The small-town drama Sullivan’s Crossing has captivated audiences with its heartfelt storytelling, scenic Nova Scotia backdrop, and intricate relationships. As the series gears up for its fourth season, set to premiere on October 12, 2025, on CTV and The CW, fans are buzzing with anticipation over a shocking revelation from the Season 3 finale: Maggie Sullivan’s secret marriage to Liam Davies, a man who claims to be her husband. This cliffhanger, coupled with the lingering aftermath of Maggie’s tragic miscarriage and her evolving relationship with Cal Jones, sets the stage for a dramatic new chapter. Adding fuel to the fire is the possibility of a new pregnancy for Maggie, hinted at in promotional materials for Season 4, with questions swirling about who the father might be—and whether Cal will remain the central father figure in her life. With creator Roma Roth teasing “exciting and emotional challenges” for Maggie and Cal, Season 4 promises to unravel the complexities of love, loss, and family in Timberlake. This article explores Maggie’s pregnancy revelation, the potential father figures in her orbit, and what fans can expect from the upcoming season.

The Journey of Maggie Sullivan

Sullivan’s Crossing, based on Robyn Carr’s five-novel series, follows Maggie Sullivan (Morgan Kohan), a talented neurosurgeon whose life unravels after a legal scandal in Boston. Forced to return to her hometown of Timberlake, Nova Scotia, Maggie reconnects with her estranged father, Harry “Sully” Sullivan (Scott Patterson), who runs the titular campground. Over three seasons, the show has chronicled Maggie’s journey of self-discovery, as she navigates her career ambitions, complex family dynamics, and a slow-burn romance with Cal Jones (Chad Michael Murray), the campground’s handyman. The series has resonated with audiences for its emotional depth and relatable characters, earning a devoted following on CTV, The CW, and Netflix, where it became a streaming hit in 2025.

Season 2 introduced a major plot twist: Maggie’s pregnancy with her ex-boyfriend Andrew Mathews’ (Allan Hawco) child. The revelation, confirmed in Season 2, Episode 7, came after Andrew found an ultrasound picture in Maggie’s purse and shared the news without her consent, straining their already faltering relationship. Maggie, initially uncertain about motherhood, decided to embrace it, choosing to raise the child on her own after ending things with Andrew. However, the Season 2 finale delivered a devastating blow: a fire at the town’s diner led to Maggie’s miscarriage, a loss confirmed off-screen in the Season 3 premiere. The tragedy, attributed to the stress and trauma of the fire, deeply affected Maggie, who grappled with grief while leaning on Cal for support.

Season 3 explored Maggie’s healing process, her growing bond with Cal, and her decision to stay in Timberlake and open a medical practice. Just as it seemed Maggie and Cal were finding stability, the finale introduced Liam Davies (Marcus Rosner), who shocked everyone by claiming to be Maggie’s husband. This bombshell, combined with Season 4’s promotional hints about a new pregnancy, has fans speculating about Maggie’s future and the men who might shape it.

The Pregnancy Revelation: A New Chapter?

While Sullivan’s Crossing Season 3 resolved the fate of Maggie’s first pregnancy, promotional materials for Season 4, including a teaser trailer released on August 22, 2025, by Deadline, suggest another pregnancy storyline. In the trailer, Maggie is seen holding a pregnancy test, her expression a mix of shock and uncertainty, while Cal looks on with concern. The tagline, “Some secrets change everything,” hints that this revelation will be central to the season’s drama. Given Maggie’s miscarriage, this development carries significant emotional weight, raising questions about the father’s identity and how it will impact her relationships.

In Robyn Carr’s novels, Maggie and Cal eventually have a daughter named Elizabeth, suggesting that Cal could be the father in the TV series. Their Season 3 romance, culminating in Maggie’s decision to stay in Timberlake and Cal’s proposal to move in together, supports this possibility. However, the show has diverged from the books before, notably with Maggie’s Season 2 pregnancy with Andrew’s child, which ended in miscarriage. The introduction of Liam as Maggie’s secret husband complicates matters further, raising the possibility that he could be involved in the pregnancy storyline.

Cal Jones: The Steady Father Figure

Cal Jones, played by Chad Michael Murray, has been Maggie’s emotional anchor throughout Sullivan’s Crossing. A former lawyer who moved to Timberlake after his wife’s death from ALS, Cal is a complex character, marked by grief and a reluctance to open up. His slow-burn romance with Maggie has been a fan favorite, with their Season 3 arc showing them overcoming obstacles like Maggie’s miscarriage and Cal’s fears about fatherhood. Cal’s hesitation to have children stems from his father’s schizophrenia, a genetic condition he worries about passing on. Despite this, he supported Maggie through her grief, planting a tree in honor of her lost child and proving his capacity for compassion.

In Season 3, Episode 3, Maggie observed Cal’s gentle handling of a newborn during a medical emergency, sparking hope that he could embrace fatherhood. Fans on Reddit have speculated that Cal’s growth—particularly after reconciling with his terminally ill father—might lead him to reconsider his stance. If Maggie is pregnant with Cal’s child in Season 4, it could be a turning point, forcing him to confront his fears and solidify his role as a father figure. However, his reaction to Liam’s claim as Maggie’s husband, seen in a Season 4 first-look photo where he stares at Liam with unease, suggests tension that could complicate their future.

