A quiet suburban neighborhood in Columbus, Ohio, shattered into nightmare on the eve of the new year when beloved local dentist Spencer Tepe, 37, and his wife Monique Tepe, 39, were brutally gunned down inside their own home. The couple, just weeks away from celebrating their fifth wedding anniversary, left behind two young children who were found crying nearby—unharmed physically but forever scarred by the unimaginable violence that unfolded around them. As a massive manhunt grips the region for an unknown suspect who vanished without a trace, leaving no weapon or signs of forced entry, questions swirl in a case that has all the hallmarks of a targeted, cold-blooded assassination.

the-express.com

myfox28columbus.com

The double homicide, discovered on December 30, 2025, has transformed the Tepes’ Weinland Park residence into a grim crime scene, cordoned off with yellow tape as forensic teams comb for clues. What drove someone to execute this seemingly perfect couple in their sanctuary? And how did the killer slip away undetected, leaving the children to bear witness to the aftermath? This is a story of shattered dreams, a community’s terror, and a desperate race against time to catch a ghost before they strike again.

The Chilling Discovery: Cries of Children Lead to a House of Horrors

The tragedy began unraveling on a Tuesday morning that should have been ordinary. Spencer Tepe, known for his punctuality and dedication at Athens Dental Depot, failed to show up for his shift—a red flag for his boss, Dr. Mark Valrose. “He is always on time and he would contact us if there was any issues,” Valrose told reporters, his voice laced with worry. “This is very out of character for him. We are very, very concerned.”

Alarmed co-workers and a family friend drove to the Tepes’ home for a welfare check around 10 a.m. What they encountered turned their concern into horror: The unmistakable wails of young children echoing from inside the house. Peering through windows, one friend spotted Spencer’s body near a bed, lifeless and bloodied. A frantic 911 call captured the panic: “There is a body inside… Our friend wasn’t answering his phone. We just did a wellness check. We just came here, and he appears dead.”

Columbus Police Department officers arrived swiftly, breaching the door to a scene of carnage. Spencer lay riddled with multiple gunshot wounds, while Monique had suffered at least one fatal shot to the chest. The two children—toddlers too young to fully comprehend the nightmare—were found crying but miraculously uninjured. No firearm was recovered, and crucially, there were no obvious signs of forced entry, suggesting the killer was someone the couple knew or let in willingly.

By Wednesday, a makeshift memorial of roses and sunflowers bloomed outside the home, a poignant tribute amid the police barricades. Neighbors, stunned in this typically peaceful area, whispered about the family’s normalcy—no loud arguments, no visible troubles. Yet, beneath the surface calm, something sinister had brewed to eruption.

myfox28columbus.com

myfox28columbus.com

Spencer and Monique Tepe: A Picture-Perfect Life Masking Unknown Shadows

Spencer Tepe was more than a dentist—he was a community pillar, trusted with smiles and confidences at his practice. Colleagues described him as reliable, professional, and family-oriented. Monique, his wife of nearly five years (married in 2021), complemented him perfectly: A devoted mother who balanced home life with grace. The couple’s social media, now scrubbed or private in the wake of tragedy, once showcased happy milestones—anniversaries, family outings, and the joys of parenthood.

Their Weinland Park home, in a revitalizing Columbus neighborhood, represented the American dream: A safe haven for raising their young family. Friends recall barbecues, playdates, and the Tepes’ quiet contentment. But in hindsight, was there tension bubbling unseen? Police have ruled out murder-suicide, confirming a third-party assailant. No motive has surfaced—no robbery (valuables untouched), no known enemies, no domestic disputes on record.

Investigators are digging into finances, relationships, and digital footprints. Was it a professional grudge from Spencer’s dental world? A personal vendetta against Monique? Or something darker, tied to their private lives? The absence of forced entry points chillingly to trust betrayed.

The Manhunt: A Killer on the Loose in the Heartland

With no suspect in custody, central Ohio is on edge. The unknown gunman fled the scene undetected, leaving behind a puzzle that baffles seasoned detectives. Columbus Police Homicide Unit, leading the probe, has appealed for tips: Call 614-645-4730 or Central Ohio Crime Stoppers anonymously at 614-461-TIPS.

Forensic teams scour for DNA, ballistics, and surveillance footage from neighboring Ring cameras or traffic cams. The weapon’s absence suggests premeditation—the killer came prepared and left clean. “This was not random,” sources whisper off-record. “Someone wanted them dead.”

The children’s survival adds heartbreaking urgency. Rescued and placed with relatives, their cries haunt first responders. Child psychologists are involved, but the trauma is profound—witnessing parents’ violent ends at tender ages.

Community vigils form, candles flickering against the winter chill. “They were good people,” one neighbor tearfully told local media. “Who could do this?”

Broader Implications: Safety in Suburbia Shattered

This double homicide strikes at America’s core fear: Violence invading the safest spaces. Weinland Park, once struggling but now gentrifying, reels from the spotlight. Gun violence statistics loom—2025 saw thousands of domestic or targeted shootings nationwide.

As toxicology and autopsy results pend, speculation runs rampant online. True crime forums dissect timelines; podcasts gear up for episodes. But for the Tepe family—parents, siblings, friends—the pain is raw, unrelenting.

Spencer and Monique’s story ends in bullets, but the hunt for justice begins. Will the killer’s trail go cold, or will a tip crack the case? Central Ohio holds its breath, praying for answers in a mystery as dark as it is devastating.

In the meantime, two orphans navigate a world forever altered, and a community mourns what was lost on that fateful Tuesday. The suspect remains at large—armed, dangerous, and unknown. If you have information, speak now. Silence aids only the shadows.