Was Joe Alwyn Cheating on Taylor with Alison Oliver? What Evidence Are They Hunting for?

“If anything the album implies she cheated, or at least pined after Matty,” one Reddit user pointed out.

Taylor Siwft and Joe Alwyn, Alison Oliver

SOURCE: GETTY IMAGES

It’s been about a year since the news broke that Taylor Swift and her boyfriend of six years, Joe Alwyn, called it off. Though Taylor has since moved on to date football star Travis Kelce, her fans refuse to forget about the man she wrote “King of My Heart” (and most of the “Lover” album) about.

In the weeks leading up to the release of Taylor’s latest album, “The Tortured Poets Department,” fans speculated that with songs like “So Long, London” the new project would dig into her relationship with Joe. It’s also led to an increase in speculation that Joe may have cheated on Taylor with his Conversations With Friends co-star Alison Oliver. This theory has run rampant among the Swifties, and Alison’s comments are still flooded with speculators.

Joe Alwyn and Alison Oliver at the premiere for 'Conversations With Friends'

SOURCE: GETTY IMAGES

Did Joe Alwyn cheat with Alison Oliver? The clues in Taylor Swift’s content.

Most Swifties know that Taylor loves to leave Easter eggs like diary entries in her work. Taylor has written pretty extensively about cheating (see “illicit affairs” and “Getaway Car” if you need a refresher), but there’s little evidence in any of her work that Joe actually cheated on her.

The rumors that Joe was unfaithful to Taylor began when a video from the Conversations With Friends set leaked and Joe allegedly called out Alison’s real name instead of her character’s name (Frances) during an intimate scene. It was further fueled by the claims that Joe threw Alison a party at Taylor’s house while the singer was out of town.

Beyond this and some uncanny parallels in Taylor’s photography promoting various works, there isn’t really much evidence that the actor cheated on Taylor.

@jessicalynnslocumReplying to @Brooke Marie 121 *AlLeGeD 💅 * #SwiftTok #swifties #heylovers #swifties4ever #swifttoker #swifttok #TSPN #swift #tspn #taylorswift #swiftie #thetorturedpoetsdepartment #ttpd #eclipse #alisonoliver #joealwyn #emmalaird

♬ original sound – JessiSwiftTok

In fact, most of the evidence suggests the contrary. While still with Taylor, Joe said during an interview that he wasn’t into the illicit affairs of his on-screen character, a married man who entered a relationship with Alison’s character.

“People can do whatever they want that makes them happy,” he said, per USA Today. “I’m obviously happy in a monogamous relationship.” He said that open relationships “seem exhausting,” suggesting he doesn’t see the appeal of having more than one partner.

Swifties have been commenting on Alison’s posts about “The Tortured Poets Department.”

Despite “The Tortured Poets Department” (surprisingly) focusing on Taylor’s 10-year situationship with The 1975’s frontman Matty Healy, some Swifties haven’t let go of the rumors. As a result, since the album’s release, Alison’s Instagram comments have been filled with Taylor’s fans commenting about the album. Some are snarky and mean, while others are just leaving comments with gifs of Taylor or the white heart Taylor specifically dedicated to her 11th studio album.

A screenshot of Alison Oliver's Instagram page with screenshots from Swifties

SOURCE: INSTAGRAM/@ALISONJOLIVER

“If anything the album implies she cheated, or at least pined after Matty,” one Reddit user wrote on a post with screenshots of Alison’s comment section.

“It’s [just] not the only possible explanation and I feel like he would’ve gotten more angry songs if this were the case,” another wrote. “Like with the Matty songs you can clearly see she was so deeply bothered by how it all went down, Joe songs don’t seem to have that same vibe.”

Related Posts

😭 Saddle Up for Heartbreak 💔 My Life With The Walter Boys Season 3 Trailer Teases George’s Final Goodbye — and a Twist That’ll Shatter You 💥🐎

The dusty trails of the Walter Ranch have always been a battleground for broken hearts, sibling rivalries, and the kind of small-town secrets that simmer like a…

“We Gave Our Saturdays to America – Now They’re Taking Them Away” – Michelle Miller and Dana Jacobson’s Tearful CBS Saturday Morning Farewell as Paramount’s Axe Falls on Beloved Hosts.

The coffee was still steaming in the green room when the email hit: “Immediate All-Staff Meeting – Urgent.” It was October 29, 2025, a crisp fall morning…

💥 Legends Unite for Murder! 😱 Helen Mirren, Pierce Brosnan, Judi Dench & Ian McKellen Turn Retirement Into a Crime Scene. The Thursday Murder Club (2025)

Picture this: A sun-dappled English village, where roses climb ivy-clad walls and the only thing sharper than the garden shears is the gossip over afternoon tea. In…

‘When Peace Becomes a Weapon…’ The Diplomat Season 4 Unleashes Betrayal, Passion, and Power Like Never Before 🌎💥

When peace becomes a weapon…” The line hangs in the air like the acrid smoke of a diplomatic cable incinerated in a midnight panic, a whisper from…

Stephen Colbert’s Sobbing Late Show Breakdown Over Virginia Giuffre’s Final Words Shocks America Into Silence.

The Ed Sullivan Theater has seen legends cry before—Springsteen’s cracked voice on 9/12, Lin-Manuel’s Hamilton tears, even Colbert’s own 2015 farewell to his mom. But at 11:37…

🩺 NEW SEASON. NEW SECRETS. 💥 The Resident Is Coming Back — and This Time, Nothing Stays Buried for Long 😳💉

The fluorescent hum of Chastain Park Memorial Hospital is about to roar back to life, and this time, the beeps of monitors will sync with the pounding…