The Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) is no stranger to speculation, but few rumors have sparked as much excitement as the latest buzz surrounding Spider-Man: Brand New Day. According to a January 2025 Reddit post on r/EmmaMyers, breakout star Emma Myers, known for her vibrant role as Enid Sinclair in Netflix’s Wednesday, is rumored to be playing a young Gwen Stacy in the upcoming Spider-Man film, set to swing into theaters on July 31, 2026. With fans already rallying behind Myers as the perfect fit for the iconic Marvel Comics character, the rumor has ignited debates about how Gwen Stacy might fit into Tom Holland’s Spider-Man saga, whether as a traditional love interest or a multiversal Spider-Gwen. As the MCU dives deeper into its Multiverse Saga, could Myers be the fresh face to bring Gwen Stacy to life in a new, unexpected way? Here’s everything we know about the rumor, Myers’ rise to fame, and what this casting could mean for Spider-Man: Brand New Day.

The Rumor: Emma Myers as Gwen Stacy

The rumor first gained traction on social media, particularly through a Reddit thread that garnered 759 votes and 31 comments, with fans passionately advocating for Myers to take on the role of Gwen Stacy. The post highlighted Myers’ resemblance to the animated Spider-Gwen from Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse (2018) and Across the Spider-Verse (2023), voiced by Hailee Steinfeld, noting her “different hair colors” and facial likeness to the character. Myers herself fueled the speculation years earlier, expressing in a 2022 interview her dream of playing Spider-Gwen in a live-action project. “I would love to be Spider-Gwen,” she told CBR, sparking fan campaigns that have persisted since her breakout role in Wednesday.

However, the rumor is not without competition. Reports from June 2025 suggest Stranger Things star Sadie Sink is also in contention for a Gwen Stacy variant in Spider-Man: Brand New Day, with insider Jeff Sneider claiming she might play an “alternate universe Gwen Stacy.” This has led to confusion, as Sink’s rumored role aligns with a multiversal narrative, while Myers’ casting is speculated to involve a younger, possibly mainline MCU Gwen Stacy. The lack of official confirmation from Marvel or Sony keeps the door open for Myers, with fans on X and Reddit arguing her youthful energy and acting chops make her a better fit for a teenage Gwen. Posts like “Emma Myers as Gwen Stacy would be absolutely perfect” and “She’s got that Spider-Gwen vibe” reflect the fervor surrounding her potential casting.

The Spider-Man: Brand New Day working title, “Blue Oasis,” offers a clue to Gwen’s inclusion. The title nods to the Spider-Man: Blue comic run, which centers on Peter Parker’s emotional reflections on Gwen Stacy’s tragic death. While a direct adaptation seems unlikely, the title suggests Gwen’s significance, possibly as a new love interest for Peter Parker post-No Way Home. With filming set to begin this month in Glasgow, the rumor mill is in overdrive, and Myers’ name is at the forefront.

Who Is Emma Myers?

Born on April 2, 2002, in Orlando, Florida, Emma Myers is a 23-year-old actress who began her career as a child, appearing in The Glades (2010) at age eight. Her breakout came with Wednesday (2022), where she played Enid Sinclair, the colorful, werewolf roommate of Jenna Ortega’s Wednesday Addams. Myers’ performance, blending humor, heart, and relatability, earned her widespread praise and comparisons to Gwen Stacy, particularly for her blonde, purple-streaked hair and optimistic demeanor. She followed up with roles in A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder (2024) and Family Switch (2023), showcasing her versatility in drama and comedy.

Myers’ appeal lies in her ability to embody youthful exuberance while conveying depth, making her a natural fit for Gwen Stacy, a character known for her intelligence, strength, and emotional resonance. Her expressed interest in Spider-Gwen—Gwen’s superhero alter ego from Earth-65, where she gains spider-powers—has only strengthened fans’ conviction. In a 2022 CBR interview, Myers said, “Spider-Gwen is my ultimate dream role,” citing her love for the character’s punk-rock aesthetic and heroic spirit. This passion, combined with her rising star power, has made her a fan-favorite for the role, with Reddit users noting, “She matches everything the animated Gwen Stacy, from the different hair colors to the face.”

Gwen Stacy: A Pivotal Marvel Character

Gwen Stacy, created by Stan Lee and Steve Ditko in 1965, is one of Marvel Comics’ most enduring characters, debuting in The Amazing Spider-Man #31 as Peter Parker’s first love. A college student and daughter of police captain George Stacy, Gwen is defined by her intelligence, compassion, and tragic fate—her death at the hands of the Green Goblin in The Amazing Spider-Man #121 (1973) remains a defining moment in comic history. In alternate universes, Gwen takes on new life as Spider-Gwen (or Ghost-Spider), a superhero bitten by a radioactive spider, as seen in Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse and Across the Spider-Verse.

In live-action, Gwen has been portrayed by Bryce Dallas Howard in Spider-Man 3 (2007) and Emma Stone in The Amazing Spider-Man (2012) and its 2014 sequel, where her tragic arc was adapted. Stone’s performance, opposite Andrew Garfield’s Peter Parker, cemented Gwen as a fan-favorite, with fans still clamoring for her return in projects like Spider-Man: No Way Home. The MCU, however, has yet to introduce Gwen Stacy, with Tom Holland’s Peter Parker paired with Zendaya’s MJ (Michelle Jones-Watson) since Spider-Man: Homecoming (2017).

