What if Emma Myers Played Wednesday Addams? A Fun What-If Scenario for Fans of the Addams Family

The Addams Family franchise has long been known for its quirky characters and dark humor, with Wednesday Addams standing out as one of the most iconic figures. From her distinctive style to her dry wit, Wednesday has captivated audiences for decades. But what if a different actress had stepped into her shoes in the recent Netflix series Wednesday? Enter Emma Myers, an actress known for her breakout role in Wednesday as Enid Sinclair, the bright and bubbly werewolf. But what if Emma Myers played the role of the iconic goth teenager Wednesday Addams instead? Let’s explore this fun hypothetical scenario.

Emma Myers’ Unique Take on Wednesday Addams

Wednesday Addams, as portrayed by Jenna Ortega, has quickly become a fan favorite for her sarcastic humor, her signature black attire, and her deadpan expression. Ortega brought a fresh, darker interpretation of the character to life, blending the gothic nature of the classic Wednesday with an intriguing, almost emotionally complex side. But how would Emma Myers—whose portrayal of Enid was the complete opposite of Wednesday’s dark, mysterious personality—take on the role of the Addams Family daughter?

Emma Myers has an undeniable charm and wit, which helped make Enid Sinclair one of the most beloved characters in Wednesday. Her bubbly and colorful personality would certainly create an interesting contrast if placed in the dark, brooding world of Wednesday Addams. Imagining Emma in the role of Wednesday might give us a lighter, more cheerful take on the character, without losing the sarcastic edge that fans love. Her natural ability to balance humor and heart could bring a new dimension to Wednesday’s character, potentially leaning more into the role’s witty, slightly less serious aspects while still keeping the sharpness and intelligence that define her.

The Enid-Wednesday Contrast: Could Emma Myers Balance the Dark and Light?

One of the major draws of Wednesday on Netflix is the contrast between the titular character and Enid Sinclair, who is played by Emma Myers. Enid, with her vibrant colors, optimism, and bright personality, complements Wednesday’s darker, reserved nature. The pairing of the two characters works so well because of their contrasting personalities, which makes them a memorable duo.

But what if Emma Myers had taken on the role of Wednesday instead? It could have added a unique dimension to the series, playing with the contrast between her natural sunny disposition and the character’s usual gloom. Fans may have seen a different type of Wednesday, one who still has a sharp wit and an affinity for the dark, but who perhaps uses her brightness as a way to navigate the chaos around her.

The Aesthetic: How Would Emma Myers’ Wednesday Look?

Wednesday’s signature aesthetic—black clothing, pale skin, and braided pigtails—is key to her identity. In Emma Myers’ hands, we could imagine a more colorful twist on this classic look. Maybe Emma’s Wednesday would wear subtly brighter versions of the iconic outfit—blacker-than-black with a hint of deep purple or dark blue. It would still keep the Gothic edge but might allow for more playful experimentation with fashion while staying true to the essence of the character.

Emma’s long, light brown hair as Enid could also be styled differently to reflect the serious, somewhat rebellious vibe of Wednesday. The contrast between Enid’s colorful persona and Wednesday’s more morose style would make for a truly unique interpretation that fans would either love or be curious to see unfold on-screen.

The Character Dynamics: Emma Myers and the Addams Family

Emma’s portrayal of Enid showed that she has a knack for playing off of other actors, especially when it comes to contrasting personalities. If she were to take on Wednesday, the dynamic between her and the other members of the Addams family could be fascinating. Imagine the chemistry between Emma’s Wednesday and Catherine Zeta-Jones’ Morticia Addams, with their complex mother-daughter relationship, or between her and Luis Guzmán’s Gomez Addams, with his loving yet sometimes over-the-top fatherly behavior.

While Emma Myers may bring a lighter side to the character, it’s also likely that her version of Wednesday would still share a strong connection to her family. The dark humor, the intense loyalty, and the quirky love for the bizarre would likely still remain in Emma’s portrayal, all while perhaps adding a touch more playfulness to the character’s interactions.

Fan Reactions: What Would They Think?

Of course, the true question is: how would Wednesday fans react to Emma Myers stepping into the role? Jenna Ortega’s portrayal of Wednesday has been so beloved that it might be hard for fans to imagine someone else in the role. However, Emma Myers’ fresh energy and talent would likely bring a new perspective to the character, one that could still fit within the established world of the Addams family while offering something new.

With Emma’s skills as an actress, there’s no doubt she could deliver Wednesday’s biting sarcasm and rebellious nature while also adding a subtle lightness that might be refreshing in a character so often portrayed as dark and intense. Fans may even enjoy seeing the contrast between Wednesday’s bleakness and Enid’s enthusiasm—only this time, they would be seeing it through Emma’s unique take on the character.

Conclusion: Emma Myers as Wednesday Addams—A Fun, Fresh Take

While Jenna Ortega’s portrayal of Wednesday will undoubtedly go down in history as an unforgettable take on the iconic character, imagining Emma Myers in the role adds a whole new layer of fun to the conversation. Emma could bring a more playful, bubbly, yet still sarcastic version of Wednesday to life—creating a fascinating contrast to the character’s usual dark and moody nature. The idea of Emma Myers playing Wednesday might just be an exciting twist that fans didn’t know they wanted, making it an interesting “what if” scenario for those who love the Addams Family universe.

What do you think? Could Emma Myers have nailed the role of Wednesday Addams, or do you think Jenna Ortega was perfect for the part? Let us know your thoughts in the comments!