The Voice 2025 Fans Scream: ‘Lucia Flores-Wiseman Should Have Won!’—What’s Your Take?

The Voice 2025 has once again captured the hearts of millions worldwide, delivering a season filled with raw talent, emotional performances, and the kind of drama that keeps viewers on the edge of their seats. As the finale aired earlier this week on May 20, 2025, the buzz surrounding the show reached a fever pitch. However, the announcement of the winner left a significant portion of the fanbase reeling, with many taking to social media to voice their frustration. Among the most vocal sentiments was the outcry: “Lucia Flores-Wiseman should have won!” So, what sparked this passionate reaction, and does Lucia truly deserve the crown? Let’s dive into the controversy, her journey, and what this means for the future of The Voice.

Lucia Flores-Wiseman: A Voice That Stole the Show

From the moment Lucia Flores-Wiseman stepped onto the blind audition stage, she turned heads—or rather, chairs. Her raspy, soulful rendition of Amy Winehouse’s “Back to Black” had all four coaches spinning around within the first 30 seconds. Posts on X immediately began comparing her to the late Winehouse, with one user noting, “Her raspiness reminds me of Amy Winehouse. She is the favorite.” That early sentiment only grew as the season progressed. Lucia, a 24-year-old singer-songwriter from Seattle, brought a unique blend of grit and vulnerability to every performance, earning her a dedicated fanbase.

Her journey through the competition was nothing short of remarkable. In the battle rounds, she faced off against a powerhouse vocalist, delivering a haunting duet of Adele’s “Someone Like You” that left the audience in tears. Her coach, pop icon Halsey, praised her ability to “make every note feel like a story.” The knockout rounds saw Lucia take a bold risk with a stripped-down version of Billie Eilish’s “When the Party’s Over,” showcasing her vocal control and emotional depth. By the time she reached the live shows, Lucia had become a frontrunner, consistently topping fan polls and earning glowing reviews from the coaches.

What set Lucia apart was her authenticity. Unlike some contestants who relied on flashy production or gimmicks, Lucia’s performances were raw and unfiltered. Whether she was belting out a rock anthem or crooning a soft ballad, her voice carried a weight that resonated with listeners. Fans on X often described her as “a breath of fresh air” in a competition that sometimes felt overly polished. But despite her consistent excellence, the final result left many questioning the fairness of the outcome.

The Finale: A Shocking Upset?

The Voice 2025 finale was a star-studded affair, featuring performances from past winners, celebrity guests, and, of course, the final four contestants. Lucia’s final performance was a showstopper: a medley of Janis Joplin’s “Piece of My Heart” and Etta James’ “At Last.” Her ability to seamlessly transition between the raw intensity of Joplin and the smooth elegance of James left the audience roaring with applause. Coach Kelly Clarkson called it “one of the best finale performances in The Voice history,” while John Legend added, “You have a gift that transcends genres.”

When the votes were tallied, however, Lucia didn’t take home the title. Instead, the win went to 19-year-old country singer Jake Carter, whose upbeat original song and small-town charm had won over a significant portion of the voting audience. Jake’s victory wasn’t entirely surprising—he had a strong following, particularly among country music fans—but for many, it felt like a miscarriage of justice. Fans immediately took to social media to express their outrage, with hashtags like #LuciaWasRobbed and #JusticeForLucia trending within hours.

The sentiment that “Lucia Flores-Wiseman should have won” wasn’t just about her finale performance. Fans pointed to her consistency throughout the season, her versatility, and her ability to connect emotionally with the audience. One X user wrote, “Lucia poured her heart into every song. Jake’s good, but he didn’t have the same depth.” Another commented, “This isn’t a country music contest—it’s The Voice. Lucia had THE voice.” The outcry echoed a long-standing critique of The Voice: the voting system often favors popularity and marketability over raw talent.

The Voting Controversy: A Flawed System?

The Voice has always relied on audience votes to determine its winner, a format that gives fans the power to choose their champion. But this system has long been a point of contention. As far back as 2012, during The Voice of Vietnam’s early seasons, fans and critics alike questioned the fairness of SMS voting. An article from VietnamPlus at the time highlighted how a contestant, Kien Giang, won a round despite a lackluster performance, simply because of an “overwhelming number of text votes.” The article noted that “the number of fans plays a crucial role in securing a spot,” often overshadowing actual vocal ability.

