Toss a coin, Witcher fans—because Henry Cavill might not be done with Geralt of Rivia just yet! 

After his controversial exit from Netflix’s The Witcher, and the announcement that Liam Hemsworth would take over the role, fans were left outraged, heartbroken, and demanding justice for Cavill’s portrayal of the White Wolf. But now, a jaw-dropping new report suggests that Henry Cavill could be returning to the role in an upcoming season! 

What’s REALLY Happening?

For months, rumors have been swirling about Netflix reconsidering their decision after The Witcher Season 3 received mixed reviews and saw a decline in viewership following Cavill’s departure. Now, inside sources claim:

 Netflix is in talks with Cavill about making a grand return!
 There could be a multi-Witcher storyline, featuring both Cavill and Hemsworth.
 The showrunners are reportedly reworking the plot to allow Cavill’s Geralt to return in an unexpected way.
 A possible spin-off could focus entirely on Cavill’s version of the White Wolf.

Could this be Netflix’s way of winning back fans and saving the franchise?

Henry Cavill’s Passion for The Witcher – Why He May Return

Unlike many actors who take on roles purely for career moves, Henry Cavill has been a lifelong fan of The Witcher books and games. He poured his heart and soul into the role, often going beyond the script to ensure Geralt stayed true to the source material.

His departure reportedly stemmed from creative differences with the showrunners, who were accused of deviating too far from the original novels by Andrzej Sapkowski. But if Netflix is willing to correct course, could Cavill be convinced to wield the silver sword once more?

 Fans have already taken to social media, demanding that Netflix bring Cavill back. 

What About Liam Hemsworth?

With The Witcher already set to move forward with Liam Hemsworth as Geralt, many are wondering how Cavill’s return could fit into the narrative. Possible theories include:

 A multiverse plotline—introducing two Geralts from different timelines.
 Cavill playing an older Geralt, guiding Hemsworth’s younger version.
 A surprise twist where Hemsworth is a different Witcher altogether.

One thing is clear: if Cavill comes back, it will be a MASSIVE game-changer.

Can Netflix Save The Witcher?

After Cavill’s departure, The Witcher faced major backlash, with fans threatening to boycott the show entirely. Netflix has been under pressure to fix the franchise before it’s too late, and bringing back Henry Cavill might be their only shot at redemption.

Will he return? Will Netflix make the right call? The Witcher’s fate now hangs in the balance.

What Do You Think?

Would you watch The Witcher again if Henry Cavill returns? Or is it too late for Netflix to fix the damage? Drop your thoughts below!