The Titans series on Netflix may have had its fair share of ups and downs, but one thing it absolutely nailed was the portrayal of Donna Troy, aka Wonder Girl. Among the many adaptations of DC’s legendary heroes, Titans delivered one of the most compelling, nuanced, and powerful versions of Donna Troy ever seen in live-action.

Played to perfection by Conor Leslie, Donna embodied the strength, wisdom, and warrior spirit that makes her such an iconic character in DC lore. She was more than just a sidekick to Wonder Woman—she was a hero in her own right. And while the show gave her moments to shine, many fans agree that Donna Troy deserved even more screen time, especially alongside Aqualad and the unexplored Themyscira-Atlantis connection.

Let’s dive into what made Titans’ Donna Troy so special, how she was one of the few things the series got right, and why a Themyscira-Atlantis crossover could have been legendary.

🔥 Conor Leslie’s Donna Troy – The Perfect Wonder Girl

From the moment Conor Leslie stepped onto the screen as Donna Troy, it was clear that she was a perfect fit for the role.

She radiated strength and confidence, embodying the Amazonian warrior legacy.
She had an undeniable presence, balancing warmth, humor, and battle-hardened experience.
Her dynamic with Dick Grayson (Brenton Thwaites) was electric, showing their shared history as Titans while teasing deeper connections.

Unlike some other adaptations, Titans showcased Donna as more than just Wonder Woman’s protégée. She was her own person, with her own sense of justice, her own moral dilemmas, and her own powerful moments in battle.

Yet, despite all of this… Titans never gave Donna the full spotlight she deserved.

💔 The Biggest Problem? Donna Troy Was Underserved

Despite being one of the strongest characters in Titans, Donna Troy never got enough screen time or proper development.

1. Her Death Was a Huge Disservice

One of the biggest complaints from fans was how Titans handled Donna’s death in Season 2.

Instead of going out in an epic battle worthy of an Amazon, Donna was killed by electricity while saving people from a collapsing structure. It felt… cheap. A warrior who had fought gods and monsters shouldn’t die from something so underwhelming.

Thankfully, Titans brought Donna back in Season 3, but by then, the damage had been done. Her arc was rushed, and the show never fully explored her true potential as a leading figure in the Titans.

2. Not Enough Time with Aqualad

Fans were robbed of what could have been an amazing dynamic between Donna and Aqualad (Garth, played by Drew Van Acker).

In the flashbacks of Season 2, we saw glimpses of their romance and shared history, but it was cut short far too soon. The chemistry between Donna and Aqualad was natural and engaging, and had the show given them more time, they could have been one of the most compelling DC couples in live-action history.

Their story ended abruptly, leaving many fans wanting more.

And that leads us to the biggest missed opportunity in Titans—a Themyscira-Atlantis crossover.

🌊 The Themyscira-Atlantis Crossover That Could Have Changed Everything

The DC Universe has two of the most fascinating ancient civilizations—Themyscira and Atlantis. And yet, live-action has barely explored their potential connection.

Think about it:

The Amazons and the Atlanteans are both ancient warrior societies with rich histories and powerful heroes.
Donna Troy (Wonder Girl) and Garth (Aqualad) were both young champions of these two civilizations.
A story that brought them together in a major way could have added incredible depth to Titans, showing how these two mythological societies view the modern world.

Imagine a plot where:

Donna and Aqualad unite their people to fight a shared enemy.
We get to see Atlantean warriors fighting alongside Amazons, something that has rarely been explored in DC media.
Wonder Woman and Aquaman are mentioned as legends of their respective homes, while Donna and Garth fight to make their own names known.

It would have elevated Titans to another level, bringing a cinematic Game of Thrones-style war between Themyscira and Atlantis into the mix.

But instead, the show missed this opportunity, leaving fans wondering what could have been.

🎬 What’s Next for Donna Troy and Aqualad?

Although Titans has ended, there’s still hope for Donna Troy and Aqualad in live-action.

1. Could They Return in the DCU?

With James Gunn rebooting the DC Universe, there’s a possibility that Wonder Girl and Aqualad could return in a future DCU project.

A live-action Young Justice series could bring back these characters in a fresh way.
A HBO Max Wonder Woman spin-off exploring Themyscira’s past could reintroduce Donna Troy.
James Gunn’s Aquaman reboot could feature a proper Aqualad, setting up a new Titans-style story.

2. An HBO Max Miniseries?

Given the popularity of Conor Leslie’s portrayal, an HBO Max mini-series focusing on Donna Troy could be a huge hit.

It could explore her time in Themyscira before joining the Titans.
It could finally give her the epic warrior arc she deserves.
And, most importantly, it could finally give us that Themyscira-Atlantis crossover fans have always wanted.

📢 Final Thoughts – Did Titans Waste Donna Troy and Aqualad?

There’s no doubt that Titans had glimpses of greatness, and one of those shining moments was Conor Leslie’s Wonder Girl.

But the series never fully embraced her potential, and it left us with more questions than answers about her place in the DC Universe.

Did Titans waste Donna Troy and Aqualad? Absolutely.

Could a Themyscira-Atlantis crossover have changed everything? 100%.

But with the new DCU reboot, there’s still hope that we’ll see these characters reach their full potential in live-action.

Now, we just have to wait and see what the future holds.

What Do You Think?

🔥 Should Donna Troy get her own DCU series?
⚡ Would you have loved a Themyscira-Atlantis crossover?
💬 Drop your thoughts below and let’s talk! 👇