The Witcher fandom is still in mourning mode over Henry Cavill’s departure, and it looks like they’re not the only ones struggling to accept the change. Freya Allan, the talented actress behind Ciri, has opened up about how much she misses working with Cavill—and let’s just say, fans couldn’t agree more!

With The Witcher Season 4 on the horizon, Netflix is pushing forward with Liam Hemsworth as Geralt, but can the show ever recover from losing its most beloved star? And more importantly, is there any chance Cavill could return?

Let’s dive into Freya Allan’s comments, the backlash against Netflix, and why #BringBackCavill is still trending among furious fans.

Freya Allan Speaks Out – “We Really Miss the Real Geralt”

Since Henry Cavill’s shocking exit from The Witcher, cast members have mostly stayed silent on the matter. However, in a recent interview, Freya Allan didn’t hold back her feelings.

👉 She admitted she misses working with Cavill and felt lucky to have had him as Geralt during the show’s first three seasons.

👉 She wished Netflix would bring him back, acknowledging that Cavill’s presence was a major part of what made The Witcher special.

👉 She praised Cavill’s dedication to the role, noting that he deeply respected the Witcher lore, which made him the perfect Geralt.

These comments hit home for fans, who have been vocal about their frustration over Cavill’s departure. If even the cast is struggling to adjust, what does that mean for the future of the show?

Henry Cavill: The Ultimate Geralt – Why Fans Won’t Let Go

The reason Cavill’s exit hurts so much is simple—he wasn’t just an actor playing Geralt; he was Geralt.

🔥 He was a die-hard Witcher fan long before Netflix even announced the series.
🔥 He fought for book and game accuracy, often pushing back against creative changes.
🔥 His performance was legendary, perfectly capturing Geralt’s strength, sarcasm, and emotional depth.

From the moment he stepped onto the screen, fans knew they were witnessing something special. Now, with his departure, many are left wondering: Why even continue watching?

The Netflix Controversy – Did They Push Cavill Out?

While Netflix claimed Cavill’s departure was a personal decision, rumors tell a different story.

🔴 Creative Differences – Cavill was reportedly unhappy with how the writers strayed from the original books, clashing with them over key story changes.

🔴 Lack of Respect for the Lore – The writers allegedly mocked the source material, frustrating both Cavill and the fans.

🔴 A Toxic Work Environment? – Some insiders hinted that Netflix didn’t value Cavill’s input, making it harder for him to stay.

This only fueled the outrage from fans, with many blaming Netflix for losing the one person who truly understood Geralt.

Can Liam Hemsworth Fill Cavill’s Boots?

Now, let’s talk about the biggest challenge facing Season 4—can Liam Hemsworth possibly live up to Henry Cavill’s legacy?

Here’s the brutal truth: it’s an uphill battle.

🚨 Fans are already rejecting him, refusing to accept a new Geralt.
🚨 He lacks Cavill’s deep knowledge of the Witcher world, which could impact his portrayal.
🚨 He’ll have to win over an audience that’s actively rooting against him.

To be fair, Hemsworth is a talented actor, and it’s not his fault he’s stepping into this impossible situation. But even the best actor can’t fix a broken fanbase.

If Netflix thinks they can just swap out Cavill and move on, they seriously underestimated the passion of Witcher fans.

Will Netflix Ever Bring Cavill Back?

With all the backlash, the biggest question is: Could Netflix actually reverse their decision and bring back Henry Cavill?

🤔 Possible? – Technically, yes. If the backlash continues and viewership drops, Netflix could make a deal with Cavill to return.

😞 Realistic? – Sadly, not likely. Cavill has already moved on to his new Warhammer 40K project with Amazon, and it’s clear he was deeply frustrated with The Witcher’s creative direction.

Unless Netflix dramatically changes leadership and creative direction, the dream of Cavill returning as Geralt may never come true.

Final Thoughts – “We Will Always Miss the Real Geralt”

Freya Allan said what we’re all thinking—Henry Cavill is The Witcher, and no one can replace him.

Netflix made a huge mistake letting him go, and now they’re left with an angry fanbase, a struggling franchise, and a new Geralt that nobody asked for.

🔥 Will you still watch Season 4 without Cavill?
🔥 Should Netflix fight to bring him back?
🔥 Or is it time to let go and move on?

Let us know in the comments! #BringBackCavill 🐺⚔️