Case set to test Julie Inman Grant’s powers under the Online Safety Act, but it’s only one of seven ongoing cases her office has with the Elon Musk-owned platform
A notice issued to Twitter over its tackling of child sexual abuse material did not account for the company “ceasing to exist” when Elon Musk’s X Corp merged with Twitter in March 2023 soon after, X Corp has said, in a landmark case challenging a penalty from the Australian online safety regulator.
X took the eSafety commissioner to court last year challenging the $610,500 fine issued against the company over failing to answer questions in the notice, with the case being heard in the federal court on Monday and Tuesday this week.
The eSafety commissioner, Julie Inman Grant, issued legal notices to what was then Twitter, among others, in February last year, under the Online Safety Act asking the company to answer questions on what it was doing to crack down on child sexual abuse material on its platform.
Australia fined X $610,500. But will Elon Musk’s company pay up?
Read more
Inman Grant told Guardian Australia at the time the fine was issued that, despite giving the company extensions in time to respond, Twitter had left some questions “totally blank, to obfuscate [from providing] inaccurate information.”
In the federal court on Monday, Bret Walker SC, acting for X, said the original notice that led to the fine was served to what was then Twitter Inc, which merged with X Corp in March of 2023.
“Everyone agrees that Twitter ceased to exist. That’s the critical point,” he said.
“The point about a notice is that the time ticks from the day of issue, and the statute, perfectly sensibly, does not provide for the cessation of existence of the person to whom it is directed as to a continued operation of that notice thereafter,” he said.
Counsel for the eSafety commissioner did not address this point on Monday. The court will hear from two expert witnesses on Tuesday who Walker indicated would have opposing views on whether whether the responsibility for the notice transferred to X Corp.
The case will be a test of the commissioner’s powers under the Online Safety Act, including the issuing of notices for platforms to account for how they’re meeting the government’s basic online safety expectations.
eSafety has commenced a separate civil penalty proceeding against X in relation to its alleged non-compliance with the notice, the office of the eSafety commissioner said on Monday. That proceeding is on hold until the federal court case has been determined.
Walker flagged so far that only one of the notices issued under the act was issued to the new X Corp entity. Inman Grant told the ABC last month that X currently has seven ongoing legal cases with her office.
The hearing also comes as the Albanese Labor government is reviewing the Online Safety Act, with a report due to government at the end of October.
News
Game of Thrones Made the Right Call Cutting the Books’ Biggest Targaryen Twist – And This Major Spinoff Trend Proves It!
Game of Thrones cut A Song of Ice and Fire‘s biggest Targaryen twist (so far) when it didn’t include Young Griff, aka Aegon Targaryen, but it was the right…
Jon Snow’s iconic sword and Jaime Lannister’s golden hand are up for grabs – Don’t miss your chance to own a piece of ‘Game of Thrones’ history!
Heritage Auctions has united with HBO to offer more than 2,000 pieces from the hit series based on George R.R. Martin’s novels. They include the dreaded shame…
‘House of the Dragon’ Season 3 Might Blow Past Game of Thrones’ Biggest Cameo – If They Can Land This One Celebrity Who Would Be Perfect for the Role!
One celebrity is so perfect that their potential cameo in House of the Dragon can leave behind Game of Thrones’ most memorable cameo. The Game of Thrones prequel, House…
House of the Dragon Season 2: A slow-burning yet captivating ‘dance’ you won’t want to miss!
The long night has officially begun, and two bleak winters will now pass before we are gifted season three of this magnificent show. Season one of House of…
House of the Dragon’s Fabien Frankel set to reunite with co-stars Matt Smith & Tom Glynn-Carney at NYCC 2024 – What could this epic reunion reveal?
Raise your banners – green and black are coming head-to-head at New York Comic Con 2024. House of the Dragon’s Ser Criston Cole – aka actor Fabien…
10 Strangest Details You Probably Missed in House of the Dragon!
The first two seasons of House of the Dragon had many great moments and clever plotlines setting up a horrific war, known as the Dance of the Dragons,…
End of content
No more pages to load