etflix’s “Ransom Canyon” galloped to the number one spot on the streamer’s TV charts when it debuted on April 17. The buzz about the contemporary Western romance, which follows three Texan ranching families, has sparked immediate comparisons to Taylor Sheridan’s “Yellowstone” franchise. Even though the series does seem to echo Sheridan’s neo-Western empire, one star says that “Ransom Canyon” is carving its own path.

‘Ransom Canyon’ Is in ‘Its Own World, Its Own Universe,’ Claims Star Jack Schumacher

Netflix
The ranching backdrop of “Ransom Canyon” definitely invites “Yellowstone” parallels. Both feature families fighting to save ancestral land from modern threats. However, according to star Jack Schumacher, who plays drifter Yancy Grey, the comparisons between the two series are missing the mark.

“Those ‘Yellowstone’ shows are incredible—I don’t know anyone who does not like them, myself included,” he told Distractify. “But ‘Ransom Canyon’ is its own world, its own universe. … I think if you’re a fan of ‘Yellowstone,’ you’re absolutely going to be a fan of Ransom, too—and you’ll enjoy the differences!”

While Sheridan’s “Yellowstone” universe thrives on gritty violence and political rants, “Ransom Canyon” leans into romance and emotional depth. Based on Jodi Thomas’ 2015 novel, which predates “Yellowstone’s” 2018 debut, Ransom’s roots are distinct. The focus is on love stories, not just land wars. And that’s what sets it apart.

Netflix’s Latest Hit Is Not a ‘Yellowstone’ Knockoff

Schumacher pointed out that “Ransom Canyon” wasn’t “a knockoff ” but a fresh take on the Western genre. Unlike “Yellowstone’s” male-driven intensity,” Schumacher says the Netflix series embraces the “female gaze.”

The series weaves three love stories into its narrative. First, fortysomethings Staten Kirkland (Josh Duhamel) and Quinn (Minka Kelly) navigate a long-simmering crush. Then thirtysomethings Yancy and Ellie (Marianly Tejada) spark a new connection. Finally, the story has teens Lucas (Garrett Wareing) and Lauren (Lizzy Greene) defying her sheriff dad.

This romantic core aligns more with “Virgin River’s” small-town charm than “Yellowstone’s” grim stakes. Schumacher told ScreenRant that the show’s heart lies in “love, and other struggles,” amplified by West Texas vistas and a murder mystery about Staten’s son’s death.

‘Ransom Canyon’ Stands on Its Own MeritsPlay

With “Ransom Canyon” finding early success by topping Netflix’s charts, this suggests that it’s more than a “Yellowstone” shadow. Early reviews have been positive, with praise that the new series can “surprise you, make you laugh, and break your heart.”

Schumacher credits the show’s standalone appeal to its storytelling and cast, including Duhamel and Kelly, who bring depth to the romance.

While “Yellowstone” spawned spinoffs like “1883,” “Ransom Canyon’s” eight-book source material hints at multi-season potential. Schumacher says that fans of both Westerns and romance should dive in.

“This is a great new standalone thing that I’m really proud of,” he said.