The romantic comedy sensation Nobody Wants This is gearing up to return to Netflix on October 23, 2025, for a highly anticipated second season that promises to crank up the drama, humor, and heart-pounding romance. After its debut in September 2024, the show skyrocketed to global acclaim, dominating Netflix’s Top 10 list with over 57 million views by the end of the year and sparking a frenzy among rom-com fans. With Kristen Bell and Adam Brody reprising their roles as the star-crossed Joanne and Noah, Season 2 is poised to dive deeper into their chaotic love story, introducing new faces, unexpected obstacles, and a whirlwind of emotions that will keep viewers glued to their screens. Buckle up—things are about to get even messier.
At the heart of Nobody Wants This is the unlikely romance between Joanne, an outspoken, agnostic sex and relationships podcaster, and Noah, a charming, unconventional rabbi fresh off a breakup. Their chemistry in Season 1 was electric, drawing viewers into a rollercoaster of witty banter, steamy moments, and cultural clashes. Created by Erin Foster and loosely inspired by her own love story with husband Simon Tikhman, the series struck a chord with its authentic portrayal of navigating love across religious and personal divides. The Season 1 finale left fans on edge: Joanne hesitated to convert to Judaism, a potential dealbreaker for Noah’s ambitions to become head rabbi, only for Noah to chase her down in a dramatic parking-lot kiss that screamed, “I choose you.” But can their love survive the pressures of faith, family, and their own insecurities?
Season 2 picks up shortly after this cliffhanger, promising a seamless continuation of the show’s signature vibe—sharp humor, heartfelt moments, and just the right amount of chaos. Foster has emphasized that the new season will maintain the same cadence and dynamics, ensuring fans feel like they’re diving back into the same world. “It’s not the same night, but more or less a continuation,” Foster revealed, hinting that the story will explore whether Joanne and Noah can make their relationship work without sacrificing their core identities. Will Joanne reconsider converting? Will Noah give up his dream of leading his synagogue? Or will they find a middle ground that defies the odds? These questions will drive the narrative, with Foster teasing that the show will take its time to unravel the complexities of their bond.
The returning cast is a major draw, with Bell and Brody leading the charge. Bell’s Joanne is a firecracker—bold, flawed, and fiercely independent—while Brody’s Noah, dubbed the “Hot Rabbi” by fans, brings a mature charm that echoes his iconic The O.C. days. Their chemistry is the show’s heartbeat, and early reports suggest Season 2 will lean heavily into their push-and-pull dynamic. Justine Lupe returns as Morgan, Joanne’s sister and podcast co-host, whose messy personal life and sibling rivalry add layers of humor and tension. Timothy Simons is back as Sasha, Noah’s older brother, whose deadpan wit and questionable life choices make him a fan favorite. Jackie Tohn, now promoted to a series regular, will bring more sass as Esther, Sasha’s wife, whose meddling in Noah’s life is sure to stir the pot.
New faces are set to shake things up, none more exciting than Leighton Meester, Brody’s real-life wife and Gossip Girl icon. Meester will guest-star as Abby, Joanne’s middle-school nemesis turned Instagram mommy influencer. Described as a spicy addition, Abby’s presence is expected to ignite old rivalries and test Joanne’s confidence, especially as she crosses paths with Noah. The casting is a coup for the show, with fans buzzing about the on-screen reunion of Brody and Meester, who share a daughter and a son in real life. Other newcomers include Miles Fowler as Lenny, a basketball teammate of Noah’s who catches Morgan’s eye; Arian Moayed as Dr. Andy, a charismatic psychotherapist who might be Morgan’s perfect match; and Alex Karpovsky as Big Noah, a cocky rabbi at Noah’s temple who could stir up professional jealousy.
Behind the scenes, Season 2 marks a shift with new showrunners Jenni Konner and Bruce Eric Kaplan, both veterans of HBO’s Girls, taking the reins. Foster remains the creative voice, joined by her sister Sara Foster, Bell, Steven Levitan, and newcomer Nora Silver as executive producers. This powerhouse team aims to elevate the show’s blend of comedy and drama, with Konner praising Foster’s “crystal-clear voice” and collaborative spirit. Production wrapped in May 2025, with filming in Los Angeles, and the cast’s camaraderie—evident in behind-the-scenes photos shared by Tohn—suggests a tight-knit group pouring their hearts into the project. The show’s Golden Globe nominations for Best Television Musical or Comedy Series and acting nods for Bell and Brody, along with Brody’s Critics Choice Award win, underscore its critical and cultural impact.
The plot of Season 2 is shrouded in mystery, but teasers hint at a deeper exploration of sacrifice and growth. Noah’s grand gesture in the finale—choosing Joanne over his promotion—sets the stage for tough decisions. Will he regret putting love first? Brody has mused that the show will probe whether Noah’s choice holds up in the “light of day,” questioning what sacrifices are worth making for love. Joanne, meanwhile, faces her own reckoning. Her reluctance to convert stems from a desire to stay true to herself, but her feelings for Noah challenge her to confront her fears of commitment. Foster, who converted to Judaism in her own life, has clarified that Joanne’s journey won’t necessarily mirror her own, leaving room for surprises. “She’s her own person with her own story,” Foster said, suggesting that Season 2 could take bold risks with the couple’s arc.
The show’s supporting characters will also get their moment to shine. Morgan and Sasha’s flirtation in Season 1 raised eyebrows, and their “loser sibling” dynamic is ripe for more chaos—especially with Lenny and Dr. Andy entering Morgan’s orbit. Esther’s expanded role could mean more family drama, particularly as she navigates her loyalty to Noah and her own ambitions. The wider ensemble, including Stephanie Faracy as Joanne’s mother Lynn, Michael Hitchcock as her father Henry, and Tovah Feldshuh as Noah’s mother Bina, will continue to meddle, sabotage, and occasionally support the couple. Sherry Cola’s Ashley, Joanne’s best friend and Noah’s neighbor, and Shiloh Berman’s Miriam, Noah’s niece, add warmth and humor to the mix.
What makes Nobody Wants This stand out is its balance of frothy fun and poignant themes. The show doesn’t shy away from tackling cultural differences, religious identity, and the messy realities of modern relationships, all while delivering laugh-out-loud moments and swoon-worthy romance. Season 1’s success—spending six weeks on Netflix’s Global English Top 10 and reaching the Top 10 in 89 countries—proves its universal appeal. Fans have praised the show’s sharp writing, with The Guardian’s Lucy Mangan giving it a rare 5/5 stars for its “genuinely funny” and “timely” storytelling. Social media is abuzz with excitement for Season 2, with viewers clamoring for more of Joanne and Noah’s “addictive” chemistry and the show’s feel-good vibe.
As October 23 approaches, anticipation is building for what promises to be a binge-worthy continuation. Will Joanne and Noah find a way to bridge their differences, or will new rivals, family pressures, and personal doubts tear them apart? With a stellar cast, seasoned creative team, and a knack for blending humor with heart, Nobody Wants This Season 2 is shaping up to be a must-watch. One thing’s certain: everybody wants this—and the chaos is just getting started.
