Controversial Theory: Josh Brolin Says Thanos Is Responsible For MCU’s Boring Phase 4?

Thanos was a bit more merciful than what the people give him credit for!

When Marvel wanted to cast an actor for the role of Thanos, Josh Brolin became the go-to guy for the role of the Mad Titan. Portraying a brilliant character throughout the MCU, Brolin’s Thanos literally became inevitable and wreaked havoc for the Avengers.

Following his death in Avengers: Endgame, Phase 3 of the Marvel Cinematic Universe came to an end. And with that, Phase 4 continued carrying on the story of the remaining heroes but it was kind of dull. An interesting theory proves why Phase 4 and 5 feel a bit dull and it’s all connected to the mercy of Thanos!
MCUJosh Brolin’s Thanos in Avengers: Endgame

Josh Brolin’s Thanos Was More Merciful Than People Thought!

The first line of defense in favor of Thanos has become a pretty common point now. Wanting to erase half of the universe so that the other half could live peacefully, Thanos essentially chose the lesser evil (as Geralt said in The Witcher).
Josh Brolin's Thanos was actually more merciful than what people thoughtJosh Brolin’s Thanos was actually more merciful than what people thought
Although his point was valid, erasing half of the universe was generally considered a bad idea. After Thanos completed his plan, he retired and went to farming and living a peaceful life until the Avengers found and killed him. Going back in the past and fixing things, Thanos was erased once and for all and the world went back to a somewhat normal state.

With Phase 4 arriving, the MCU projects were a bit dull and not as great as Phase 3 of the Universe. This brilliant theory might just answer the question of why. Josh Brolin as Thanos, being a merciful titan (with exceptions, of course) did not want people to suffer. When Doctor Strange sat down to look at the possibilities of the Avengers bringing the people back, only one worked.
“It was a shitty f*cking movie”: Josh Brolin Will Never Stop Sh*tting on the Flop DC Movie He Made Before His MCU Fame as Thanos

This fan theory on Reddit states that Thanos also saw the future and saw nothing but suffering and death for the superheroes. With the Infinity Gauntlet having its own mind of who lives and dies, the random killing of superheroes wasn’t so random and there was a very specific reason behind it.

Thanos Did Not Want The People To Suffer

ThanosThanos
As the theory further continues, it is alleged that the Mad Titan saw the future and saw suffering. For example, MJ forgot Peter Parker. Since Thanos already knew that this future was going to happen, he tried to wipe out half the universe but chose the Avengers who had a bit more “dull” life compared to the other superheroes.

Opting to spare them the pain of their future, Thanos wiped out half of the universe but the killings weren’t so random after all. This is the reason, Phase 4 felt a little bit duller compared to the rest of the MCU. This theory does not have proper proof but it does set within the Mad Titan’s persona and character while another theory states his potential return! Although this theory does give Thanos a bit more emotional and merciful side, in the end, it remains a theory.

Related Posts

🔥💥 Taylor Sheridan Strikes Again: “The Last Immortal” Leaves Prime Video for Netflix — Instantly Becomes #1 in 91 Countries, Outselling Stranger Things & Wednesday, and Delivering a Finale Twist That Leaves Viewers Silent for Hours 😱🎬

Deep in the frozen heart of the Wind River Indian Reservation, where the snow falls so thick it swallows sound and the temperature drops low enough to…

Maxton Hall’s Shocking S3 Bombshell: Ruby’s Oxford Dream Explodes in Ultimate Scandal – James Betrayed Forever? The Jaw-Dropping Twist Set to Premiere March 17, 2026! 😱

In the glittering yet treacherous halls of elite academia, where privilege clashes with ambition, Maxton Hall – The World Between Us has captivated global audiences with its…

😱 HEARTLAND FANS, BRACE YOURSELVES—Nathan SHOT DEAD in Season 19 Bloodbath! Cops Snag the Killer, But the REAL Monster? His OWN Sister Gracie’s Fatal Secret! 💔🔫

In the sprawling prairies of Alberta, where family bonds and wild horses define the rhythm of life, the beloved long-running series Heartland has unleashed its most devastating…

SHATTERED HEARTS & FORBIDDEN SECRETS EXPLODE: Is Noah’s Oxford Dream About to CRASH Nick’s Empire in the Most TWISTED Twist Yet?! Prime Video’s ‘Your Fault: London 2’ Trailer Drops Like a Heartbreak Bomb – Betrayal, Boardroom Steam, and a Cliffhanger So Savage It’ll Have You Rage-Binging the Spanish Originals All Over Again.

You survived the step-sibling inferno of My Fault: London back in February 2025, didn’t you? That glossy gut-punch of a Prime Video premiere, where Noah Scott (Asha…

Heartland S19E10 Trailer Bombshell: Amy’s Tear-Jerking Twist Spells Early Grave—Nathan’s Deadly Case Leaves Him Doomed Alone! Fans in Floods of Tears! 😢💔

In the windswept prairies of Alberta, where the Heartland ranch has long stood as a beacon of resilience and redemption, fans of the beloved CBC drama Heartland…

Silk Curtains Shredded: Old Money S2 Trailer Unleashes Buried Heirlooms, Blood Betrayals, and a Shocking Star Exit That’ll Leave Fans Reeling!

The opulent world of Istanbul’s high society is about to crack wide open. Netflix’s breakout Turkish drama Old Money—the tale of clashing fortunes where self-made grit collides…