The Superman: Legacy hype is in full swing, but not everyone is happy about one specific detail—David Corenswet’s red underwear. The return of the classic trunks-over-tights look has stirred up a fierce online debate, with some fans loving the nostalgic throwback while others think it’s completely outdated.

And now, director James Gunn has finally broken his silence, responding directly to the backlash.

THE GREAT SUPERMAN UNDERWEAR DEBATE: CLASSIC OR CRINGE?

When the first official image of David Corenswet as Superman dropped, fans were quick to react. The bright red trunks—a staple of Superman’s classic design—immediately became the biggest talking point.

 Some fans loved it, calling it a “return to tradition” that honors Superman’s Golden Age roots. Many praised Gunn for sticking to comic accuracy and celebrating what makes the character timeless.

 Others, however, were not impressed. Critics slammed the trunks as “outdated, goofy, and unnecessary,” arguing that Henry Cavill’s modern suit (which ditched the trunks) looked far more fitting for today’s superhero movies.

Twitter and Reddit exploded with reactions, with memes like:

“Superman saves the world, but first, he has to put on his diaper.”
“2025 Superman still dressed like it’s 1938? Come on, Gunn!”
“Cavill looked like a god. This? This looks like a cosplay.”

But just when the controversy reached its peak, James Gunn stepped in with a fiery response.

JAMES GUNN CLAPS BACK AT CRITICS: “THIS IS SUPERMAN!”

Never one to stay silent, James Gunn addressed the backlash head-on, making it clear that the red trunks were not just a random choice but a deliberate creative decision.

 Gunn’s response:
“Superman is the world’s most iconic superhero, and his suit is one of the most recognizable costumes of all time. The red trunks are part of that identity. We’re embracing what makes Superman, Superman.”

He also took a dig at the negativity, saying:
“If the biggest problem people have with a Superman movie is his trunks, I’d say we’re doing something right.”

 Translation? Gunn isn’t here to please the naysayers—he’s here to bring back the essence of Superman in its purest form.

THE BIGGER PICTURE: SUPERMAN’S LEGACY & WHAT REALLY MATTERS

While fans may be divided over Superman’s fashion choices, what’s most important is whether Superman: Legacy delivers the heart, hope, and inspiration that the character stands for.

David Corenswet is stepping into one of the most legendary superhero roles ever, and early reports suggest his performance will focus on Clark Kent’s humanity, struggles, and growth as a hero.

At the end of the day, Superman is about more than just his costume. Whether the trunks stay or go, what truly matters is whether the film captures the spirit of the Last Son of Krypton.

WHAT DO YOU THINK?

Are you Team Trunks or Team No-Trunks? Do you love the classic comic-accurate look, or do you think Superman should have moved on from the red underwear for good?

Drop your thoughts in the comments!