“I Felt My Heart Aflutter”: ‘American Idol’ Performance Leaves Judges Speechless

A new era of American Idol has officially begun. After months of celebrating Carrie Underwood‘s homecoming, from contest to winner to judge, the newly cemented judge has officially endured her first audition of Season 23. Joining Lionel Richie and Luke Bryan, Underwood discussed how things have changed on the show that made her 20 years ago.

To kick off the season comes the audition by Sonny Tennet. Hailing from South Shields, Tennet stunned the judges. That is after clarifying to Luke Bryan that “shrimp on the barbie” is not from his homeland of the UK. As Carrie Underwood’s first contestant, Tennet said, “It is so surreal.” He’s been a singer-songwriter, naming Lionel Richie as one of his influences. Accompanying himself on guitar, Tennet sings “Easy” by The Commodores in hopes of earning a golden ticket to Hollywood.

Sonny Tennet Gets ‘American Idol’ Aflutter


With R&B as a major influence, Tennet takes the song to a smooth, acoustic direction with his silky smooth vocals. His performance left newly appionted judege Carrie Underwood judges aflutter, with Richie even saying, “You made my song, your song.” For her first official critique behind the table, Underwood noted, “You look joyous when you were playing and singing and we felt that. Perfect song choice.” Bryan noted that Tennet sang the “timeless song in a timeless way.” With three yeses, Sonny Tennet is going to Hollywood!

American Idol doesn’t officially kick off until Sunday, February 9th, but the series shared a special preview following the Academy Awards. Season 23 marks the first major change of the series since moving to ABC. Long-time judge Katy Perry departed the show at the end of Season 22. After months of speculation, Carrie Underwood officially joined the judging panel, becoming the first alum to become a permanent judge. Joining the judges will be Jelly Roll as the season’s “artist in residence,” helping the American Idol hopefuls on their journey. The announcement came in a teaser video alongside host Ryan Seacrest.

Related Posts

Taylor Swift’s Heartwarming Social Media Gesture for Natalia Bryant’s USC Graduation Steals the Spotlight.

In a world where celebrity social media activity is scrutinized with the intensity of a high-stakes chess match, Taylor Swift’s recent return to TikTok has sent waves…

Taylor’s Heartwarming Gift: Baking 100 Cupcakes for Orphaned Children and Sharing Stories in a Day of Joy.

In a world often filled with hustle and bustle, one woman’s simple act of kindness has captured hearts and sparked conversations far and wide. Taylor, a compassionate…

Taylor Swift Leaves Fans Speechless with Selfies and a Stanley Cup Final Surprise Alongside Travis Kelce.

In a whirlwind of star power and heartfelt gestures, Taylor Swift has once again proven why she’s not just a global music icon but a cultural phenomenon…

Kat Timpf’s back on Gutfeld!—swapping diapers for punchlines and making us all LOL!

Kat Timpf, the quick-witted comedian, Fox News contributor, and co-host of Gutfeld!, has never been one to shy away from a punchline, even when life throws her…

SHOCK: Kat’s back on Gutfeld tonight! Laughing through life’s toughest battles with wit and heart.

On June 16, 2025, the vibrant and irreverent late-night show Gutfeld! on Fox News welcomed back one of its most beloved panelists, Kat Timpf, after a months-long…

🕵️‍♀️ Secrets Unravel in Ginny & Georgia S4: Who’s Missing from the Wellsbury Lineup? 👀✨

The wait is almost over for Ginny & Georgia fans, as Netflix has officially announced that Season 4 of the beloved mother-daughter dramedy will premiere in January…