Hold up, Peaches! The latest buzz surrounding Ginny & Georgia Season 4 has dropped a bombshell that’s shaking Wellsbury to its core. Georgia Miller, the fierce and enigmatic “Mayoress Murderess,” is pregnant, but a tantalizing teaser trailer has left fans questioning everything. Is Joe, the loyal Blue Farm Café owner, out of the picture as the father? Could Paul, the embattled mayor, be the dad? Or is there another jaw-dropping twist lurking in the shadows? With the stakes higher than ever, a hidden clue in the Season 4 buildup has left fans speechless, and the internet is ablaze with speculation. Buckle up as we dive into the drama, dissect the clues, and explore what this pregnancy shocker means for Ginny & Georgia’s explosive next chapter.

A Cliffhanger That Changed Everything

Ginny & Georgia Season 3, which premiered on Netflix on June 5, 2025, ended with a finale that had fans clutching their pearls. After a rollercoaster of a season—complete with Georgia’s murder trial, a fake pregnancy lie, and a crumbling marriage to Paul Randolph—the final scene delivered a gut-punch. Georgia (Brianne Howey) was chugging milk straight from the carton, a habit her daughter Ginny (Antonia Gentry) noted she only indulges in when pregnant. The look of realization on Georgia’s face confirmed it: she’s expecting, for real this time. But the question that’s haunted fans since that moment is, who’s the father?

The Season 3 finale set up a classic Ginny & Georgia love triangle twist. Georgia had recently been intimate with both Paul (Scott Porter), her estranged husband, and Joe (Raymond Ablack), her longtime friend and potential soulmate. Creator Sarah Lampert confirmed to Netflix’s Tudum that Georgia is indeed pregnant, but the paternity remains a mystery, with Paul and Joe as the primary candidates. Now, as Season 4 looms, a new teaser trailer—though not yet officially released as of June 25, 2025—has sparked fresh theories, with whispers of a clue that suggests Joe might not be the father after all.

The Teaser That’s Breaking the Internet

While Netflix hasn’t dropped a full Season 4 trailer, industry insiders and fan accounts on X have been buzzing about a promotional teaser shown at a recent Netflix event. Described as “cryptic” and “loaded with Easter eggs,” the teaser reportedly features Georgia staring at a pregnancy test, followed by a fleeting shot of Paul looking conflicted and Joe appearing distant. A voiceover from Ginny ominously says, “Some secrets change everything,” while a quick cut shows a Wellsbury street sign—possibly hinting at the town itself playing a role in the drama. Fans on X are dissecting every frame, with one user posting, “That teaser SCREAMS Paul’s the dad. Joe looked too detached. What is Georgia hiding?”

The teaser’s most talked-about moment, according to leaks, is a subtle visual clue: a pair of baby booties in Georgia’s hands, embroidered with a monogram that doesn’t match Joe’s initials. While some argue it’s a red herring, others believe it points to Paul—or even a third, unexpected candidate. The ambiguity has fueled wild theories, with fans wondering if Ginny & Georgia’s writers are setting up a paternity twist to rival the show’s most shocking moments, like Georgia’s arrest at her wedding or her confession to killing Tom Fuller.

Joe vs. Paul: The Paternity Debate

The question of who fathered Georgia’s baby is at the heart of Season 4’s anticipation, and the Joe-Paul divide has split the fandom. Joe, the kind-hearted café owner who’s loved Georgia since their teenage years, has been a fan favorite for her endgame. Showrunner Sarah Glinski and creator Sarah Lampert have teased that Joe’s non-judgmental acceptance of Georgia’s chaotic past makes him her perfect match. In Season 3, their long-awaited intimate moment—after years of will-they-won’t-they tension—was a victory for “Team Joe” fans, who celebrated on X with posts like, “Joe and Georgia FINALLY. He’s the dad, right? He HAS to be.”

Yet, the teaser’s suggestion that Joe might be “out of the picture” has thrown this narrative into question. Raymond Ablack, who plays Joe, told Us Weekly, “In my heart, Joe is the father. But I don’t know. I have no idea.” His uncertainty, coupled with the teaser’s imagery, has some fans worried that the writers are leaning toward a more dramatic outcome. One X user speculated, “If it’s Paul’s baby, Joe will still step up. He’s too loyal to walk away, even if it breaks his heart.”