Fast forward to 2025, and the same issues persist. The Voice 2025 allowed voting through the show’s app, social media, and text messages, making it easier than ever for fans to support their favorites. However, this accessibility also amplified the influence of fanbases. Jake Carter, with his appeal to the country music demographic—a group known for its loyalty—likely benefited from a mobilized voting bloc. Lucia, whose style was more eclectic, may not have had the same concentrated support, despite her broader appeal.

This isn’t a new problem for The Voice. In 2012, The Voice of Vietnam saw similar fan backlash when popular contestants like Bui Anh Tuan and Truc Nhanh were eliminated, despite strong performances. A report from CAND at the time called the semi-final “boring” and criticized the lack of consistency in judging and voting. Fans in 2025 are echoing those same frustrations, arguing that the show needs to rethink its format. Some have suggested a hybrid system, where coach votes or expert panels carry more weight, to balance out the popularity contest aspect.

Lucia’s Legacy: A Star in the Making

Despite not winning the title, Lucia Flores-Wiseman’s impact on The Voice 2025 is undeniable. Her performances have already garnered millions of views on YouTube, and industry insiders are buzzing about her potential. In the days following the finale, several record labels reportedly reached out to her, and there’s talk of a debut album in the works. If history is any indication, losing The Voice doesn’t mean the end of a career—many runners-up, like Vietnam’s Vu Cat Tuong (who came second in 2013 and went on to win 11 Vpop awards in 2014), have gone on to achieve greater success than the winners.

Lucia’s story also highlights the power of authenticity in music. In an era where auto-tune and overproduction often dominate, her raw, unpolished voice stood out. She didn’t conform to a single genre or image, and that refusal to fit into a box may have cost her the win—but it also earned her a legion of fans who value genuine artistry. As one fan on X put it, “Lucia didn’t win, but she won our hearts. That’s what matters.”

What Do You Think?

The debate over whether Lucia Flores-Wiseman deserved to win The Voice 2025 is far from over. On one hand, Jake Carter’s victory reflects the democratic nature of the show—fans voted, and he won fair and square. On the other hand, the outcry over Lucia’s loss raises valid questions about the voting system and whether it truly rewards the best vocalist. Should The Voice prioritize popularity, or should it focus on vocal talent above all else? And in a competition as diverse as this, how do you fairly compare a country singer to a soulful indie artist?

As the dust settles on The Voice 2025, one thing is clear: Lucia Flores-Wiseman has left an indelible mark on the show and its fans. Whether she takes home a trophy or not, her voice has already won her a place in the hearts of millions. So, what do you think—did Lucia deserve to win? Let the conversation continue.

Related Posts

Shocking Season 3 Twist in My Life with the Walter Boys: A Devastating Family Secret Threatens to Shatter Jackie, Cole, and Alex’s World Forever!

The sun-drenched fields of Silver Falls, Colorado, have never felt so heavy with tension. As My Life with the Walter Boys gears up for its highly anticipated…

😍 “Are They More Than Co-Stars?!” – Noah LaLonde & Nikki Rodriguez Finally Break Silence After THAT Viral Romantic TikTok 💥🔥

The world of teen dramas thrives on heart-pounding romance, and few shows have captured that magic like Netflix’s My Life with the Walter Boys. At the center…

Secrets Unearthed: Jack’s Shocking Discovery in The Waterfront Season 2 Plunges the Harbor into Heart-Wrenching Chaos!

The highly anticipated second season of The Waterfront is set to premiere on November 23, 2025, and it promises to deliver a tidal wave of drama, mystery,…

Shocking Return of The Queen’s Gambit: Season 2 Confirmed for Late 2025, But Deadly Traps Await Beth Harmon in a High-Stakes Chess Odyssey

The chessboard is set, the pieces are aligned, and the world holds its breath as Netflix announces the unthinkable: The Queen’s Gambit will return for a second…

🚨 ‘Jackie’s Charm Is UNSTOPPABLE!’ – My Life with the Walter Boys Soars to #1 in 67 Countries, Leaving Fans Screaming: Team Cole or Team Alex? 💔🤯

In a world craving escapist romance and heart-pounding drama, My Life with the Walter Boys has taken the globe by storm, soaring to the top of Netflix’s…

Will Robyn Carr’s Next Small-Town Romance Steal Your Heart? Discover the Upcoming TV Adaptation Set to Outshine Virgin River and Sullivan’s Crossing!

The small-town romance genre has found a devoted following, and no one has mastered this art quite like Robyn Carr. Her bestselling book series, Virgin River and…