Johnny Depp has long been celebrated as one of Hollywood’s most versatile and enigmatic actors, captivating audiences with his transformative performances and eclectic role choices. From his iconic portrayal of Captain Jack Sparrow in the Pirates of the Caribbean franchise to his hauntingly tender role as Edward Scissorhands, Depp has a filmography that spans blockbuster hits and indie gems alike. However, among his vast body of work lies a lesser-known masterpiece that often flies under the radar, despite its brilliant script and Depp’s riveting performance: Donnie Brasco (1997). If you’re a fan of Johnny Depp, this crime drama is an absolute must-watch—a film that showcases his dramatic depth and proves why he remains a beloved figure in cinema, even as he continues to rebuild his career in 2025.

Donnie Brasco, directed by Mike Newell, is a biographical crime drama based on the true story of FBI agent Joseph D. Pistone, who infiltrated the Bonanno crime family in New York during the 1970s. Depp stars as Pistone, who adopts the alias “Donnie Brasco” to go undercover as a jewel thief, embedding himself deep within the Mafia. The film follows his relationship with Lefty Ruggiero (Al Pacino), an aging mobster who takes Donnie under his wing, unaware of his true identity. As Donnie becomes entangled in the criminal underworld, the lines between his undercover persona and his real self blur, leading to a gripping exploration of loyalty, betrayal, and the psychological toll of living a double life. The script, penned by Paul Attanasio, is a masterclass in tension and character development, offering a nuanced look at the human cost of undercover work.

When Donnie Brasco was released in 1997, it marked a pivotal moment in Depp’s career. At the time, he was still carving out a niche as a serious actor, having gained fame through roles in quirky films like Edward Scissorhands (1990) and What’s Eating Gilbert Grape (1993). Depp had already begun to establish himself as a performer who favored offbeat characters over conventional leading men, often collaborating with director Tim Burton on projects that highlighted his eccentricity. However, Donnie Brasco showcased a different side of Depp—one that was grounded, intense, and deeply human. Opposite Al Pacino, one of cinema’s most formidable actors, Depp held his own, delivering a performance that was both subtle and powerful. Critics praised the film, with the Houston Chronicle’s Jeff Millar noting that “Depp is as good as I’ve seen him, and Pacino is simply astonishing,” highlighting the chemistry between the two leads.

What makes Donnie Brasco stand out as a brilliantly written film is its focus on the emotional and moral complexities of its characters. Unlike many crime dramas that glorify the Mafia lifestyle, this film takes a more introspective approach, delving into the personal struggles of both Donnie and Lefty. The script masterfully balances the high-stakes tension of Donnie’s undercover mission with quieter, more poignant moments that reveal the toll it takes on his psyche. One particularly memorable scene, often cited by fans and critics alike, takes place in a hospital where Lefty opens up about his son’s struggles with addiction. In this moment, both characters drop their tough exteriors, allowing their vulnerabilities to surface—a testament to the script’s ability to humanize even the most hardened criminals.

For Depp, the role of Donnie Brasco was a departure from the eccentric characters he was known for, requiring a level of restraint and emotional depth that he hadn’t yet fully explored on screen. He portrays Donnie as a man torn between duty and the unexpected bonds he forms with the mobsters he’s meant to betray, particularly Lefty. Depp’s performance is understated yet powerful, conveying Donnie’s internal conflict through subtle gestures and expressions. In one scene, as Donnie is forced to participate in a brutal act to maintain his cover, the anguish on Depp’s face speaks volumes, showing the audience the heavy burden of his double life. This nuanced portrayal earned Depp widespread acclaim, with many fans on platforms like X noting that it remains one of his most underrated roles. A 2025 post on X even stated, “Johnny Depp’s raw, gripping role in Donnie Brasco revealed his dramatic firepower and changed his Hollywood path forever—yet hardly anyone talks about it.”

Despite its critical success, Donnie Brasco remains relatively underappreciated compared to Depp’s more mainstream hits. The film grossed a modest $125 million worldwide against a $35 million budget, a respectable sum but far from the blockbuster numbers of the Pirates of the Caribbean series. Its lack of widespread recognition may be due to its release during a period when Depp was still transitioning from indie darling to Hollywood leading man, as well as the fact that it was overshadowed by other high-profile crime films of the era, like Goodfellas (1990) and The Godfather Part III (1990). Additionally, Donnie Brasco doesn’t have the flashy, larger-than-life appeal of Depp’s later roles, which may have contributed to its status as a hidden gem.

For fans of Johnny Depp, Donnie Brasco is a must-watch because it offers a rare glimpse into his ability to tackle complex, dramatic roles with authenticity and depth. While Captain Jack Sparrow may have made him a household name, it’s roles like Donnie Brasco that demonstrate his range as an actor. The film also highlights Depp’s willingness to take risks, a trait that has defined his career from the beginning. As noted in a 2014 Rotten Tomatoes article, Depp has always been a “brave and astute chooser of scripts,” often opting for challenging roles over safe, commercial ones. Donnie Brasco is a perfect example of this, showcasing his commitment to artistry over fame.

The timing of this recommendation couldn’t be better, as Depp is currently experiencing a career resurgence in 2025. After years of personal and professional turmoil, including his highly publicized defamation trial against Amber Heard in 2022, Depp has been steadily reclaiming his place in Hollywood. His recent projects, such as Day Drinker, a Lionsgate thriller where he stars alongside Penélope Cruz, and Modi, a biographical drama he directed about artist Amedeo Modigliani, have generated buzz among fans and critics alike. Additionally, rumors of Depp’s potential return to the Pirates of the Caribbean franchise have been swirling, with reports in April 2025 suggesting that Disney is “very close” to finalizing a deal for his return as Captain Jack Sparrow. For fans eager to see more of Depp, revisiting Donnie Brasco offers a chance to appreciate the depth of his talent while awaiting his next big-screen appearance.

Beyond its significance in Depp’s career, Donnie Brasco is also a testament to the power of a well-crafted script. The film’s dialogue is sharp and authentic, capturing the gritty reality of the Mafia world while also exploring universal themes of loyalty, identity, and sacrifice. The relationship between Donnie and Lefty is the heart of the story, with the script providing both characters with moments of vulnerability that make their bond feel genuine. As noted by a 2022 article on Movies2binge.com, the film’s director, Mike Newell, chose to “highlight the friendship and affection between Donnie and Lefty,” giving the production a “rare quality of palpable tension.” This emotional depth, combined with the film’s thrilling plot, makes Donnie Brasco a standout in the crime drama genre.

If you’re a Johnny Depp fan, Donnie Brasco is a film you cannot afford to miss. It’s a powerful reminder of why Depp became a Hollywood icon in the first place—his ability to bring authenticity and humanity to even the most challenging roles. Whether you’re drawn to the film’s gripping story, its stellar performances, or its insight into Depp’s early career, Donnie Brasco is a hidden gem that deserves a spot on your watchlist. As Depp continues to make headlines with his comeback in 2025, there’s no better time to revisit this underrated masterpiece and rediscover the magic of one of his finest performances.