As Outer Banks gears up for its fifth season, fans are eager for fresh details following the dramatic conclusion of season 4, where JJ Maybank’s death left the Pogues—and viewers—reeling. While official announcements about season 5 are limited, a deep dive into recent reports, cast interviews, and fan speculation reveals some potential new plot points that have yet to be widely disclosed. Here’s what might be in store for the treasure-hunting crew.

A Time Jump and New Beginnings

Season 4 ended with an 18-month flash-forward, showing the Pogues embarking on a new adventure to find Blackbeard’s treasure. Season 5 is expected to pick up in this timeline, focusing on how the group has evolved. John B and Sarah, now married and expecting a child, may face the challenges of balancing parenthood with their adventurous lifestyle. This shift could introduce a more mature dynamic, with the Pogues grappling with adult responsibilities while still chasing danger. The time jump also opens the door for new characters, potentially including a child of one of the Pogues, adding a fresh layer to the group’s dynamic.

JJ’s Death: A Lingering Mystery

While JJ’s death at the hands of Chandler Groff in season 4 appeared final, there’s speculation about unresolved threads. Some fans on social media platforms like X have theorized that JJ’s death might not be as straightforward as it seems, pointing to the show’s history of faking deaths—like Ward Cameron’s in season 2. The creators have remained tight-lipped, but Rudy Pankow’s cryptic comments in a recent interview with Entertainment Weekly hint at a possible flashback arc exploring JJ’s untold backstory, potentially revealing secrets about his family that could tie into the Blackbeard treasure hunt. This could also provide closure for Kiara, who was deeply affected by his loss.

A Deeper Dive into Blackbeard’s Treasure

The season 4 finale introduced a new quest: the search for Edward Teach’s (Blackbeard’s) treasure, sparked by a mysterious man handing John B a journal. Season 5 is likely to delve into the historical lore of Blackbeard, whose real-life exploits were centered around the Outer Banks. Expect the Pogues to uncover clues tied to Blackbeard’s ship, the Queen Anne’s Revenge, which sank off the North Carolina coast in 1718. This treasure hunt might lead them to new locations, possibly even international waters, as they face off against a new antagonist—a ruthless treasure hunter with ties to the region’s pirate history.

Kiara’s Leadership Role and Emotional Arc

With JJ gone, Kiara is poised to take on a more prominent leadership role within the Pogues. Madison Bailey has hinted in interviews that her character will channel her grief into determination, becoming a fiercer protector of the group. This arc might explore Kiara’s struggle to honor JJ’s memory while navigating her own path, potentially leading to a new love interest or a deeper bond with Cleo, who also lost someone close in season 4. Kiara’s growth could be a central focus, showcasing her evolution from a rebellious teen to a grounded leader.

A New Villain with a Personal Vendetta

Season 5 is expected to introduce a new antagonist connected to the Blackbeard treasure. Unlike previous villains like Ward or Rafe, this character might have a personal stake in the Pogues’ journey—possibly a descendant of Blackbeard seeking to reclaim their family legacy. This could create a more emotionally charged conflict, as the Pogues face an enemy who mirrors their own loyalty to family. The villain’s backstory might also tie into the broader mythology of the Outer Banks, revealing hidden secrets about the region’s history.

Pope and Cleo’s Expanding Roles

Pope and Cleo, who solidified their relationship in season 4, are likely to take on larger roles in the treasure hunt. Pope’s historical knowledge and Cleo’s street smarts could make them the driving force behind solving Blackbeard’s riddles. There’s also potential for Pope to explore his family’s connection to the treasure, building on his arc with the Santo Domingo cross. Meanwhile, Cleo’s past in the Bahamas might resurface, bringing new allies—or enemies—into the fold.

The Return of Familiar Faces

While JJ’s death marked a significant loss, there’s buzz about the potential return of other characters. Rafe Cameron, last seen on the run after season 4, could reappear as a wildcard, possibly seeking redemption or revenge. Additionally, there’s speculation about Ward Cameron’s influence lingering through unseen forces, such as a secret alliance he formed before his death. Fans are also hoping for a cameo from Big John, perhaps in a flashback, to provide John B with guidance as he navigates fatherhood.

A Darker, More Intense Tone

The showrunners have teased that season 5 will push the Pogues to their limits, with higher stakes than ever before. The loss of JJ might cast a darker shadow over the group, forcing them to confront their mortality and the cost of their treasure-hunting lifestyle. This could lead to more intense action sequences, including underwater explorations and high-stakes confrontations, as they race to secure Blackbeard’s treasure before their enemies do.

What Fans Don’t Know Yet

While these plot points are based on available hints, much of season 5 remains under wraps. The creators have a history of subverting expectations—John B’s father being alive, Sarah’s betrayal in season 1—so there’s likely a major twist in store. Could there be a traitor among the Pogues? Might Blackbeard’s treasure hold a supernatural element, as some fan theories suggest? And will the season mark the end of the series, as originally planned by the creators for a five-season arc? These questions remain unanswered, keeping viewers on edge.

Outer Banks season 5 promises to blend nostalgia, heartbreak, and high-stakes adventure as the Pogues chase their most dangerous treasure yet. While the full picture is still unfolding, these potential developments hint at a thrilling continuation of their journey.