The Boys’ Creator Aims for Jared Padalecki Reunion in Season 5: ‘I Must Complete My “Supernatural” Pokémon Collection

The Boys/Supernatural

Eric Kripke is gonna catch ’em all. “The Boys” showrunner has slowly but surely been casting the stars of the iconic CW series “Supernatural,” which Kripke created, on his R-rated Amazon Prime Video superhero drama. And he’s got one “very big one” he’s eyeing to bring on in Season 5, even if it’s for “a single episode” — Jared Padalecki, a.k.a. Sam Winchester.

“He’s been busy the last few years, so schedules haven’t worked out,” Kripke told Variety in an interview Thursday, referring to Padalecki’s starring role on the CW’s “Walker,” which was canceled earlier this week after four seasons. Padalecki starred alongside Jensen Ackles on the CW’s “Supernatural” for 15 seasons, from its debut on what was then the WB in 2005 through its series finale in 2020.

But now, unfortunately, [‘Walker’] got canceled — but the good thing is he’s free,” Kripke said. “And I feel like I have to complete my game of ‘Supernatural’ Pokémon and I have my one big one — very big one — left to catch.”

Popular on Variety

So far, there has been a coterie of “Supernatural” grads who have appeared in guest-starring or recurring roles on “The Boys,” which has been picked up for Season 5 — even before its fourth season premieres on June 13. Jensen Ackles (who played Sam’s brother Dean Winchester on “Supernatural”) appeared as Soldier Boy, and Jim Beaver as Robert Singer (who was Bobby Singer on “Supernatural”). And in Season 4, Jeffrey Dean Morgan (John Winchester, Sam and Dean’s father) joins the cast in a mystery role, and Rob Benedict (the prophet Chuck) will play supe Splinter.

Kripke was speaking with Variety ahead of “The Boys” Season 4 premiere, in an interview alongside “The Boys” actors Colby Minifie (Ashley Barrett) and series newcomers Susan Heyward (Sister Sage) and Valorie Curry (Firecracker) — who were all very on board with the Padalecki casting conversation.

“As a childhood fan of ‘Gilmore Girls,’ I would also vote for that,” Minifie said, referencing Padalecki’s role as Rory (Alexis Bledel’s) first boyfriend Dean on another iconic CW show. “That would be great.”

Curry added: “Same! Same! Second that.”

“OK, all right, the crowd has spoken!” Kripke declared, which hopefully seals the deal for Padalecki.

Related Posts

Chiefs’ Empire Crumbles: Reid’s Fiery Ultimatum Exposes Offense Woes, Defensive Brain Drain Looms, and Mahomes’ Shadow Mentor Plots Shock Arrowhead Return!

Shattered Glass, Shattered Hearts: Maxton Hall Season 2 Episode 4’s Gut-Wrenching Opener That Left Fans Sobbing – Is This the End for James and Ruby?

The clock strikes midnight in the opulent halls of Maxton Hall, but on November 14, 2025, Prime Video’s servers might as well have been ground zero for…

Wednesday Season 3 CONFIRMED: Netflix Drops Jaw-Dropping Teaser That Has Fans Screaming – “The Addams Family Never Looked This Deadly!”

The crypt doors are creaking open once more, and the shadows of Nevermore Academy are deeper, darker, and deadlier than ever. In a midnight drop that sent…

Small-Town Magic: How a Letterpress Shop and a Stranger’s Smile Turned Ally’s Heart – The Hallmark Holiday Hit That’s Stealing Christmas!

In the snow-dusted streets of Evergreen Hollow, Vermont—a postcard-perfect hamlet where Main Street’s gas lamps flicker like fireflies and the air smells of cinnamon and pine—Ally Harper…

Breaking News from Gayle King: “I’m Going to Be a Grandma Again!” – The Heartwarming Reveal That Has Oprah and the World in Tears of Joy.

It was a sun-drenched Sunday afternoon in Los Angeles, the kind where palm trees sway lazily and the ocean whispers promises of new beginnings. But inside a…

From Late-Night Laughs to Lifelong Dreams: Jimmy Kimmel’s $175 Million Bet on Chicago’s Forgotten Kids – The School That Proves One Man’s Heart Can House a Thousand Hopes.

In the shadow of Chicago’s gleaming skyscrapers, where the Windy City’s relentless hustle often drowns out the whispers of its most vulnerable, a groundbreaking ceremony unfolded on…