The family of a murdered Ohio dentist and his wife expressed no surprise at the arrest of her ex-husband, a Chicago doctor, in connection with the couple’s deaths, according to recent reports. Michael David McKee, 39, was taken into custody on January 10, 2026, in Illinois and charged with two counts of murder in the shooting deaths of Spencer Tepe, 37, and Monique Tepe, 39. The victims were discovered deceased in their Westerville home on December 30, 2025, sparking a swift investigation that led authorities across state lines. While McKee has pleaded not guilty, sources close to the Tepe family indicate they had long anticipated his involvement, citing a history of strained relations stemming from his divorce from Monique.
Spencer Tepe, a respected dentist practicing in the Columbus area, and his wife Monique, a former nurse, were found shot to death in their upscale suburban residence just days after Christmas. Police responded to a welfare check initiated by concerned relatives who hadn’t heard from the couple. Upon arrival, officers discovered the bodies in what appeared to be a targeted attack, with no signs of forced entry or robbery. The Franklin County Coroner’s Office confirmed both died from multiple gunshot wounds, ruling the deaths homicides. The couple, married since 2022, shared a young child from Monique’s previous marriage to McKee, adding a layer of complexity to the case. Neighbors described the Tepes as a quiet, family-oriented pair, active in local community events and known for their involvement in dental charity work.
McKee, a surgeon based in Chicago, was arrested approximately 300 miles from the crime scene at his home in Illinois. Authorities executed a search warrant, seizing evidence including electronic devices and vehicles believed to link him to the murders. Westerville Police Chief Charles Chandler, in a January 11 press conference, stated, “This was a meticulous investigation involving multiple agencies. We believe we have the right individual in custody.” McKee was extradited to Ohio on January 12 and appeared in Franklin County Court for an initial hearing, where he entered a not guilty plea. His bond was set at $2 million, and he remains detained pending trial. Prosecutors have not yet disclosed a motive, but court documents hint at “domestic discord” and financial disputes from the 2020 divorce between McKee and Monique.
Family members of the victims have remained largely private, but anonymous sources told the New York Post that relatives “all expected” McKee’s arrest. “It was only a matter of time,” one family friend reportedly said, alluding to ongoing tensions post-divorce. Monique’s family, in particular, had expressed concerns about McKee’s behavior in the past, including allegations of harassment detailed in divorce filings. Spencer Tepe’s relatives issued a statement through their attorney: “We are devastated by this senseless loss and grateful for the swift action of law enforcement. Our focus now is on healing and supporting the child left behind.” The couple’s young daughter, aged 4, is now in the care of Monique’s family, with custody proceedings expected to unfold separately.
The investigation unfolded rapidly. Surveillance footage from the neighborhood showed a vehicle matching one registered to McKee near the Tepe home around the time of the murders. Digital forensics played a key role, with phone records placing McKee in Ohio on December 30. Illinois State Police assisted in the arrest, coordinating with Ohio authorities to ensure a peaceful takedown. McKee, who specializes in orthopedic surgery at a Chicago hospital, was placed on administrative leave following his arrest. Hospital officials declined to comment, citing privacy laws.
This case has drawn comparisons to other high-profile domestic violence incidents involving professionals. Legal experts note that McKee’s status as a physician could complicate jury selection, given potential biases toward medical professionals. Defense attorney Mark O’Mara, not involved in the case, told Fox News, “Prosecutors will need ironclad evidence to overcome any sympathy. But if the digital trail is as strong as reported, it’s an uphill battle for the defense.” McKee’s legal team has argued for his release on bond, citing his clean record and community ties, but the judge denied the request, deeming him a flight risk.
Background on the individuals involved paints a picture of contrasting lives. Spencer Tepe graduated from Ohio State University’s College of Dentistry in 2012 and built a successful practice specializing in family dentistry. Known for his volunteer work with underserved communities, he was remembered in obituaries as “compassionate and dedicated.” Monique Tepe, formerly Monique McKee, worked as a registered nurse before focusing on family life after their marriage. The couple met through mutual friends in 2021 and wed in a small ceremony in Columbus. McKee, originally from Ohio, moved to Chicago after medical school at Northwestern University. His divorce from Monique was finalized in 2020, with shared custody of their daughter.
Court records from the divorce reveal acrimony over finances and parenting. Monique sought full custody, citing McKee’s demanding work schedule, while he countered with claims of alienation. A 2021 restraining order filed by Monique alleged verbal threats, though it was later dropped. These details have resurfaced in media coverage, suggesting a possible motive rooted in resentment. Prosecutors may use this history to build a narrative of premeditation.
Community response in Westerville has been one of shock and mourning. A vigil held on January 5 at the local park drew hundreds, with candles lit in memory of the Tepes. Spencer’s dental practice announced a temporary closure, with patients redirected to colleagues. Friends described Monique as “vibrant and loving,” often volunteering at animal shelters. The tragedy has prompted discussions on domestic violence awareness, with local organizations like the Ohio Domestic Violence Network offering resources.
Legal proceedings are expected to move forward quickly. McKee’s next court date is scheduled for February 15, 2026, for a preliminary hearing. If convicted, he faces life imprisonment without parole under Ohio law for aggravated murder. The case has attracted national attention, with true-crime podcasts and TV segments dissecting the details. “Dateline NBC” has already announced an episode focusing on the story.
As the investigation continues, questions linger about any accomplices or additional evidence. Police have not ruled out further arrests, though McKee remains the sole suspect. For the Tepe family, the arrest brings a measure of closure, but the road to justice is long. In a statement, Spencer’s brother said, “We trusted the system, and it delivered. Now, we heal.” The case serves as a stark reminder of how domestic disputes can escalate fatally, even among seemingly stable professionals.
In Chicago, McKee’s colleagues expressed disbelief. A fellow surgeon told local media, “He was professional and focused. This doesn’t align with the man I knew.” His defense may hinge on alibi claims or challenging the evidence chain. As trial preparations begin, the public watches closely, awaiting revelations that could explain the motive behind this tragic double homicide.
The impact on the surviving child is profound. Child psychologists emphasize the need for stability, with family members stepping in to provide support. Advocacy groups have called for increased funding for domestic violence prevention in light of the case.
Ultimately, the arrest of Michael McKee underscores the hidden dangers in fractured relationships. As Ohio moves toward trial, the Tepe family’s quiet resolve contrasts with the sensational headlines. Justice, if served, may bring peace, but the scars remain.
