As the credits rolled on the final episode of Sirens Season 1, released on Netflix on May 22, 2025, viewers were left reeling from a twist that redefined the series: Simone (Milly Alcock) emerging as the new wife of Peter Kell (Kevin Bacon), effectively usurping the position of Michaela (Julianne Moore). This dramatic turn of events, set against the opulent yet treacherous backdrop of Port Haven, has sparked endless speculation about the future of the show. With the season concluding on an ambiguous note—Simone standing triumphantly yet isolated on a cliffside, wearing Michaela’s dress—the potential for a second season looms large. If renewed, a new season could delve deeply into the complex dynamics of Simone and Peter’s marriage, exploring the internal conflicts within the Kell family and Simone’s uneasy navigation of newfound power. This could pave the way for intricate family political intrigue or profound betrayals that keep audiences on the edge of their seats.

The Genesis of a Controversial Alliance

The relationship between Simone and Peter was anything but conventional from the outset. Introduced as a young, ambitious woman drawn into the orbit of the Kell family through her sister Devon (Meghann Fahy), Simone’s journey in Season 1 was marked by manipulation, resilience, and a calculated ascent. Her initial bond with Michaela, a seasoned lawyer with a troubled past, appeared to be one of mentorship and mutual support. However, the facade crumbled when Michaela discovered compromising photos of Peter kissing Simone, a moment that Simone claimed was initiated by Peter. This betrayal led to Michaela’s swift dismissal of Simone, setting the stage for a seismic shift.

The climactic revelation came in the finale, where Peter, seemingly captivated by Simone’s enigmatic allure, proposed marriage after dissolving his union with Michaela. The decision stunned viewers and characters alike, given Peter’s established role as a patriarchal figurehead of the Kell dynasty, a man whose wealth and influence were matched only by his volatility. For Simone, this marriage represented not just a personal victory but a strategic coup, elevating her from an outsider to the matriarch of a powerful family. Yet, the question remains: what lies beneath this union, and how will it shape the narrative moving forward?

The Fallout: Internal Family Conflicts

A potential Season 2 would likely thrust the Kell family into uncharted territory as they grapple with the repercussions of Peter’s choice. Michaela, now cast aside, is unlikely to retreat quietly. Her legal acumen and emotional investment in the family suggest she might launch a counteroffensive, perhaps seeking a divorce settlement that could destabilize Peter’s empire. The dynamic between Michaela and Simone could evolve into a psychological chess match, with each woman leveraging her strengths—Michaela’s experience and Simone’s youthful cunning—to outmaneuver the other.

Within the Kell household, Peter’s children from his previous marriage with Michaela—hypothetical heirs to the family legacy—could emerge as significant players. Their resentment toward Simone, a usurper in their eyes, might fuel sibling rivalries or alliances aimed at undermining her position. Peter’s own reaction to this new marriage will be critical. Will he view Simone as a partner or a pawn? His history of controlling behavior, hinted at throughout Season 1, suggests he may attempt to mold Simone into his ideal, potentially sparking resistance or rebellion from her.

The introduction of extended family members or business associates could further complicate matters. The Kell fortune, likely tied to real estate or shipping (given the island setting), might be contested through boardroom battles or legal disputes. Simone’s lack of formal ties to this world could make her a target for exclusion, forcing her to rely on her wits and the support of Devon, who remains a wildcard in the family drama.

Simone’s Ascendancy: Navigating Power

For Simone, the transition from outsider to wife of Peter Kell is a double-edged sword. Milly Alcock’s portrayal of Simone as a blend of vulnerability and steel has been a highlight of Season 1, and a new season could expand on her character’s evolution. Thrust into a role of unprecedented authority, Simone must contend with the expectations and scrutiny that come with being the Kell matriarch. Her youth and relative inexperience could be both her weakness and her strength, allowing her to approach challenges with a fresh perspective that older family members might overlook.

