Lindsay Lohan’s New Rom-Com Is Here: Meet the Cast of Our Little Secret – You Won’t Believe Who’s In It!

The movie features new faces, veteran comedians, and one of Lohan’s “Mean Girls” costars.

The holidays are for spending time with loved ones… not people you used to love.

Netflix’s snappy new rom-com Our Little Secret (directed by Stephen Herek, who helmed Bill & Ted’s Excellent Adventure) sees bitter exes Avery (Lindsay Lohan) and Logan (Ian Harding) forced to spend Christmas together after discovering their new partners, Cam (Jon Rudnitsky) and Cassie (Katie Baker), are siblings.

Undoubtedly, this creates some friction between the brood — most notably for matriarch Erica (Kristin Chenoweth). A battle of wills soon ensues, but will the exes find they’re meant for each other after all?

As Lohan headlines her third Netflix rom-com, here’s everything to know about the cast of Our Little Secret.

Lindsay Lohan (Avery)

Lindsay Lohan as Avery in Our Little Secret, Lindsay Lohan attends Netflix's "Our Little Secret" New York screening at The Paris Theatre on November 18, 2024 in New York City

Lindsay Lohan. 

Lindsay Lohan began her career as a child actor in The Parent Trap (1998) before starring in teen hits like Freaky Friday (2003), Confessions of a Teenage Drama Queen (2004), and Mean Girls (2004). She then moved on to more adult roles in A Prairie Home Companion (2006), I Know Who Killed Me (2007), and The Canyons (2013). Her career took a temporary detour due to legal issues and time spent in rehab.

After relocating to Dubai, Lohan returned to screens with the Netflix rom-coms Falling for Christmas (2022) and Irish Wish (2024). She’ll soon reprise her role as Anna Coleman opposite Jamie Lee Curtis in Freakier Friday, due out next year.

Though Lohan has performed in her share of comedies, she found it hard to adjust to some of the bits in Our Little Secret. “I think the biggest difference with Avery is that, in this, I did have to do some comedic scenes — I haven’t had to go as deep into that before,” she told Tudum.

Lohan wed Bader Shammas in 2022. The following year, she gave birth to their son, Luai.

Ian Harding (Logan)

 Ian Harding as Logan in Our Little Secret, Ian Harding attends Netflix's "Our Little Secret" New York screening at The Paris Theatre on November 18, 2024 in New York City

Ian Harding. 

Prior to playing Avery’s former flame, Ian Harding was best known for his role as Ezra Fitz on Pretty Little Liars (2010–2017), for which he won seven Teen Choice Awards. He also appeared on the series Long Slow Exhale (2022) and played Phillip Davis on 11 episodes of Chicago Med. As for film, Harding appeared as Ford executive Ian in Ford v Ferrari (2019).

Harding has been with his wife, Sophie Hart, for over a decade, though they’ve kept details of their romance private. They married in 2019 and announced the birth of their first child in September 2022.

Kristin Chenoweth (Erica)

Kristin Chenoweth as Erica in Our little Secret, Kristin Chenoweth attends the 27th Annual Power of Love Gala hosted by Keep Memory Alive on May 10, 2024 in Las Vegas, Nevada

Kristin Chenoweth. 

Star of stage and screen Kristin Chenoweth steals scenes as Cam and Cassie’s “meanie” mom, Erica.

She won Tony Awards for You’re a Good Man Charlie Brown (1999) and On the Twentieth Century (2015), but she’s best known on Broadway for originating the role of Glinda the Good Witch in Wicked. She’s also turned in celebrated performances on television shows like The West Wing (2004–2006) and Pushing Daises (2007–2009), the latter of which won her an Emmy.

Chenoweth previously dated writer Aaron Sorkin and actor Seth Green. She married guitarist Josh Bryant in September 2023.

Jon Rudnitsky (Cameron)

Jon Rudnitsky in "Our Little Secret," Jon Rudnitsky attends "The French Italian" Premiere during the 2024 Tribeca Festival at Village East Cinema on June 06, 2024 in New York City.

Jon Rudnitsky. 

Jon Rudnitsky plays Avery’s new beau, Cam.

The actor and comedian had a brief tenure on Saturday Night Live between 2015 and 2016. He then moved on to more dramatic projects, including a turn in the dramedy Summer Days Summer Nights (2018) and playing McMatt in Hulu’s Catch-22 (2019).

Beyond additional big-screen roles in Home Again (2017) opposite Reese Witherspoon and Set It Up (2018) with Glen Powell, Rudnitsky has also appeared in two episodes of Curb Your Enthusiasm.

Katie Baker (Cassie)

Katie Baker in "Our Little Secret," Katie Baker attends the screening of Netflix's "Our Little Secret" at The Paris Theatre on November 18, 2024 in New York City

Katie Baker. 

