“Carly was easily the worst MCU villain ever”: Anthony Mackie’s Captain America Owns the Worst Dialogue of MCU, According to Fans

One specific line is being called one of the worst from the entire MCU and unfortunately for Anthony Mackie, it is from Falcon and the Winter Soldier.

Hypocrisy can often be inevitable when projects are being made. This is especially true when it comes to the MCU, which is known for having some extremely complicated and confusing plot lines that can span over the years. Anthony Mackie’s The Falcon and the Winter Soldier was beloved for several reasons. The series was quite grounded in comparison to the cosmic threats of Loki and WandaVision.

Anthony Mackie as Captain America in The Falcon and the Winter Soldier | Marvel EntertainmentAnthony Mackie as Captain America in The Falcon and the Winter Soldier | Marvel Entertainment

Despite this, it managed to answer two of the most important questions of the franchise; What will happen to Captain America and the Winter Soldier? Although fans got the answers they wanted and understood the fates of these two characters and titles, this does not mean that the show was a perfect piece of media from Marvel.

There is one distinctive scene from the series in the finale that went against everything that the show tried to establish in the rest of its episodes. Fans have taken note, and they cannot help but call it one of the worst lines from the entire franchise.

Anthony Mackie Did Not Make Much Sense In The Falcon and the Winter Soldier Finale

A fan posted a video on YouTube that showcased a moment in The Falcon and the Winter Soldier that had many scratching their heads. Near the end of the series, after Anthony Mackie had put on his Captain America suit, he confronted those who made the decisions that led to the Flag Smashers being formed. Why they called Karli Morgenthau and her group “terrorists,” Sam Wilson was quick to correct them.

Anthony MackieAnthony Mackie and Sebastian Stan in Falcon and the Winter Soldier | Marvel Entertainment

He mentioned that they needed to stop calling Morgenthau’s team terrorists as the things that they were doing were a product of the decision made by those present in Wilson’s company. While many could understand what Mackie’s character was trying to say, the creator of the video could not help but be critical of the meaning behind it.

The actions and crimes committed by Morgenthau’s group could easily be used to describe what terrorism actually is.

Fans Continue To Scratch Their Heads

While some would think only one person could hold such a belief, the comments on the video said otherwise. Many pointed out how Anthony Mackie’s character simply told the senators to do better with their terminology and laws without giving them a way that they could actually bring about change.

Erin Kellyman as Karli Morgenthau | Marvel Entertainment

Point out that they were also out of their depths with what Thanos did, some fans mentioned how the senators were also trying their best to do the right thing.

“Wanda: enslaves an entire town full of people including kids. MCU: she’s misunderstood Karli: uses violence against innocents to carry out her political plans ( literal definition of terrorism) MCU: she’s not a terrorist Walker: killed a terrorist who participated in murder of his best friend. MCU: he’s a bad guy.” mentioned sanalk1444 on YouTube.

““You gotta stop calling them terrorists.” LITERALLY MEETS THE LEGAL DEFINITION OF TERRORISM” added JONPIAASU98.

“Karli was easily the worst MCU villain ever.” stevetrail2307 stated. 

“Sam: You gotta do better, senator. Senator: How do we do better? Sam: idk do better.” said Bully_who_made_goblin_Jr_cry.

What’s worse is that the show actually did a pretty decent job at presenting how they’d started as genuine activists but strayed into terrorism, but not acknowledging that they became terrorists who caused destruction is what ruined it.” added HUMAN-fq5ff.

Others pointed out that hypocrisy is Marvel’s definition of right and wrong. They think that calling Wanda Maximoff and Karli Morgenthau “misunderstood” and then portraying John Walker as the bad guy does not show any consistency. Since Karli was involved in killing innocents for the sake of “sending a message,” fans believe her actions to be the textbook definition of terrorism.

Wyatt Russell John WalkerWyatt Russell as John Walker in The Falcon and the Winter Soldier | Marvel Entertainment

With this in mind, Wilson’s line simply feels off to fans. Additionally, the bland motivations made many label Karlie one of the worst villains from the MCU.

The Falcon and the Winter Soldier is available for streaming on Disney+.

Related Posts

🧩⚠️ More questions than answers: Why do investigators believe there may have been more people on the boat before the uncle and nephew vanished in the Gulf of Mexico?

In the serene yet unforgiving waters of the Gulf of Mexico, a routine fishing trip turned into one of Florida’s most heartbreaking and perplexing disappearances of 2025….

💔✈️ Tearful Airport Goodbyes, Unfinished Feelings With Min Ho, and a Past That Won’t Stay Buried: XO, Kitty Season 3 Trailer Has Fans Spiraling

XO, Kitty fans, brace yourselves—because the just-dropped official trailer for XO, Kitty Season 3 (coming to Netflix in 2026) is an emotional tsunami that no one saw…

🔥😱 Walter Boys Fans Are Losing It: Alleged Season 3 Trailer Leak Teases Jackie Leaving, a New Man, and Total Heartbreak

Buckle up, Walter Boys nation—because the internet just exploded with what appears to be a leaked official trailer for My Life with the Walter Boys Season 3,…

Emily in Paris Season 6 Whispers Ignite Fan Frenzy: Greek Isles Romance, Shattered Engagements, and Gabriel’s Yacht Beckons After Jaw-Dropping Cliffhanger!

The Netflix sensation “Emily in Paris” has fans in a tizzy with swirling rumors of a sixth season, fueled by the explosive Season 5 finale that left…

Explosive First Looks Drop: Dave Bautista & Jason Momoa as Feuding Brothers in ‘The Wrecking Crew’ – Unraveling a Murderous Conspiracy on Prime Video!

In a thrilling reveal that’s got action fans buzzing, Amazon Prime Video has unveiled the first official images from “The Wrecking Crew,” the high-octane buddy action-comedy starring…

Your Fault: London Season 2 Ignites with Ruthless Betrayals – Nick & Noah’s Love Teeters on the Edge in Oxford’s Shadowy Elite!

Prime Video’s steamy romantic drama “Your Fault: London” is ramping up the intensity with its highly anticipated Season 2, set to premiere in early 2026. Building on…