The rumor of Myers as a young Gwen Stacy suggests a fresh take, possibly as a teenage version of the character before her college years or as a multiversal variant like Spider-Gwen. The Brand New Day comic run, which inspired the film’s title, marked a soft reboot for Spider-Man, introducing new characters and dynamics after Peter’s deal with Mephisto erased his marriage to Mary Jane. This context hints that Myers’ Gwen could be a new love interest or ally for Peter, navigating the emotional fallout of No Way Home, where Peter chose anonymity to protect MJ and Ned.

The Context of Spider-Man: Brand New Day

Spider-Man: Brand New Day, directed by Destin Daniel Cretton (Shang-Chi and the Legend of the Ten Rings) and written by Chris McKenna and Erik Sommers, picks up after Spider-Man: No Way Home (2021), where Peter Parker (Tom Holland) sacrificed his identity to protect the world via Doctor Strange’s spell. Producer Amy Pascal has teased that the film will explore Peter’s decision to prioritize being Spider-Man over his personal life, suggesting a darker, more grounded narrative. Yet, rumors of a multiversal element, including Sadie Sink’s potential role as a Gwen Stacy variant, indicate the film may blend street-level stakes with alternate realities.

The confirmed cast includes Holland, Zendaya (MJ), Jacob Batalon (Ned), Liza Colón-Zayas (The Bear), and possibly Jon Bernthal as The Punisher and Mark Ruffalo as a “Savage Hulk” villain. Rumored villains like Scorpion, Tombstone, and Mister Negative suggest a crowded, action-packed story. Myers’ rumored role as a young Gwen Stacy could position her as a new student at Midtown High, a friend or romantic interest for Peter, or even a Spider-Gwen variant teaming up with him against these threats. The “Blue Oasis” title supports Gwen’s inclusion, evoking the emotional weight of her comic book legacy.

Why Emma Myers?

Myers’ casting makes sense for several reasons. At 23, she can convincingly play a teenager, aligning with a younger Gwen Stacy introduced in Peter’s post-No Way Home world. Her performance in Wednesday showcased her ability to balance humor, vulnerability, and strength—qualities essential for Gwen, who is both a brilliant student and a tragic figure. Fans on Reddit have praised her “Spider-Gwen vibe,” citing her expressive face and dynamic energy as perfect for a live-action adaptation. Her expressed enthusiasm for the role adds credibility to the rumor, as does her growing popularity, which could draw younger audiences to the MCU.

However, the Sadie Sink rumor complicates things. Sink, 23, is also a strong contender, with reports suggesting she’ll play an “alternate universe Gwen Stacy” with a “mysterious past.” This description aligns with Spider-Gwen or a multiversal variant, while Myers’ rumored role as a “young Gwen Stacy” implies a mainline MCU version, possibly pre-powers. The distinction could allow both actresses to appear, with Myers as a teenage Gwen and Sink as a Spider-Gwen from another universe, though this remains speculative.

Critics of the Myers rumor argue she may lack the gravitas for Gwen’s tragic arc, with some preferring Sink’s proven dramatic range in Stranger Things. Others, however, see Myers’ youthful charm as ideal for a fresh, optimistic Gwen, especially if the film leans into Peter’s high school years. “Emma Myers has that spark you need for Gwen,” posted u/ImaginativeHobbyist on r/Fancast. “She’d bring heart and humor to the role.”

Challenges and Opportunities

Introducing Gwen Stacy in the MCU poses challenges. With Zendaya’s MJ as Peter’s established love interest, adding Gwen risks overcrowding the romantic narrative, especially after MJ’s memory of Peter was erased. Fans on Reddit have expressed concern about a multiversal Gwen feeling “out of place” without a mainline version first, as Gwen was never introduced in Holland’s trilogy. Myers’ younger Gwen could address this, setting her up as a friend or classmate before any romantic arc, mirroring Gwen’s comic book role as a Midtown High student.

The multiversal angle, hinted at by Sink’s rumored role and the film’s ensemble cast, opens exciting possibilities. Myers as a young Gwen could interact with a Spider-Gwen variant, creating a dynamic where Peter grapples with multiple versions of a character tied to his comic book past. Alternatively, she could play a Gwen who gains powers, becoming Spider-Gwen within the MCU’s main timeline, a twist that would align with Pascal’s “fresh start” vision.

Fan and Industry Reactions

The rumor has sparked a lively debate online. On X, fans have posted, “Emma Myers as Gwen Stacy? Sign her up!” while others advocate for Sink or even Milly Alcock (House of the Dragon), who was previously rumored for Spider-Gwen. Reddit threads highlight Myers’ visual similarity to the animated Gwen, with u/Sachit77 noting her “perfect casting” for a live-action Spider-Gwen. Industry insiders, however, remain cautious, with no official confirmation from Marvel or Sony. The IMDb listing for Sink’s role underscores the speculative nature of both rumors, noting that casting calls describe a “sharp, free-spirited woman” without specifying Gwen.

What’s Next?

As Spider-Man: Brand New Day begins filming, the truth about Myers’ involvement will likely remain under wraps until Marvel or Sony makes an announcement. The film’s multiversal and grounded elements suggest a bold new chapter for Spider-Man, with Gwen Stacy—whether played by Myers, Sink, or another actress—poised to play a pivotal role. Myers’ potential casting would mark a significant step in her career, elevating her from Netflix star to MCU mainstay, while bringing a beloved character to a new generation.

Whether Myers swings into the MCU as a young Gwen Stacy or a web-slinging Spider-Gwen, the rumor has fans buzzing with anticipation. As one X user put it, “Emma Myers as Gwen would be a game-changer. Let’s see her save the day with Spidey!” With Spider-Man: Brand New Day set to redefine Peter Parker’s journey, Myers could be the key to unlocking Gwen Stacy’s long-awaited MCU debut.