In a swift courtroom development, Michael David McKee, the Chicago-based vascular surgeon accused of murdering his ex-wife Monique Tepe and her husband Spencer Tepe, waived his extradition hearing on January 12, 2026, during a brief appearance in Winnebago County Court in Rockford, Illinois. The 39-year-old, dressed in a standard-issue yellow jumpsuit, spoke little as his attorney informed the judge of his decision to expedite transfer to Ohio, where he faces upgraded charges of premeditated aggravated murder—potentially carrying the death penalty. This move comes amid fresh revelations from court filings and family accounts, including McKee’s alleged post-divorce vow to Monique that he would “never leave her life” and plans to purchase a home nearby, fueling suspicions of stalking. As the case shifts to Franklin County for arraignment, prosecutors build a narrative of obsession and calculation in the December 30, 2025, slayings that left two young children orphaned in their bloodied home.
The gruesome scene was uncovered on the morning of December 30 in the Tepes’ Weinland Park residence on North Fourth Street, Columbus. Police, responding to a welfare check initiated by concerned relatives, found Spencer Tepe, 36, a respected local dentist, and Monique Tepe, 37, a marketing professional, deceased from multiple gunshot wounds. Spencer suffered shots to the torso and head, while Monique was hit in the chest. Disturbingly, the couple’s 4-year-old son and 1-year-old daughter were discovered unharmed but alone in the house, possibly exposed to the aftermath for hours. No firearm was located, and the absence of forced entry pointed investigators toward someone familiar with the victims. The children, now with family, are receiving counseling, as a relative told local media: “They’re innocent in all this, and we’re shielding them as best we can.”
McKee’s link to the crime solidified through neighborhood surveillance footage showing a dark SUV resembling his Illinois-registered vehicle near the home during the estimated window of the murders—between 8 p.m. and 10 p.m. on December 29. Digital forensics, including GPS data and phone records, further tied him to the area, leading to his arrest on January 10 in Rockford. Employed at Northwestern Medicine in Chicago’s Lincoln Park, McKee specialized in vascular procedures, maintaining a polished professional facade that contrasted sharply with the allegations. His mugshot, released by authorities, shows a composed demeanor, but court observers noted his lack of visible emotion during the hearing.
In court, McKee’s public defender, Carie Poirier, articulated his intent: “Mr. McKee believes the most expeditious manner in which he may defend himself against the charges pending in Ohio is to plead not guilty, waive his right to an extradition hearing, and have a governor’s warrant for his immediate transport.” The waiver avoids prolonged legal wrangling, with a status check scheduled for January 19, though transfer could occur sooner. Once in Ohio, McKee will enter a formal plea in Franklin County, where prosecutors have amended complaints to include premeditation specifications, elevating the stakes to capital punishment eligibility. Ohio has executed 56 individuals since reinstating the death penalty in 1999, though recent moratoriums make it rare.
Divorce records from 2017, unsealed amid the investigation, reveal a marriage that ended amicably on paper but harbored underlying discord. McKee and Monique wed in August 2015 in Athens County but separated after two years, citing incompatibility. No children were involved, and assets were divided without contest. However, new affidavits and social media analyses suggest McKee’s reluctance to let go. Sources close to the family allege he told Monique he would “never leave her life” and intended to use a work bonus to buy property in her vicinity after her 2020 remarriage to Spencer. These claims, echoed in YouTube breakdowns and family interviews, point to potential harassment, though no prior restraining orders were filed. “It was always in the back of our minds,” a Tepe relative confided to NBC4 Columbus.
The Tepe family issued a measured statement post-hearing: “Today’s arrest represents an important step toward justice for Monique and Spencer. Nothing can undo the devastating loss of two lives taken far too soon, but we are grateful to the City of Columbus Police Department, its investigators, and assisting law enforcement community. As the case proceeds, we trust the justice system to hold the person responsible fully accountable. Monique and Spencer remain at the center of our hearts, and we carry forward their love as we surround and protect the two children they leave behind.” The message, shared on platforms like Facebook, reflects a focus on healing and accountability.
Spencer and Monique were community fixtures. Spencer’s Tepe Family Dentistry emphasized accessible care, with him often volunteering for low-income patients. Monique supported children’s charities and was known for her vibrant energy. Their 2020 wedding followed a rekindled high school romance, captured in joyful photos from family albums. A joint memorial on January 11 drew overflow crowds, with tributes highlighting their generosity.
Police Chief Elaine Bryant commended the interstate collaboration: “This was a team effort—from local detectives to the FBI.” Motive remains speculative, but the premeditation charge implies advance planning. A GoFundMe for the children exceeds $200,000, funding therapy and education.
The case has ignited discussions on domestic violence, with groups like the National Coalition Against Domestic Violence noting ex-partners as common perpetrators. Ohio’s 15% rise in intimate partner homicides in 2025 underscores the urgency. True crime podcasts and X threads dissect the “never leave” comment, amplifying awareness.
As McKee prepares for Ohio proceedings, the Tepes’ story serves as a cautionary tale. Mayor Andrew Ginther vowed enhanced victim protections: “We must prevent these tragedies.” For the family, the road to justice is just beginning, honoring two lives lost to alleged unresolved rage.
