“All he does is heckle Tom’s Spider-Man with minor insults”: Andrew Garfield’s Spider-Man Solved a Problem That Fans Hated in Both Tobey Maguire and Tom Holland’s Franchise

The Amazing Spider-Man showcased Flash Thompson at his best!

andrew garfield’s spider-man, tobey maguire and tom holland

Spider-Man is one of the most popular superhero characters that we have loved watching while growing up. The character has a ton of adaptations, from animated series to live-action films, each representing their own iterations of Peter Parker and the Web-Head.

The Amazing Spider-Man has one of lowest IMDb ratings in the IMDb franchise

Although the portrayals of Tobey Maguire and Tom Holland are considered to be fan favorites, both versions featured a major flaw in the film. While Andrew Garfield’s stint was considered to be the worst among the three versions, The Amazing Spider-Man solved a problem that neither of the two versions of the film could solve.

Well, in both films, the character of Flash Thompson was wrongly showcased. Hence, fans of the superhero were not delighted because of the variation, which wrongly portrayed the side character.

Andrew Garfield’s The Amazing Spider-Man Solved an Issue That Other Versions of The Character Couldn’t Solve

All three cinematic versions of Spider-Man showcase different interpretations of Peter Parker’s bully, Flash Thompson. In Sam Raimi’s version of the film, the character is showcased as a young adult who is always ready to throw hands at Parker.

Sam Raimi's Spider-Man had the worst portrayal of Flassh Thompson

The rendition could not be any more wrong because the character was showcased as a character full of brute strength and arrogance, making the lives of other teenagers a hell. However, the character was not perfect because it only focused on the physicality of the character, making him poorly written.

Tom Holland’s franchise noticed this issue, and they tried to modernize the character by adding their own twist to it. In Holland’s series, the character is drastically different from Sam Raimi’s version, as he is also another teenager.

Tony Revolori's Flash Thompson was much like a comic relief in the film

However, he is not any better because he torments Peter Parker through his quirky insults, showcasing the change in the dynamics of bullying in the current high school setting. Nevertheless, the writers thought of adding depth to the character by showcasing vulnerability and insecurities that compelled him to get attention, which led to bullying Parker and other students.

Both iterations of the high school bully were significantly different, undergoing a massive change. However, in Andrew Garfield’s The Amazing Spider-Man, he is written in a much more complex manner. While he was the typical bully, he showcased remorse and sympathy for our protagonist after Uncle Ben was murdered.

Flash THompson's character was perfect in the franchise

However, that’s not all, because in Sam Raimi’s version, Thompson was a one-dimensional, low-key villain; in Holland’s version, he was nothing but a comic relief in the film. Garfield’s franchise decided to enhance their storyline by modernizing the high school setting and by giving people a second chance to change.

Hence, a major problem was solved that allowed Flash Thompson to redeem himself for his actions. This idea was quite thoughtful because it not only allowed room for character growth but also shed light on the complex human relationships that Peter Parker has built over the years.

Fans Are Tired of Watching a Disappointing Portrayal of Flash Thompson in The Spider-Man Franchise

While the three versions of the film decided to showcase their own versions of Flash Thompson, which were perfect according to the settings of the film, fans are debating on social media which iteration of the character was the worst.

An Instagram page uploaded a reel where they showcased that the character has downgraded over the years, and fans of the three franchises shared their opinions in the comment section of the post.

@jesse_souza_1 commented, “The best version of flash has to be from amazing spider man”

@enriquetheblack commented, “This Flash looks like he could be fold by a 10 year old”

@frmitch1 commented, “Chad that’s actually what high school students look like. Not 40-year-olds who got held back 10 times”

@exile976 commented, “He’s not even a bully. All he does is heckle Tom’s Spiderman with some minor insults.”

@savon_thesaint commented, “He got updated this generation dont got the average bully we got wannabe thugs, online trolls and people that talk alot of shi”

While fans had different opinions, some agreed that the Hacksaw Ridge actor’s franchise had the perfect portrayal of the high school bully, but that it could not get any more perfect and was misrepresented in the other two franchises.

The Amazing Spider-Man can be streamed on Netflix.

Related Posts

The wait is over. 🦴 Booth & Brennan are back — and this time, the bones tell a new story. Don’t blink. Bones: Resurrection premieres soon — are you ready? 👀

The Jeffersonian Institute’s lab has always been a place where bones tell stories—secrets etched in calcium, murders whispered through fractures, histories pieced together from the dust of…

Blood. Betrayal. Redemption Turned to Ruin. 💥 The Pitt – Season 2 Drags Robby Into His Darkest Hour — Where Every Ally Lies

The fluorescent lights of Allegheny General Hospital flicker like a dying heartbeat. When The Pitt returns for its sophomore season on January 15, 2026, the ER that…

ROMAN RUCKUS ALERT: Emily’s Steamy Italian Fling in Season 5 Could TORCH Her Paris Dreams Forever—But One Couture Catastrophe Might Just Stitch It All Back Together in the Most Chaotic Glow-Up Yet!

The Eiffel Tower might be twinkling, but all eyes are on the Eternal City this holiday season. Netflix’s guilty pleasure extraordinaire, Emily in Paris, jets back into…

A Jewish Girl Hiding Under a False Name Falls for the Son of a Nazi Hunter 💞 My Name Is Sara – Season 2 Is a Forbidden Love That Could Cost Both Their Lives.

In the shadowed annals of World War II cinema, where tales of heroism and horror intertwine like barbed wire, “My Name Is Sara” (2019) emerges as a…

BABY POGUE BOMBSHELL: Real-Life Tots Spotted on Outer Banks Season 5 Set—Is Sarah & John B’s Tiny Treasure Already Here, or Just a Heart-Melting Tease for the Pogues’ Wildest Adventure Yet?

The salty breezes of the Outer Banks are about to carry more than just treasure hunts and teen drama—they’re whispering the pitter-patter of tiny feet. As filming…

One Secret Could Cost Her Life… My Name Is Sara Is the Heart-Stopping True Story of a Jewish Girl Hiding Her Identity to Survive the Holocaust.

In the annals of cinema, few stories grip the soul quite like those born from the ashes of history’s darkest chapters. “My Name Is Sara” (2019), directed…