Shocking Truth: Why Marvel Faced Backlash Over Introducing a Black Captain America Onscreen – Comic Book Writer Speaks Out

Anthony Mackie is making his film debut as the first Black Captain America decades after Marvel’s initial “resistance” to the change.

Anthony Mackie is the 1st Black on-screen 'Captain America.' Why his historic role is controversial.

Anthony Mackie is officially making his film debut as the first Black Captain America in Captain America: Brave New World. The new Marvel film hit theaters on Valentine’s Day and opened with $100 million in the U.S. and $192 million globally.

The achievement is a significant milestone for Mark Waid, 62, who first introduced the concept of a Black Captain America in the 1998 comic book Captain America: Sentinel of Liberty. Reflecting on Sam Wilson’s initial donning of the Captain America mantle, Waid recalls encountering “a little bit of resistance” from Marvel when he first pitched the idea in the ’90s, NBC News reports.

“Not because anybody disbelieved the message,” Waid explained to TODAY.com. “Not because anybody at Marvel was on the wrong side of history here, but just because when you’re dealing with a corporate character like that, it’s going to go through many creators’ hands over his 80 years of existence.”

Captain America was originally introduced in March 1941 as a blonde-haired, blue-eyed white male with a chiseled jawline and muscular build, embodying the idealized image of America at the time. In the MCU, Chris Evans’ Captain America passed the mantle to Anthony Mackie’s Falcon in the 2019 film Avengers: Endgame.

Anthony Mackie is the 1st Black on-screen 'Captain America.' Why his historic role is controversial.

Within Marvel, Waid remembers his story of Falcon taking on the role of Captain America, which was “very well received.” However, outside the company, he faced “a little bit of pushback” from fans and readers, some of whom questioned the decision, saying, “Well, this is not Captain America. I don’t know what you’re trying to say.”

“There’s been a lot more trolling, a lot more blowback,” Waid says of critics who have an issue with a Black Captain America. “A lot of organized fandom full of angry white guys who are not happy that they are being quote, unquote, eclipsed by people of color, which is bulls–t.”

Waid hopes that Captain America’s fight for inclusion “gets easier” since the fictional character was created to represent “the best part of all of us.”

“Captain America can be an Asian man. Captain America can be a woman. Captain America could be anyone who stands for the ideals that Captain America stands for,” Waid explains.

“As long as they’re an American at heart and fight for the American way … the way we wish truly was the dream as opposed to what racism and bigotry has sort of poisoned that well.”

Mackie agrees, noting that his Captain America leads with two important things: “Compassion and empathy.”

“I feel like today, we could all use a little compassion and empathy,” he adds.

Related Posts

Jodie Foster ‘to tell sons who their father is when they turn 21,’ claims mother of the man who took the secret to his grave

Oscar winner Jodie Foster plans to tell her beloved sons who their father is when they turn 21, the mother of the star’s best friend claimed today….

Jodie Foster Says Her Sons Are ‘Insecure’ About Their Fledgling Careers but She’s ‘Thrilled’ for Their ‘Future’

Jodie Foster isn’t sure what kind of work her sons will pursue, but she supports them every step of the way. Speaking to PEOPLE at the 76th annual…

Jodie Foster’s Dating History: From Coparent Cydney Bernard to Wife Alexandra Hedison

Jodie Foster, the two-time Academy Award-winning actress known for her performances in The Silence of the Lambs, Taxi Driver and more, has primarily kept her personal life out of the…

Blake Shelton & Gwen Stefani Take Sons on “Unforgettable” Ozarks Family Vacation

Take us with you! The Voice alums and married couple Gwen Stefani and Blake Shelton just took a gorgeous trip to the Ozarks to spend some family time with Stefani’s sons Zuma, 16,…

Kelly Clarkson and Dwayne Johnson Honor Loretta Lynn With a Moving Country Duet

Two Weeks After Loretta Lynn’s Passing, Kelly Clarkson & Dwayne Johnson Gave Her the Tribute No One Saw Coming When country music lost its queen, the world…

Blake Shelton Vows To “Stay Country Or Die Tryin’” In Fiery New Song Published Apr 11, 2025 By Miranda Raye

Blake Shelton Is Gearing Up To Release A New Album On May 9 Blake Shelton is vowing to “Stay Country or Die Tryin’” as he prepares to release…