Newly released incident records from the Minneapolis Fire Department offer stark and previously unreported medical detail about the fatal shooting of 37-year-old Renee Nicole Good during a January 7 U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) operation. The documents show that Good, a mother of three, suffered up to four separate gunshot wounds, underscoring the intensity of the confrontation and fueling fresh calls for transparency, accountability and a thorough federal and local review of the case.
Paramedics responding to the chaotic scene found Good unresponsive in the driver’s seat of her SUV with multiple injuries, according to the Minneapolis Fire Department incident report obtained by multiple U.S. news outlets. Good was treated at the scene and transported to a hospital, where efforts to save her life continued before she was later pronounced dead. 
The fatal encounter — which unfolded amid heightened ICE activity in Minneapolis — has rapidly become one of the most scrutinized uses of deadly force by a federal law enforcement officer in recent years, drawing protests nationwide, prompting political debate, and straining relations between local and federal officials.
⸻
Multiple Gunshot Wounds Documented by Fire Department
The Minneapolis Fire Department report details Good’s wounds with a level of medical specificity that had not been publicly available before. According to the incident report and accompanying transcripts:
• Good sustained two apparent gunshot wounds to the right side of her chest.
• A third gunshot wound was observed on her left forearm.
• A fourth injury — described as a possible gunshot wound with protruding tissue on the left side of her head — likely represented a penetrating wound or graze. 
The combination of injuries was severe, and responders found Good unresponsive, not breathing and with an irregular, inconsistent pulse when they reached her vehicle just after 9:40 a.m. local time on January 7. Emergency personnel documented blood on her face and torso and noted that signs of life were virtually absent by the time they began life-saving measures at the scene. 
Medical teams worked to stabilize Good on a snow-covered Minneapolis street before moving her a short distance — to improve ambulance access and create separation from what had already become an escalating law enforcement and bystander situation. Despite extensive efforts, including chest compressions, airway and ventilation management, and advanced life support by hospital staff, Good succumbed to her injuries. Resuscitative efforts were discontinued later that morning. 
The report’s confirmation that Good endured up to four gunshot wounds adds new gravity to a case already under intense public and legal scrutiny.
⸻
Conflicting Accounts of What Happened
The circumstances leading up to the shooting remain fiercely contested. Federal officials, including the Department of Homeland Security (DHS), have defended the actions of the ICE agent involved. They maintain that the officer acted in “self-defense” after Good “weaponized her vehicle” and attempted to strike officers during a law enforcement operation in Minneapolis. The administration has characterized the encounter as an example of Good’s aggressive response to federal agents executing their duties. 
According to that account, ICE agents were conducting a targeted operation when Good’s vehicle obstructed the roadway. Federal statements assert that Good’s motion toward officers left the ICE agent with no choice but to fire to protect himself and his colleagues.
However, multiple video recordings, witness statements and local officials dispute that depiction. Footage posted online appears to show Good’s SUV attempting to move away from agents at the time shots were fired — with the ICE officer positioned to the side of the vehicle rather than directly in front of it. Some video analysts conclude that at least one shot was fired after Good’s vehicle had begun to accelerate. 
Perhaps most significantly, no publicly released video shows Good striking an officer with her vehicle, a pointed contrast to the federal narrative that she had attempted to run down the agent. Eyewitness accounts instead describe confusion, yelling, and conflicting instructions given just before the shooting occurred.
⸻
Family, Local Officials and Legal Representatives Respond
Good’s family has vehemently disputed federal characterizations of her behavior. Represented by civil rights attorneys — including the Chicago-based firm Romanucci & Blandin, known for high-profile litigation — they have called for full transparency and a thorough investigation beyond the preliminary federal and incident reports.
Her legal team has characterized the shooting as unjustified and demanded that authorities release all available evidence, including body-worn camera footage, surveillance video and detailed forensic analysis.
Becca Good, Renee’s partner, was present during the incident and witnessed the shooting. According to eyewitness reports and media accounts, she was seen at the scene shortly after the incident, distraught and holding Renee as emergency response teams treated her. 
Local officials, notably Minneapolis Mayor Jacob Frey and Police Chief Brian O’Hara, have expressed “deep concern” about the use of deadly force by a federal agent in a residential neighborhood and emphasized the need for accountability. O’Hara has pointed out that, in normal police practice, officers are trained to minimize lethal force when it can be avoided — especially when a civilian is in a vehicle and there is no clear threat posed. 
⸻
Political and Public Reaction: From Protests to Policy Debates
The shooting has reignited long-running debates over federal immigration enforcement and use-of-force standards. Within days of Good’s death, protests erupted in Minneapolis and in other cities across the country, with demonstrators calling for justice, transparency and an end to what they describe as overreach by ICE and federal law enforcement. Hundreds of demonstrators gathered at rallies, some clashing with law enforcement, while others held peaceful vigils. 
Democratic lawmakers, civil rights leaders and immigration policy advocates have seized on the incident as evidence of systemic problems in how aggressive federal operations are conducted in urban communities. They argue that the apparent lack of independent oversight and the federal government’s refusal to permit Minnesota state investigators to participate in the review have undermined public trust. 
Republican officials and conservatives have largely defended ICE’s role, framing the incident within the broader context of national immigration enforcement. Some have emphasized the dangers federal agents face during such operations, while others have pointed to the need for stronger protection of lawful immigration officers.
⸻
Federal Investigations and Legal Challenges
The Department of Justice (DOJ) has announced that it will not open a criminal civil rights investigation into the shooting, asserting there is currently “no basis” for such a probe. This decision has drawn sharp criticism from legal experts, local prosecutors and members of the public who argue that an independent review is necessary to ensure accountability. 
Instead of a criminal inquiry, the ongoing investigation has been described as a civil review, with Good’s family pushing for greater involvement of independent forensic experts and a full release of evidence. State and local agencies — including the FBI and the Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension — are also expected to examine the use of force and other incident details.
Civil litigation on behalf of the Good family could hinge on how the shooting is characterized legally, and whether federal agents can be shown to have violated established procedures and civil rights protections.
⸻
Who Was Renee Nicole Good?
Renee Nicole Good was a 37-year-old American citizen, described by family and acquaintances as a devoted mother, partner, writer and poet. She lived in Minneapolis with her partner Becca and was the mother of three children, including a 6-year-old she had dropped off at school shortly before the shooting. 
Friends and relatives remember Good as compassionate and deeply committed to her family and community. Social media posts paint a picture of a woman who cherished her role as a mother and partner, pursued creative expression through writing, and valued kindness and empathy. 
Her sudden and violent death has reverberated across Minneapolis — a city already deeply marked by high-profile police shootings and national debates about law enforcement practices — and has renewed public discussion about federal jurisdiction, immigration enforcement and the intersection of civil liberties with aggressive policing strategies.