Paul, meanwhile, has a compelling case as the potential father. Despite his Season 3 divorce from Georgia—prompted by her lie about being pregnant and his realization that she’s “manipulative”—Scott Porter, who plays Paul, has argued for his character’s claim. In an interview with Us Weekly on June 24, 2025, Porter said, “If you want to see that to its complete [and] happy ending—which I’m not sure we get on our show—then Joe should be the dad. But Paul’s invested in this family.” Paul’s desire to remain a father figure to Austin, Georgia’s son, suggests he might embrace the role of dad again, complicating Georgia’s budding romance with Joe.

The show’s history of subverting expectations adds fuel to the fire. Georgia’s lie about a pregnancy to manipulate Paul in Season 3 backfired spectacularly, and her real pregnancy now feels like poetic irony. Fans on X have noted the show’s penchant for chaos, with one writing, “It’s Ginny & Georgia. They’ll make it Paul’s baby just to mess with Joe and Georgia’s vibe.” Another theory posits that the baby could belong to a third party, though no other candidates have been strongly hinted at in Season 3.

Wellsbury’s High Stakes and Hidden Clues

Beyond the paternity drama, Season 4 promises to raise the stakes in Wellsbury, where secrets never stay buried for long. The Season 3 finale introduced new threats, including the arrival of Georgia’s mother and stepfather, who drove past her house in a chilling cliffhanger. This development, paired with a warning from Georgia’s father, Shane Reilly, suggests her past is catching up, and her pregnancy could make her more vulnerable. The teaser’s focus on a Wellsbury street sign has led some fans to speculate that the town’s judgmental residents—already dubbing Georgia the “Mayoress Murderess”—will play a role in exposing or complicating her situation.

A hidden clue from Season 3 is also gaining traction among fans. During Georgia’s conversation with Ginny about her milk-drinking habit, she mentioned craving it “all the time” when pregnant with Ginny and Austin. Some viewers believe this could foreshadow a connection to Paul, as Georgia was with him during a period of stability in Wellsbury, unlike her more tumultuous history with Joe. Others point to Joe’s consistent presence in Georgia’s life, arguing that the writers have been building toward a Joe-Georgia romance since Season 1. Creator Sarah Lampert told Us Weekly that “Zion, Paul, and Joe each bring something so unique,” hinting that Season 4 will explore these dynamics further without confirming a frontrunner.

The cast has remained tight-lipped, adding to the suspense. Brianne Howey, in a YouTube interview, teased that Season 4 will “pick up right where we left off,” with Georgia grappling with the pregnancy’s implications. Antonia Gentry, who plays Ginny, noted that her character’s reaction to the pregnancy was one of shock, saying, “Ginny’s like, ‘Are you kidding me?’” This suggests Ginny will play a key role in navigating the fallout, especially since she’s unaware of Georgia’s encounter with Joe.

Fan Reactions and What’s Next

The Ginny & Georgia fandom is in overdrive, with X posts reflecting a mix of excitement, anxiety, and hope. One user wrote, “If Joe’s not the dad, I’m rioting. He’s been through enough!” while another countered, “Paul’s baby would be peak drama. Georgia’s life is never simple.” The debate has even sparked polls, with TV Insider running a “Joe vs. Paul” vote that showed a slight edge for Joe but no clear consensus. The show’s writers, aware of the fervor, have a history of leaning into fan expectations only to subvert them, as seen with Georgia’s acquittal in Season 3.

Season 4, already greenlit by Netflix, is expected to premiere in mid-2026, though filming has yet to begin. Scott Porter told Cosmopolitan that he hopes Paul and Georgia can “get back to that wit and banter,” suggesting their story isn’t over, while Raymond Ablack expressed excitement about exploring Joe’s arc, whether as a father or not. The season will likely address other cliffhangers, like Marcus’ rehab journey and Ginny’s summer in Korea with her father, Zion, but the paternity question is the beating heart of the anticipation.

A Shocker That Defines Ginny & Georgia

The Ginny & Georgia Season 4 paternity shocker encapsulates what makes the show a Netflix juggernaut: high-stakes drama, complex characters, and twists that keep fans guessing. Georgia’s pregnancy, with its uncertain father, is more than a plot device—it’s a lens through which the show explores love, trust, and redemption. Whether Joe, Paul, or an unexpected third party claims the title of dad, the fallout will reshape Wellsbury and Georgia’s relationships, forcing her to confront her past while fighting for her family’s future.

As fans await more clues—perhaps in an official trailer or cast interviews—the teaser’s cryptic imagery and the Season 3 finale’s lingering questions have set the stage for a season that promises to be Ginny & Georgia’s most explosive yet. One thing’s for sure: in Wellsbury, nothing is ever as simple as it seems, and this pregnancy twist is just the beginning. So, Peaches, who do you think is the father? Grab your milk carton and brace for the drama, because Season 4 is about to leave us all speechless.