Katie Baker, who plays Logan’s new girlfriend and Cam’s sister, previously had a minor role on Apple TV+’s remake of The Mosquito Coast (2022). She also made guest appearances on Beyond Belief: Fact or Fiction and The Sex Lives of College Girls (2024).

Judy Reyes (Margaret)

Judy Reyes as Margaret in Our Little Secret, Judy Reyes attends Variety's 2024 Power Of Women: Los Angeles Event Presented By Lifetime at Mother Wolf on October 24, 2024 in Los Angeles, California

Judy Reyes. 

Judy Reyes, who plays a longtime friend of Erica’s, is best known as loveable nurse Carla Espinoza on eight seasons of NBC’s medical dramedy Scrubs. Her other notable TV roles include Zoila Diaz on Devious Maids (2013–2016), “Quiet Ann” on Claws (2017–2022), and Ramona on One Day at a Time (2017–2020).

She guest-starred as Dina Milagro in Jane the Virgin (2015–2019) and made appearances on Succession (2018) and Dr. Death (2023). The actress notably played against type in the horror movie Smile (2022) and garnered acclaim for her role in Birth/Rebirth (2023). She is currently starring in ABC’s High Potential opposite Kaitlin Olson.

Reyes was previously married to cinematographer Edwin Figueroa. In May 2009, she gave birth to a daughter whom she shares with director Bruce Valencia.

Tim Meadows (Stan)

Tim Meadows as Stan in Our Little Secret, Tim Meadows visits the SiriusXM Studios on November 29, 2018 in New York City

Tim Meadows. 

Tim Meadows plays Margaret’s husband, Tim.

Our Little Secret marks a Mean Girls reunion between Lohan and Meadows, who played Principal Duvall in the 2004 film. He reprised the role in the 2011 sequel and the 2024 musical film adaptation, the latter of which also saw a brief Lohan cameo.

Meadows is well-known for his tenure on Saturday Night Live (1991–2000), where he also served as a writer. His big-screen work includes movies like Walk Hard: The Dewey Cox Story (2007), Grown Ups (2010), Grown Ups 2 (2013), Trainwreck (2015), and Dream Scenario (2023). He appeared in The Goldbergs from 2013 to 2023 and starred in his own spinoff, Schooled, from 2019 to 2020.

Meadows was married to Michelle Taylor from 1997 to 2005. They share two sons.

Dan Bucatinsky (Leonard)

Dan Bucatinsky

Actor, producer, and writer Dan Bucatinsky stars in Our Little Secret as Erica’s unfaithful husband, Leonard.

He is best known for playing James Novak in Scandal (2012–2015), winning an Emmy for Outstanding Guest Actor in a Drama Series in 2013. Bucatinsky starred opposite Lisa Kudrow in the TV series The Comeback, which he also executive produced, and Web Therapy, directed by his husband Don RoosOn the big screen, he’s appeared in movies like Under the Tuscan Sun (2003), Second Act (2018), and Air (2023).

Bucatinsky married Roos in 2008. The two share a daughter, Eliza, and a son, Jonah.

Related Posts

Details of Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce’s Private Birthday Celebration Revealed

Taylor Swift was not able to support Travis Kelce during the Kansas City Chiefs’ win over the Cleveland Browns on Sunday. Swift, who recently ended her “Eras Tour” concert series after nearly two…

When Deadpool Meets Spider-Man: Ryan Reynolds and Andrew Garfield Join Forces for Epic Actors on Actors

Ryan Reynolds lit the summer box office on fire this year with “Deadpool & Wolverine,” the third feature film centered on his subversive, pansexual goofball superhero — and…

After the success of Deadpool and Wolverine, Ryan Reynolds and Hugh Jackman are set to play middle-aged boy band members in a new comedy from director Shawn Levy

After the massive, billion-dollar success of Deadpool and Wolverine, Ryan Reynolds and Hugh Jackman are set to star in Boy Band from director Shawn Levy.Reynolds and Levy…

Ryan Reynolds Explains Where Deadpool Can Fit in MCU’s Avengers and X-Men Plans

Ryan Reynolds is a force to be reckoned with, and after the success of Deadpool & Wolverine , there is no stopping the Canadian with the Midas touch. For that…

Ryan Reynolds reveals the character Disney vetoed in ‘Deadpool and Wolverine’

Reynolds had certain limitations in the script of ‘Deadpool and Wolverine’: one of them was the prohibition of mentioning this classic Disney character. Although Ryan Reynolds admits he had…

Harry & Meghan reveal rare images of Prince Archie and Princess Lilibet on Christmas card as couple share message

PRINCE Harry and Meghan Markle have revealed a rare new image of their kids Archie and Lilibet. The picture is included among other snaps on the couple’s annual Christmas…