Former press secretary Kayleigh McEnany has become a staple at Fox News, joining the network’s ranks among fellow hosts like Ainsley Earhardt. In 2020, McEnany documented her bond with Earhardt by posting a picture on Facebook that the two took together on set. “Love my sweet friend Ainsley Earhardt!” she captioned the selfie with three heart emojis. And the resemblance between the two of them was so uncanny, fans couldn’t help but point out that they looked like they could be related!

There was no denying that McEnany and Earhardt look alike with their blonde wavy hair and matching smiles. Both of them wore V-neck ensembles and similar eyeliner for the photo op. A commenter asked, “Are you sure you’re not sisters?” One follower expressed their surprising resemblance by saying, “Wow! Lookalikes.” Another simply wrote, “Twins.” This all but confirms that Fox News has a type when it comes to their on air personalities. Blonde seems to be the default for female Fox News anchors, making them appear easily interchangeable with one another.

Earhardt and McEnany both love eyeliner

John Lamparski & John Lamparski/Getty & undefined
During their daily appearances on Fox News, Kayleigh McEnany and Ainsley Earhardt always look their best. Their hair is perfectly coiffed and their makeup is spot on to bring out their natural beauty. They never skimp when it comes to eye makeup and are rarely seen without long lashes. There’s one product that they seem most reliant on: eyeliner.

McEnany typically goes for heavier eyeliner by applying a sizable amount of it on her top and bottom lash line. But with so much black surrounding her eyes, it often overpowers their natural pigment. Too much eyeliner can make eyes appear smaller and look less youthful by drawing attention away from the color. It may be time for McEnany to retire her signature dark makeup look.

Earhardt keeps it a little more subtle with her eyeliner but definitely loves to use the product. She even posted pics on social media of her wearing eyeliner as she welcomed her child! On her daughter’s birthday in 2023, Earhardt posted a video on Instagram that included photos of the mom holding her newborn in a hospital bed. You may think Earhardt went makeup free for her delivery, but the pictures say otherwise. Earhardt can be seen in dark eyeliner with her bundle of joy, not long after giving birth.