In a chilling twist that has left America reeling, explosive allegations are surfacing in the tragic stabbing death of Texas high school football sensation Austin Metcalf – pointing the finger squarely at the father of accused killer Karmelo Anthony. Sources close to the investigation and online sleuths alike are buzzing with claims that Andrew Anthony, a devout preacher who has publicly preached against violence and labeled knife-carriers as ‘thugs,’ may have supplied his son with the very weapon used to pierce Metcalf’s heart. As the family cries victim amid a whirlwind of death threats and racial tension, the Daily Mail delves deep into this bombshell theory, uncovering the damning details that could shatter their self-defense narrative and expose a horrifying family secret.

The nightmare unfolded on April 2, 2025, at Frisco’s Kuykendall Stadium during a routine high school track meet – an event meant for cheers and competition, not carnage. Seventeen-year-old Austin Metcalf, a white star athlete from Frisco Memorial High School with dreams of NFL glory, was simply defending his school’s turf when he asked Karmelo Anthony, a black 17-year-old from rival Frisco Centennial High School, to move from under their team’s tent. What started as a petty seating squabble escalated into unspeakable horror: Anthony allegedly plunged a kitchen knife straight into Metcalf’s chest, killing him in the arms of his devastated twin brother.

Witnesses described the scene as pure chaos. “Austin was just trying to keep things orderly,” one bystander told police, as reported in the arrest affidavit. “He told the kid to leave, and next thing you know, there’s blood everywhere.” Anthony, who fled but was quickly apprehended, confessed to cops: “I’m not alleged, I did it.” He even asked if Metcalf would be okay and if his actions could be seen as self-defense – a claim that’s now crumbling under scrutiny.

But here’s where it gets truly sinister: Rumors swirling on social media and in local forums suggest Andrew Anthony, Karmelo’s father and a self-proclaimed man of God who has sermonized about the perils of street violence, might have armed his son that fateful day. “His dad gave him the knife,” one anonymous tipster posted on Reddit, echoing sentiments from X (formerly Twitter) where users like @troglodytetime raged: “Fuck Karmelo Anthony, and his bitch ass handlers too. His dad should be in prison for giving his son a knife for a track meet.” These accusations aren’t just idle chatter – they’re gaining traction amid reports that Karmelo had a history of knife-related incidents, including a school suspension for bringing a blade to class.

Andrew Anthony, who testified at his son’s bond hearing, painted a picture of a wholesome family life. “We moved to North Texas for a better life,” he said, describing Karmelo as an A-student, football captain, and track leader with two part-time jobs. But cracks in this facade are appearing. Insiders whisper that Andrew, known in his community as a preacher who rails against ‘thug life,’ once declared in a sermon: “Only a thug carries a knife – it’s the mark of someone who’s lost their way with God.” If true, these words now ring hollow, as evidence mounts that he may have handed Karmelo the 6-inch kitchen knife used in the attack.

The Daily Mail has learned from sources familiar with the family’s dynamics that Andrew drove Karmelo to the track meet – despite the teen not being scheduled to compete. Why? And why was Karmelo packing a knife in a weapons-free zone? “It’s not self-defense if you’re armed and ready,” a legal expert told us. “If the dad provided the weapon, he could face accessory charges – that’s how it works in Texas.” Prosecutors are tight-lipped, but Collin County DA Greg Willis vowed to “follow the truth wherever it leads,” hinting at a deeper probe.

Karmelo’s family has been thrust into the spotlight, holding a tearful press conference on April 17 where they portrayed themselves as victims of racism and harassment. Mother Kala Hayes sobbed: “Our family has been under attack… My husband had to take a leave of absence because he’s afraid.” They denied starting a GoFundMe that raised nearly $450,000 – funds allegedly used for a new mansion and Cadillac Escalade. But critics aren’t buying it. “They’re profiting off murder,” fumed one donor who demanded a refund. And amid the pleas for sympathy, Austin’s grieving father, Jeff Metcalf, was shockingly escorted out of the event by police after showing up silently – labeled “disrespectful” by activist Dominique Alexander.

This isn’t the first time the Anthonys have faced backlash. Karmelo’s prior scrapes – a February 4 school fight and that knife suspension – paint him as no angel. Classmates whispered he was “known for fighting,” as one girl told local news before interviews mysteriously dried up. Conspiracy theorists on X claim a cover-up: “The media shut down after she spilled the beans on Karmelo being a fighter,” posted @CinemaShogun in a viral video. And now, the preacher dad’s alleged hypocrisy fuels the fire.

Let’s break it down: If Andrew Anthony, the God-fearing father who preaches peace, armed his son, it demolishes their self-defense story. Texas law is clear – you can’t claim protection if you’re the aggressor. Witnesses say Karmelo threatened: “Touch me and see what happens,” before stabbing. “He provoked it,” Jeff Metcalf told reporters, his voice breaking. “Austin was unarmed, just a kid standing his ground.”

The racial divide has turned toxic. Online trolls spew hate, with fake autopsies claiming Metcalf overdosed (debunked by police) and wild theories linking Karmelo to NBA star Carmelo Anthony (no relation). A “pro-Karmelo militia” is reportedly forming in Dallas, discussing “street justice” on fundraiser pages. “They’re silencing witnesses,” one X user alleged, citing threats to students and teachers.

But the knife theory cuts deepest. Reddit threads explode: “Why did Karmelo have a knife on school grounds?” Users point to Andrew’s role: “Dad drove him there, knew about the suspension – he must’ve given it for ‘protection.'” A YouTube video by Cinema Shogun amplifies: “People are scared… His supporters are harassing Austin’s dad to send a message.”

As Karmelo, now 18, awaits trial after a June indictment for first-degree murder, the family hides in an undisclosed location amid threats. But questions linger: Did the preacher practice what he preached? Or did paternal ‘protection’ lead to premeditated tragedy?

Jeff Metcalf, holding vigils for his son, pleads for justice: “Austin was our light… Prevent such tragedies.” Yet, with Karmelo on house arrest and the family cashing in, many fear a miscarriage. “If dad gave the knife, charge him too,” demands one petition with thousands of signatures.

This case exposes America’s underbelly – youth violence, racial rifts, and family secrets. As trial looms, the Daily Mail will keep digging. Was it self-defense or setup? The truth may stab deeper than any blade.