Lord of the Rings Fans Fiercely Divided Over Controversial New Movie Reveal!

The Lord Of The Rings fans divided over new movie announcement

And by “divided” I mean “extremely angry”.

A recent slip-up has revealed that a second live-action Lord of the Rings film is on its way, which has of course upset several people.

Empire’s recent article by Ben Travis featured an interview with screenwriter Philippa Boyens, who previously worked on several of the Lord of the Rings films. This includes all three original films in The Lord of the Rings trilogy and all three films in The Hobbit’s trilogy.

As Boyens revealed to Empire, the upcoming film The Hunt For Gollum will be a single, standalone movie. Many had assumed it was going to be a two-part film, due to a misunderstanding on the part of Gandalf’s actor Sir Ian McKellen.

It seems McKellen’s mistake wasn’t entirely untrue however, as Boyens explained that it likely originated from discussions with the actor about a completely different live-action Lord of the Rings film that’s in the early stages of pre-production.

“That was a genuine misunderstanding that happened because we’ve begun to work, conceptually, on two different live-action films. The first being The Hunt For Gollum, the second one still to be confirmed.” Boyens explained.

Of course, this is a reveal on its own. The interview confirms that a completely new LOTR film will come out after The Hunt For Gollum, which people aren’t happy about.

Several comments on DiscussingFilm’s tweet discussing the reveal are extremely negative, such as this one from user @SirJoshFord.

“Doubt they’ll have the same care, time and attention that LOTR had… You can tell that they had less time & the quality couldn’t be replicated to that same effect for The Hobbit films.”

“Why do they wanna milk this franchise more than necessary…” replied user @mind_talkss. “The 3 movies from Peter jackson were perfect let’s leave it that at”

Personally, I think the fact that Boyens, Peter Jackson and Andy Serkis are involved with The Hunt For Gollum should imply the project will be treated with care and authenticity.

Many seem to forget that The Hobbit trilogy’s production process was extremely rough, with Jackson being brought on at the last minute to help steer it. The decision to split it into a trilogy was also completely out of Jackson’s hands.

By the time it releases, The Hunt For Gollum will have been in production for roughly three years.

For comparison, The Hobbit trilogy of films were only in production for roughly 266 days, with Jackson only coming on board to help salvage the project five months before filming began. Post-production for the first film in the trilogy only ended a mere two days before its premiere.

So I say, let them cook. I’m quietly looking forward to seeing what they can do with The Hunt For Gollum, and beyond.

Related Posts

Michael Bublé’s Proposal Almost Didn’t Happen – Find Out the Unexpected Reason He Nearly Backed Out

Luisana Lopilato said she “loved” the thoughtful way The Voice Coach proposed in 2009.When Michael Bublé first met his wife, Argentine actress Luisana Lopilato, he didn’t speak a word…

Why Donald Trump has no plans to kick Prince Harry and Meghan Markle out of the US – and how important a role did King Charles play in his decision?

  Insiders have revealed the real reason why Donald Trump no longer plans to kick Prince Harry and his wife Meghan Markle out of the US.The President declared last week that he would not…

Adam Brody & Kristen Bell’s Hit Show Nobody Wants This Season 2 Has A Filming Date – Find Out When It Starts

Adam Brody bagged the award for Best Actor in a Comedy Series, at the Critics Choice Awards 2025. Nobody Wants This, a romantic comedy by Netflix released…

While chatting to two boys in ski gear who appeared to ask the Duchess about her freckles, Meghan shared some advice – which she previously attributed to her now-estranged father, Thomas Markle. And which…?

  The Duchess of Sussex, 43, is a proud advocate for freckles and is said to consider them her ‘favourite feature’ – even writing her first book on the…

Meghan Markle’s subtle message to the royal family before Prince Harry left was a hidden plea to the royal family? Did she want to be saved?

  Meghan Markle’s new bold piece of jewellery could be a hidden plea to the royals, according to an expert.During her time at the Invictus Games in Canada, earlier this…

Harry reveals ‘challenging but important’ conversation with Archie and ‘excited’ Lilibet about Invictus Games competitors: This is a very interesting conversation to have with your kids

  Prince Harry has revealed how he is having ‘challenging but important’ conversations with his children, Prince Archie and Princess Lilibet, about the Invictus Games competitors.Speaking at this year’s competition held…