CD Projekt Red’s The Witcher 4 has already set the gaming world ablaze with its reveal at The Game Awards 2024, confirming Ciri as the new protagonist and promising the “most immersive” Witcher game yet. But amidst the excitement, a new rumor has surfaced that could send shockwaves through the fandom: whispers that Henry Cavill, the beloved former Geralt of Rivia from Netflix’s The Witcher series, might be involved in the game in some capacity. While nothing is confirmed, the speculation has fans buzzing with anticipation for what could be a monumental reunion with the Witcher universe.

A Familiar Voice in a New Saga?

Henry Cavill portrayed Geralt of Rivia in Netflix’s The Witcher for three seasons, earning widespread praise for his dedication to the role before stepping down in 2022, with Liam Hemsworth taking over for Season 4. Cavill’s exit was attributed to creative differences, as he was known for his deep loyalty to Andrzej Sapkowski’s books and CD Projekt Red’s games—a passion that reportedly clashed with the show’s direction. Now, with The Witcher 4 focusing on Ciri’s journey as a Witcher, fans are speculating that Cavill could return to voice Geralt in the game, especially since Doug Cockle, the voice actor for Geralt in the Witcher games, confirmed Geralt will appear in the new title.

The rumor began circulating on gaming forums and social media platforms like X, where fans pointed out Cavill’s well-documented love for the Witcher franchise—he famously built his own gaming PC to play The Witcher 3. Could CD Projekt Red be planning a surprise cameo, perhaps leveraging Cavill’s iconic portrayal to bridge the gap between the Netflix series and the games? Some insiders hint that the studio has been in talks with a “high-profile actor” for a special role, though no names have been confirmed. Given Cavill’s recent departure from other major franchises like Superman and his expressed desire for more creative control in projects like Warhammer 40K, the timing might be perfect for him to step back into Geralt’s boots—or at least lend his voice to the White Wolf.

Why It Might Happen—and Why It Might Not

Cavill’s potential involvement would be a dream come true for fans who felt his Netflix exit left a void. His physicality and gravitas brought Geralt to life in a way that resonated deeply with audiences, and many believe his voice could add an emotional layer to Geralt’s mentorship of Ciri in The Witcher 4. The game’s narrative, set after the events of The Witcher 3’s best ending, positions Geralt as a supporting character, making a cameo or recurring role plausible. CD Projekt Red has a history of surprises, and with The Witcher 4 being developed on Unreal Engine 5 for a 2027 or 2028 release, the studio might be aiming to pull out all the stops to make this the definitive Witcher experience.

However, there are reasons to temper expectations. Cavill’s departure from the Netflix series was reportedly due to the physical toll of the role and creative frustrations, which might make him hesitant to return to the character, even in a voice-acting capacity. Additionally, Doug Cockle has been the voice of Geralt in the games since 2007, and replacing him could risk backlash from longtime fans. Still, the idea of Cavill contributing in a limited capacity—perhaps for a pivotal scene or as a multiversal nod to his Netflix role—has sparked heated discussions online.

Fan Speculation and Industry Whispers

The gaming community is abuzz with theories. Some fans on X have speculated that Cavill might record a few lines for a heartfelt Geralt-Ciri moment, while others imagine a full-blown appearance in a key quest, possibly tied to the new School of the Lynx hinted at in the game’s teaser imagery. A Reddit thread even suggested Cavill could voice a different character altogether, perhaps a new mentor figure for Ciri, allowing him to contribute without overshadowing Doug Cockle’s legacy.

CD Projekt Red has remained tight-lipped, with no official comment on Cavill’s involvement. However, the studio’s focus on delivering a polished product—backed by over 400 developers as of March 2025—suggests they’re open to bold moves to elevate The Witcher 4. As the game inches closer to its expected 2027 or 2028 release window, the possibility of Cavill’s return continues to fuel speculation. Will the White Wolf’s growl carry Cavill’s familiar timbre, or is this merely wishful thinking from a passionate fanbase?

Don’t miss out—keep your eyes peeled for the next big reveal from CD Projekt Red, because if Henry Cavill is indeed returning to The Witcher universe, it’s a reunion you won’t want to miss!