finally taking it easy on Isaac, letting him be — dare we say it — happy? Grade Season 4 of Netflix’s feel-good hit below, then drop a comment with your thoughts on life in Serenity.

Related Posts

Who’s Taken and Who’s Single? Get the Inside Scoop on the Sweet Magnolias Cast’s Real-Life Love Lives

From JoAnna Garcia Swisher to Jamie Lynn Spears, learn more about the cast’s significant others as the show returns to Netflix for season 4 on Feb. 6Sweet…

Family is family forever: Princes William and Harry kick Queen Camilla out of palace amid evidence linking Diana!

Queen Camilla and Prince William are leading the monarchy as King Charles and Kate Middleton battle cancer, but experts think Prince Harry is in California fuming over William and Camilla’s relationship.Source: MEGAQueen Camilla and Prince William are…

Did Netflix Just Waste a Golden Opportunity? The New Witcher Movie Fails to Recreate One of Henry Cavill’s Best Scenes! (Full story—link in comments!)

Warning: Minor spoilers ahead for The Witcher: Sirens of the Deep.The Witcher: Sirens of the Deep returns viewers to the Continent ahead of The Witcher season 4, but the anime…

Henry Cavill’s Next Superhero Role Revealed?! Could He Be Swapping Superman for Marvel’s Nova?

Henry Cavill is rumoured to join the Marvel Cinematic Universe, potentially starring in the upcoming Nova show, sparking excitement among fans. Here is you need to know:…

Is Henry Cavill Leaving DC Behind? Shocking Reports Say He Might Join the MCU Next!

Henry Cavill reportedly stars in Marvel Cinematic Universe’s upcoming show, Nova. Check out this article for more. If you’re a Henry Cavill fan, you might be intrigued…

After the shocking ending of season 4, JoAnna Garcia Swisher reveals what’s next for Sweet Magnolias season 5

Last week brought a welcome treat for anyone with a Netflix subscription who adores romance, as fans were finally able to enjoy Sweet Magnolias Season 4 during the 2025 TV schedule….