It’s been over a decade since fans last saw Emma Stone and Andrew Garfield share the screen as Gwen Stacy and Peter Parker in The Amazing Spider-Man 2 (2014), but whispers of a reunion in Spider-Man 4 are sending shockwaves through the Marvel fandom. After Garfield’s triumphant return in Spider-Man: No Way Home (2021), speculation is mounting that Stone could join him in the next chapter of Tom Holland’s Spider-Man saga, potentially marking their first onscreen collaboration in 12 years. Could this be the emotional reunion fans have been dreaming of? Let’s explore the possibilities, the buzz, and what this could mean for the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU). 🎬

A History of Chemistry: Emma and Andrew’s Amazing Legacy

Emma Stone and Andrew Garfield first captured hearts as Gwen Stacy and Peter Parker in The Amazing Spider-Man (2012), a reboot of the Spider-Man franchise directed by Marc Webb. Their onscreen chemistry was electric, fueled by a real-life romance that began during filming and lasted four years until their split in 2015. The sequel, The Amazing Spider-Man 2, ended on a heartbreaking note with Gwen’s tragic death, a moment that left fans reeling and Garfield’s Peter grappling with loss. Despite the end of their characters’ story—and their real-life relationship—the duo has remained close friends, often spotted supporting each other at events like the 2017 awards circuit and the 2025 Golden Globes, where they shared a laugh alongside Stone’s husband, Dave McCary.

Garfield’s return as his version of Peter Parker in Spider-Man: No Way Home was a highlight of the Multiverse Saga, earning thunderous applause for his emotional performance. In the film, he teamed up with Tom Holland and Tobey Maguire to battle iconic villains, even saving Zendaya’s MJ in a moment of redemption for his failure to save Gwen. However, Stone’s absence as Gwen Stacy—or a variant like Spider-Gwen—was keenly felt, especially after it was revealed that early drafts of the film considered including her. Now, with Spider-Man 4 on the horizon, fans and insiders alike are buzzing about the possibility of her return.

The Buzz: Will Emma Stone Swing Back as Spider-Gwen?

Recent posts on X have fueled speculation that Spider-Man 4 could see both Garfield and Stone return, potentially in a climactic multiverse showdown. According to some unverified sources, Sony is planning to bring back Garfield alongside Tobey Maguire for a major role in the film, with a focus on a war against symbiotes and a new iteration of the Sinister Six. One rumor suggests that Stone could reprise her role not as Gwen Stacy, but as Spider-Gwen, a popular multiverse variant of the character who dons her own Spider-suit in Marvel comics. Additionally, there’s talk of all three Spider-Men—Holland, Garfield, and Maguire—wearing symbiote suits, setting the stage for Tom Holland’s Peter Parker to encounter the black suit for the first time.

While these rumors remain unconfirmed, they align with Sony’s ongoing interest in expanding the Spider-Verse in live-action. Stone’s potential return as Spider-Gwen would be a game-changer, offering a fresh take on her character while honoring the emotional depth of her past portrayal. In Spider-Man: No Way Home, Garfield’s Peter expressed lingering guilt over Gwen’s death, and a reunion—whether with Gwen Stacy or a variant—could provide closure for his arc, giving fans the heartfelt moment they’ve been craving since 2014.

Challenges and Opportunities: Can It Happen?

Bringing Stone and Garfield back together isn’t without its challenges. Stone has been selective with her roles in recent years, focusing on critically acclaimed projects like Poor Things (2023), which earned her a Best Actress Oscar in 2024. Her busy schedule, combined with her personal life—she and McCary welcomed their daughter Louise in 2021—might make a return to the superhero genre a tough sell. Additionally, Stone has remained coy about reprising her role as Gwen Stacy. When Garfield revealed in a 2022 interview on the Happy Sad Confused podcast that he kept his No Way Home cameo a secret even from Stone, she playfully called him a “jerk” after seeing the film, hinting at her curiosity about the Spider-Man universe but not confirming any involvement.

On the other hand, the timing feels right for a reunion. Spider-Man: No Way Home proved that audiences are eager for multiverse crossovers, and Garfield’s return was met with overwhelming praise. Sony’s renewed interest in Garfield’s Peter Parker—potentially even for a standalone Amazing Spider-Man 3—suggests they’re keen to capitalize on his popularity. Stone’s return as Spider-Gwen could also pave the way for her character to appear in other projects, such as the animated Spider-Man: Beyond the Spider-Verse, where a live-action cameo might bridge the gap between Sony’s animated and live-action universes.

What a Reunion Could Mean for Spider-Man 4

If Stone and Garfield do reunite in Spider-Man 4, the emotional stakes would be sky-high. For Garfield’s Peter, seeing Gwen again—whether as a resurrected version of his lost love or a multiverse variant like Spider-Gwen—could offer a chance at redemption and healing. Fans have long dreamed of a moment where Peter and Gwen could share the screen again, and Stone’s portrayal of a fierce, web-slinging Spider-Gwen would add a thrilling dynamic to the film. Imagine the three Spider-Men battling a new Sinister Six, only for Spider-Gwen to swing in as an unexpected ally, reigniting her connection with Garfield’s Peter while teaming up with Holland’s Spider-Man to save the day.

The film could also explore deeper themes of loss, love, and legacy. Garfield’s Peter has carried the weight of Gwen’s death for over a decade in-universe, and a reunion could allow him to find peace, even as he helps Holland’s Peter navigate his own challenges with the symbiote. Stone’s return would also be a nod to the fans who have championed her Gwen Stacy since 2012, cementing her place as one of the most beloved characters in Spider-Man’s cinematic history.

Fan Reactions and the Road Ahead

The idea of Emma Stone and Andrew Garfield reuniting has sparked a frenzy among fans. On X, users have expressed their excitement, with some imagining epic team-ups and others hoping for a romantic reconciliation between Peter and Gwen. One fan wrote, “Emma as Spider-Gwen in Spider-Man 4 with Andrew would heal my heart,” echoing the sentiment of many who feel their story was left unfinished. Others are cautiously optimistic, noting that while the rumors are exciting, they’re still unconfirmed as of May 2025.

Spider-Man 4 is currently in development, with a release date rumored for 2026. Directed by Destin Daniel Cretton, the film is expected to focus on a more grounded story for Tom Holland’s Peter Parker, following the multiverse chaos of No Way Home. However, the inclusion of Garfield and potentially Stone suggests that the multiverse will still play a role, possibly setting the stage for larger crossovers like Avengers: Secret Wars. Garfield himself has been coy about his involvement, telling The Hollywood Reporter in 2024, “I’m not in Spider-Man 4, but no one’s gonna trust anything I say after No Way Home.” His playful deflection only adds fuel to the speculation fire.

A Dream Reunion 12 Years in the Making

Emma Stone and Andrew Garfield’s potential reunion in Spider-Man 4 would be a cinematic event 12 years in the making, bringing together two actors whose chemistry defined a generation of Spider-Man fans. Whether Stone returns as Gwen Stacy, Spider-Gwen, or a completely new variant, her presence alongside Garfield would undoubtedly create one of the most emotional and thrilling moments in the MCU. As the Spider-Verse continues to expand, this reunion could be the perfect way to honor the legacy of The Amazing Spider-Man while setting the stage for new adventures.

For now, fans will have to wait for official confirmation, but the possibility of seeing Emma and Andrew swing back into action together is enough to keep the excitement alive. Could Spider-Man 4 finally give Peter and Gwen the happy ending they deserve? Only time will tell, but one thing’s for sure: if this reunion happens, it’ll be nothing short of amazing. 🕸️