As The Summer I Turned Pretty fans found themselves caught between Team Conrad or Team Jeremiah, the cast of the hit Prime Video series has had sparks flying off screen in their own love lives.

After the show debuted in June 2022, viewers quickly fell in love with Belly’s (Lola Tung) adventures in Cousins Beach and her love triangle with brothers Jeremiah (Gavin Casalegno) and Conrad (Christopher Briney). Casalegno surprised fans when he announced his nuptials to Cheyanne King.

“FOREVER CAPTIVATED BY YOU🕊️,” Casalegno captioned several Instagram photos in November 2024 while tagging Cheyanne, who changed her Instagram handle to reflect her married name.

Casalegno’s costar Briney, however, has kept his romance with Isabela Rose Machado more low-key so far. In June 2022, Machado showed her support for her boyfriend by walking the red carpet with him at The Summer I Turned Pretty premiere in New York City.

Based on her social media, Tung is keeping her dating life quiet. After scoring the lead role of Belly, the New York native took a year off from Carnegie Mellon College to film the series — and has documented the experience on her Instagram.

Briney is currently in a relationship with Machado. The duo, who both attended Pace University, made their romance Instagram official in 2018.

The Vampire Diaries alum dated Larsen Thompson for over six years before their 2022 split. He exchanged vows with King two years later.

Kaufman, who isn’t a big fan of social media, has kept his romantic life private so far.

The model has also chosen not to share much about her offscreen love life. Her followers, however, have questioned if Mills is dating her costar David Iacono.

Iacono hasn’t shared much about his love life on social media. Instead, he has used the platform to post photos from his time on The Summer I Turned Pretty set.

The actress, who brought Nicole to life, is not currently linked to anyone.

Like several of her costars, Spencer has chosen not to share much about her dating life online. Instead, she has offered a glimpse at some of her other projects outside of The Summer I Turned Pretty.

The Grey’s Anatomy alum shares two kids with husband Louis Ozawa. Chung has also dedicated her social media to sharing photos of their dog Atticus.

Blanchard, who portrayed Susannah, is marred to Jeremy Turner.