Liam Davies: The Mysterious Husband

The Season 3 finale introduced Liam Davies, described by Maggie as a “summer fling” but revealed to be her husband. This twist, detailed in a People article from August 12, 2025, left Maggie speechless and Cal stunned, setting up a potential love triangle in Season 4. Little is known about Liam, played by Marcus Rosner, but his arrival raises questions about Maggie’s past. Was their marriage a youthful indiscretion, a legally binding union she never dissolved, or something more? The show’s divergence from the books, which do not feature Liam, suggests he’s a creation to heighten drama, possibly as a rival for Maggie’s affections or a figure tied to her new pregnancy.

If Liam is the father, it would mark another departure from the novels, where Maggie’s child is with Cal. The Season 4 trailer shows Liam lingering near Maggie, his expression intense, hinting at unresolved feelings. Fans on X have speculated that Liam could be a red herring, introduced to test Maggie and Cal’s relationship rather than as a legitimate father figure. Others believe his presence might reveal a hidden chapter of Maggie’s life, perhaps a brief marriage during her time away from Timberlake. Either way, Liam’s role adds intrigue to the pregnancy storyline, challenging Cal’s position as the primary man in Maggie’s life.

Andrew Mathews: A Lingering Shadow

Andrew Mathews, Maggie’s ex-boyfriend from Boston, was the father of her first child. Their relationship, marked by incompatibility and Andrew’s controlling behavior, ended in Season 2, but his impact lingered. Andrew’s decision to announce Maggie’s pregnancy to her friends without her consent highlighted his manipulative nature, and his inability to connect with Sully or embrace Timberlake’s community sealed their breakup. While Andrew is unlikely to be the father of a new pregnancy, given Maggie’s firm rejection of him, his presence in Season 3 as a recurring character suggests he could reappear to stir trouble.

In the books, Andrew is a minor figure who doesn’t want children, and Maggie’s miscarriage with his child happens before the story begins. The show’s choice to dramatize this storyline in Season 2 indicates a willingness to explore Maggie’s past relationships. If Andrew returns in Season 4, he might complicate Maggie’s emotional journey, particularly if he learns of her new pregnancy and attempts to reinsert himself into her life. However, his role as a father figure seems improbable, given Maggie’s clear preference for Cal and her commitment to Timberlake.

Sully: The Patriarchal Anchor

Harry “Sully” Sullivan, Maggie’s father, is another key figure in her life. Their strained relationship, rooted in Maggie’s childhood departure with her mother, Phoebe, has been a central arc of the series. Season 3 saw them mend their bond, with Sully surviving the diner fire and finding love with writer Helen Culver. His decision to travel to Ireland with Helen in the Season 3 finale, detailed in Netflix Tudum on July 10, 2025, leaves Maggie and Cal in charge of the campground, positioning Sully as a less active but still influential father figure.

Sully’s absence in Season 4 could impact Maggie’s pregnancy journey, as she may seek his guidance. His past support during her first pregnancy, despite their conflicts, suggests he’d be a stabilizing presence. If Maggie is pregnant, Sully’s return—potentially mid-season—could provide emotional grounding, reinforcing his role as the patriarchal anchor of Timberlake.

The Emotional Stakes of Season 4

Maggie’s potential pregnancy in Season 4 carries immense emotional weight, given her miscarriage. Morgan Kohan, in a May 2025 interview with Good Housekeeping, emphasized the importance of portraying loss respectfully, noting that it “affects so many different people in many capacities.” Her performance in Season 3, particularly scenes of Maggie folding baby clothes with a vacant stare, resonated with viewers, many of whom shared personal stories of loss on X. A new pregnancy would test Maggie’s resilience, forcing her to confront fears of another loss while navigating her relationships with Cal, Liam, and her community.

Cal’s role as a potential father figure is complicated by his fears of schizophrenia, a storyline explored in ScreenRant on May 26, 2025. His growth in Season 3, particularly after his father’s cancer diagnosis, suggests he’s ready to embrace a future with Maggie, but Liam’s arrival could derail their progress. The love triangle, teased in Deadline’s first-look photos, shows Cal gazing lovingly at Maggie while Liam watches with a furrowed brow, hinting at tension that could shape the season’s narrative.

Fan Expectations and Speculation

Fans have taken to social media to dissect the Season 4 trailer, with many hoping for a Maggie-Cal baby to align with the books. “Cal deserves to be the dad, and Maggie deserves happiness,” one X user posted. Others are intrigued by Liam, with a Reddit thread speculating that his marriage to Maggie might be a legal technicality rather than a romantic threat. The show’s history of diverging from the novels keeps viewers guessing, with some predicting a twist where the pregnancy is a false alarm, used to explore Maggie’s emotional growth.

Roma Roth’s comments to Collider in July 2025, promising a “big shoe drop” in Season 4, suggest that the pregnancy revelation will have far-reaching consequences. Whether Cal, Liam, or another figure emerges as the father—or father figure—the storyline will test Maggie’s strength and the bonds she’s built in Timberlake.

Conclusion

Sullivan’s Crossing Season 4, premiering October 12, 2025, is poised to deliver a compelling chapter in Maggie Sullivan’s journey. Her potential pregnancy, hinted at in promotional materials, raises stakes already heightened by her secret marriage to Liam and her deepening bond with Cal. While Cal remains the frontrunner as a father figure, Liam’s mysterious presence and Sully’s enduring influence add layers of complexity. As Maggie navigates love, loss, and the possibility of motherhood, the show continues to weave a tapestry of small-town drama and em