One compelling arc could involve Simone’s attempt to assert her autonomy. Having secured her position through marriage, she might seek to influence Peter’s decisions, perhaps advocating for social causes or business reforms that align with her values. This could lead to friction with Peter, whose traditionalist outlook might clash with her progressive instincts. Alternatively, Simone could embrace the darker aspects of power, orchestrating moves to consolidate her control—potentially at the expense of those who once supported her, including Devon.

The psychological toll of this transformation would also be a rich vein to explore. Scenes of Simone grappling with isolation, haunted by her past decisions (such as the ambiguous incident with Ethan’s fall), could add depth to her character. Her enigmatic smile at the end of Season 1 suggests a confidence born of strategy, but also a loneliness that hints at the cost of her ambition.

Political Intrigue and Betrayal

The potential for family political intrigue in a new season is vast. The Kell family’s wealth and influence on Port Haven imply a microcosm of power dynamics, where alliances shift like sand. Simone’s marriage could trigger a power vacuum, prompting other family members or external forces—such as rival business tycoons or local authorities—to challenge Peter’s dominance. A subplot involving a contested will or a hidden scandal from Peter’s past could serve as a catalyst, with Simone caught in the crossfire.

Betrayal, a recurring theme in Sirens, could reach new heights. Peter might turn against Simone if he perceives her as a threat, orchestrating a plan to discredit or remove her. Conversely, Simone could betray Peter, aligning with Michaela or Devon to topple him from within. The possibility of Devon’s involvement adds another layer—will she support her sister’s rise, or will old wounds resurface, leading to a heartbreaking rift? The tension between loyalty and self-interest could drive the narrative toward a climax of shocking revelations.

Another angle might involve Ethan, who survived his fall in Season 1 but was left with significant injuries. His return, possibly seeking revenge or answers, could complicate Simone’s position further. If Ethan uncovers evidence that Simone played a role in his accident—intentional or not—it could ignite a vendetta that threatens her marriage and her safety.

Cultural and Thematic Resonance

The exploration of Simone and Peter’s relationship also offers a lens into broader themes. The series, inspired by the myth of the sirens, uses their seductive yet dangerous allure as a metaphor for the Kell family’s influence. Simone’s rise mirrors this duality—she lures Peter with her charm but may ultimately lead to his downfall. This narrative arc resonates with contemporary discussions about power, gender, and ambition, particularly in the context of wealth disparities highlighted by the show’s lavish settings.

Moreover, the show’s blend of dark humor and social commentary, as noted by critics, could deepen in a new season. The Kell family’s dysfunction might serve as a satire of elite privilege, with Simone’s outsider perspective offering a critique of their insular world. Her journey could inspire viewers to reflect on the price of success and the fragility of trust in high-stakes environments.

Fan Speculation and Industry Buzz

Since Season 1’s release, fan forums and social media platforms like X have buzzed with theories about a potential Season 2. Many praise Alcock’s performance, with one user posting, “Milly Alcock as Simone is a revelation—can’t wait to see her rule the Kell empire!” Others speculate about Michaela’s next move, with hashtags like #TeamMichaela trending alongside #SimoneRising. The show’s 16.7 million views in its first four days, per Netflix data, and its number-one ranking underscore its appeal, fueling hopes for renewal.

Industry insiders suggest a decision could come by late 2025, with production potentially starting in 2026 for a 2027 premiere. The involvement of creator Molly Smith Metzler and the strong ensemble cast, including Bacon and Moore, adds credibility to the prospect. Metzler’s track record with character-driven dramas like Maid indicates she could craft a season that builds on the emotional and narrative stakes established in the first installment.

Conclusion: A Marriage on the Brink

As of 4:41 PM +07 on Tuesday, June 17, 2025, the world awaits word on Sirens’ future. The marriage of Simone and Peter stands as a pivotal plot point, promising a season rich with conflict, power struggles, and unexpected turns. Whether Simone emerges as a triumphant leader, a tragic figure, or a catalyst for the Kell family’s collapse, her journey will undoubtedly captivate audiences. The interplay of loyalty, betrayal, and ambition within this union offers a compelling narrative that could redefine the series, cementing its place as a standout in the thriller genre. For now, fans can only speculate—and hope—that the sirens’ song will call them back for more.