Modern fans’ heightened scrutiny might have turned Hugh Jackman’s Wolverine casting controversial.

Since Hugh Jackman’s debut as Wolverine in 2000’s X-Men, the actor has not only become synonymous with the adamantium-clawed mutant but also a Marvel staple set to appear in Ryan Reynolds’ upcoming Deadpool & Wolverine. Through his Marvel tenure, Jackman has won over audiences with his sheer commitment to his role, as well as his charisma and physicality.

However, looking back at his casting journey, it certainly hasn’t been the smoothest transition for him. Jackman was initially rejected because of his 6’3” height since his comic book character was only 5’3”. It is now believed that if Jackman had been cast as Wolverine in the modern era, Kevin Feige would have witnessed some backlash and controversy over such a drastic deviation from the comics.

Hugh Jackman was Initially Rejected as Wolverine for His Height 

Despite becoming one of the most beloved Marvel characters of all time, Hugh Jackman’s casting as Wolverine was plagued with uncertainty and rejection. According to reports from EW, Jackman had initially flown to Toronto to audition for the lead role of Wolverine, after Dougray Scott had dropped out of his mutant role, due to scheduling issues for Mission: Impossible 2.

However, ever since Dougray Scott had left midway after being cast as Wolverine, Marvel heads, although desperate, were a bit hesitant to cast the next star. This led them to be reluctant about Hugh Jackman who faced unprecedented challenges during his audition. Reading lines for Bryan Singer in the director’s trailer with screenwriter Tom DeSanto, Jackman recalled how people were pissed to audition once again.

He’s just going, ‘Quiet… Quieter… Quieter.’ By the end, I couldn’t even hear myself. I could tell he was like, Why on my lunch hour am I auditioning some guy for a part that I’ve already cast? He was pissed off. Jackman reflected. 

Eventually, Hugh Jackman was rejected after his audition, due to his significant height difference with his comic book character. According to reports, Jackman stands at 6’3” whereas his character has a famously diminutive stature of 5’3” in the comics. Nonetheless, Kevin Feige noted that as desperation crept in, his then-boss Lauren Shuler Donner wanted to cast Jackman despite initially rejecting him.

There was a scramble to get our Wolverine. Lauren [Shuler Donner, his boss,] was very excited about this Australian guy, who had been rejected initially. In my memory, one of the main reasons was that he was too tall. Wolverine in the comics is called ‘Lil’ Fireplugs’ sometimes. He’s a short guy. But they were desperate. Feige stated. 

Finally, Hugh Jackman landed his career-defining role as the Marvel superhero, who is now set to venture into the MCU with the forthcoming film Deadpool & Wolverine.

Kevin Feige Might Have Faced Backlash in the Modern Era for Hugh Jackman’s Casting

Meanwhile, although Hugh Jackman’s casting story serves as a hopeful reminder to newcomers in the industry, it is believed that Kevin Feige‘s decision to hire the star as Wolverine in the modern day would have led to controversies. Considering how the studio gave in to their desperation and significantly deviated from the comics, based on height difference, the casting would have led to intense criticism in today’s era.

It’s no secret that in the modern world of heightened fan scrutiny, deviations from sources can provoke intense reactions. And considering how Marvel took a major departure from the comic material, fans might not have taken this casting decision lightly. In today’s cinematic landscape, where comic book adaptations are scrutinized under watchful eyes, modern audiences’ desire for perfection might have stripped the world of Jackman’s charismatic portrayal as Wolverine.

Considering how fans expressed their disappointment in Marvel’s depiction of Mandarin in Iron Man 3, the portrayal of Dr. Doom, and even their resentment for the depiction of Jarvis, via Reddit; people might have called out Hugh Jackman for being cast as Wolverine. But thankfully, Kevin Feige’s bold move in a different era solidified Jackman’s appearance, not just in Hollywood, but even in the hearts of millions.

Deadpool & Wolverine is set to release on July 26, 2024.