After six years away from the small screen since the emotional finale of the beloved Schitt’s Creek, Dan Levy has made a triumphant — and wildly unexpected — return to television with Big Mistakes, a sharp, darkly comedic crime series that has taken Netflix by storm. In less than 48 hours after its release, the eight-episode show rocketed to the number 2 spot on Netflix’s U.S. charts, while earning a stellar 95% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes. Viewers and critics alike are calling it one of the most addictive and refreshing comedies of the year, proving that Levy’s signature blend of wit, heart, and sharp character work still resonates powerfully with audiences.

Levy stars as Nicky, a tightly wound, anxious gay pastor living a quiet, orderly life in a small town. His world is upended when he becomes the target of blackmail and is reluctantly dragged into the dangerous underbelly of organized crime. What begins as a desperate attempt to protect his secrets quickly spirals into a chaotic, high-stakes adventure that forces Nicky to partner with his wildly unpredictable sister Morgan, played with scene-stealing energy by Taylor Ortega. Together, the unlikely siblings navigate a world of shady deals, double-crosses, and moral dilemmas, all while trying to keep their deeply dysfunctional family from falling apart.

The series masterfully balances dark comedy with genuine emotional depth. Levy’s performance as the buttoned-up pastor is both hilarious and heartbreaking, capturing the internal panic of a man whose carefully constructed life is crumbling around him. His chemistry with Ortega is electric, their sibling dynamic crackling with resentment, affection, and reluctant teamwork that feels completely authentic. The show’s writing shines in its ability to shift seamlessly from laugh-out-loud moments to surprisingly tender explorations of family loyalty, identity, and redemption.

But the standout performance that has critics and viewers buzzing the most belongs to Laurie Metcalf as Linda, the siblings’ unpredictable, larger-than-life mother. Metcalf, already an Emmy-winning powerhouse known for her work in Roseanne, The Big Bang Theory, and numerous stage productions, delivers what many are calling one of the most electric and memorable supporting roles currently streaming. Her portrayal of Linda — a chaotic, sharp-tongued woman with a complicated past and zero filter — steals every scene she appears in. Whether she’s delivering cutting one-liners, meddling in her children’s criminal escapades, or revealing unexpected layers of vulnerability, Metcalf brings a magnetic unpredictability that elevates the entire series. Critics have described her performance as “scene-stealing,” “wildly entertaining,” and “the secret weapon” that makes Big Mistakes unmissable.

The show’s premise — a repressed pastor blackmailed into the criminal world — provides the perfect setup for escalating absurdity and tension. As Nicky and Morgan are pulled deeper into dangerous schemes, the series explores themes of control, family secrets, and the lengths people will go to protect (or destroy) the ones they love. The crime elements are handled with a light but clever touch, never overshadowing the character-driven comedy and emotional core that defines the story.

Screenshot 2026-04-11 101645

What has made Big Mistakes such a rapid success is its binge-friendly structure and universal appeal. Each episode builds on the last, ending with cliffhangers or hilarious reveals that make it nearly impossible to stop watching. The show cleverly pokes fun at small-town life, religious hypocrisy, and family dysfunction while maintaining a warm heart underneath the chaos. Viewers have praised the writing for feeling both fresh and familiar, with many noting that it captures the same clever, character-focused humour that made Schitt’s Creek a cultural phenomenon.

The rapid rise to #2 on Netflix’s U.S. charts within 48 hours speaks to the hunger for smart, funny, and emotionally grounded comedies. In a streaming landscape often dominated by heavy dramas or broad slapstick, Big Mistakes offers something different: a show that makes you laugh, cringe, and occasionally tear up, all while delivering satisfying character arcs and surprising twists. Early audience scores are exceptionally high, with many viewers admitting they finished the entire season in one or two sittings.

Laurie Metcalf’s performance as Linda has become the unexpected breakout element of the series. Her ability to switch between hilarious over-the-top moments and quietly devastating scenes has critics calling her work “career-highlight” material. Many have already begun speculating about award recognition, with some predicting Metcalf could be a strong contender for supporting actress honours. Her chemistry with both Levy and Ortega creates some of the show’s most memorable scenes, turning what could have been a simple crime-comedy into a rich family portrait.

For Dan Levy, the project marks a significant milestone. After co-creating, writing, and starring in the multi-award-winning Schitt’s Creek, many wondered what he would do next. Big Mistakes shows Levy stepping confidently into new territory as both star and executive producer, bringing his trademark wit and emotional intelligence to a story that feels both personal and universally relatable. His performance as the anxious pastor trying to maintain control while his life spirals is both hilarious and deeply human, proving once again why he remains one of television’s most versatile talents.

The show’s success also highlights Netflix’s continued investment in character-driven comedies with strong ensemble casts. By giving Big Mistakes a full eight-episode season and allowing the story to unfold at its own pace, the platform has created space for the kind of nuanced storytelling that rewards binge-watching while still delivering weekly water-cooler moments.

As word-of-mouth continues to spread, Big Mistakes is rapidly becoming one of the most recommended new series on Netflix. Viewers who started watching out of curiosity about Dan Levy’s return have found themselves completely hooked, staying up late to see how the Cody family’s criminal misadventures will unfold. The combination of sharp writing, standout performances — particularly Metcalf’s scene-stealing turn — and a perfect blend of comedy and heart has made the show a genuine hit.

Whether you’re a longtime fan of Schitt’s Creek looking for Levy’s next project or simply someone who enjoys clever, character-focused comedies with a darker edge, Big Mistakes delivers on every level. It’s funny, surprising, and unexpectedly moving — the kind of show that reminds you why we fall in love with television in the first place.

The Cody family’s chaotic world is now open for binge-watching, and with Laurie Metcalf stealing every scene and Dan Levy proving he still has plenty of tricks up his sleeve, Big Mistakes is quickly becoming the comedy everyone is talking about. Clear your schedule — once you start, you won’t want to stop.