Santa Monica’s Barker Hangar buzzed with anticipation on January 4, 2026, as the 31st Annual Critics Choice Awards unfolded under the sharp wit of host Chelsea Handler. Amid a night of surprises and standout victories, one moment captured hearts worldwide: Jacob Elordi, the 28-year-old Australian actor, clinched Best Supporting Actor for his haunting portrayal of the Creature in Guillermo del Toro’s Frankenstein. Clutching the gleaming trophy, Elordi stepped to the microphone, visibly stunned, and began with a raw, authentic exclamation: “Bloody hell. I really didn’t plan for this….” What followed was a heartfelt tribute that not only celebrated his breakthrough but underscored the transformative power of cinema’s most enduring monster tale.

people.com

instagram.com

instagram.com

Elordi’s win marked his first major acting award, a monumental milestone for the rising star best known for teen dramas like Euphoria and The Kissing Booth. Yet, in del Toro’s gothic masterpiece, he shed his matinee idol image entirely, disappearing into layers of prosthetics and profound emotion to embody Mary Shelley’s tragic Creature. “Thank you, Guillermo del Toro. I love you. We all love you. You made my dreams when I was 11. I’m so happy to be here,” Elordi continued, his voice cracking with genuine gratitude. He wrapped with a nod to his parents: “Thank you, Mom and Dad. Cheers.” The speech, unscripted and brimming with vulnerability, drew thunderous applause and instantly went viral, resonating as a reminder that even in Hollywood’s polished arena, authenticity shines brightest.

The victory was no small feat. Elordi triumphed over a formidable field: Benicio del Toro and Sean Penn (both for One Battle After Another), Paul Mescal (Hamnet), Adam Sandler (Jay Kelly), and Stellan Skarsgård (Sentimental Value). Critics hailed it as an upset, with outlets like Gold Derby noting how Elordi’s “monstrous” performance upended expectations in a category stacked with veterans. Historically, Critics Choice winners in this category boast an impeccable track record—every victor for three decades has earned an Oscar nomination, and the last nine have claimed the Academy Award itself. With SAG nominations looming and Golden Globes on January 11 (where Elordi is also nominated), this win catapults him into serious Oscar contention.

To grasp the magnitude, delve into Frankenstein itself—a passion project decades in the making for visionary director Guillermo del Toro. Released on Netflix in November 2025 after a limited theatrical run, the film reimagines Shelley’s 1818 novel with del Toro’s signature blend of gothic horror, visual splendor, and deep humanity. Oscar Isaac stars as the ambitious Dr. Victor Frankenstein, whose hubris unleashes tragedy, while Mia Goth, Christoph Waltz, and others round out a stellar ensemble. But it’s Elordi’s Creature that steals the soul of the story—a reanimated being pieced from corpses, towering yet tender, raging yet profoundly lonely.

people.com

people.com

vanityfair.com

nerdist.com

Del Toro, long obsessed with the tale, first dreamed of adapting it years ago, initially eyeing Doug Jones for the role. Production twists led to Andrew Garfield’s brief attachment before scheduling conflicts (post-SAG strikes) paved the way for Elordi. The transformation was grueling: nearly 10 hours daily in makeup, involving 42 prosthetics to craft the Creature’s scarred, imposing physique. Del Toro likened it to “ceremonial guard,” invoking the monster’s tragic essence. Elordi, recommended by a hairstylist from Priscilla, embraced the challenge, channeling personal vulnerability into a performance critics call “battered nobility” and “the film’s invigorating volts.”

Reviews rave about the film’s lavish visuals—stunning cinematography, intricate production design (which also won at Critics Choice)—and emotional depth. Rotten Tomatoes consensus praises it as a “lavish epic” finding humanity in the monster, with Elordi’s standout turn earning universal acclaim. Some note pacing issues or deviations from the novel, but the consensus is clear: del Toro delivers a heartfelt, visually breathtaking ode to isolation and creation’s perils.

Elordi’s journey to this pinnacle is a classic tale of evolution. Born in Brisbane, Australia, in 1997, he burst onto screens with The Kissing Booth trilogy (2018-2021), charming as bad-boy Noah Flynn. Euphoria (2019-present) showcased darker edges as abusive Nate Jacobs, earning praise for nuance amid controversy. Films like Priscilla (2023) as Elvis Presley proved his dramatic chops, but Frankenstein represents transcendence—proving he can anchor prestige horror with raw power.

The Critics Choice night amplified Frankenstein‘s momentum, netting four awards: Supporting Actor, Production Design, Costume Design, and Hair & Makeup. It tied with Ryan Coogler’s Sinners for technical dominance, while One Battle After Another claimed Best Picture. Yet Elordi’s win stole the emotional spotlight, echoing themes of outsider longing mirrored in his Creature.

Social media erupted post-win. Fans shared clips of the speech, memes of Elordi’s shocked “Bloody hell,” and tributes to his growth. Australian media celebrated a national hero’s rise, while del Toro tweeted congratulations, calling Elordi “grace incarnate.” The moment humanized awards season’s glamour, reminding us of dreams nurtured in childhood—Elordi, inspired by del Toro’s films at 11, now honored by his idol.

As Oscar buzz builds, Elordi’s trajectory excites. Upcoming projects hint at versatility, but Frankenstein cements his leading-man status beyond heartthrob labels. In a season of heavyweights, his vulnerable monster may prove unforgettable.

This triumph isn’t just Elordi’s—it’s a victory for bold reinventions, for actors daring physical and emotional extremes, for stories probing humanity’s darkest corners. As del Toro’s Creature learns awe and agony, Elordi has awakened his own potential, thrilling audiences anew. The monster lives—and so does a star’s luminous future.