Prime Video’s Bridgerton Alternative With 93% Rotten Tomatoes Score Emerges as a Massive Streaming Success

Penelope looking serious in Bridgerton while Jane sits on the throne in My Lady Jane

Prime Video’s Bridgerton substitute My Lady Jane, which currently boasts a 93% critics score on Rotten Tomatoes, has become a massive streaming success, joining the ranks of other new, popular shows that have come out recently. The period drama is set in the 16th century, following Lady Jane Grey as she’s forced to marry Lord Guildfor Dudley after her father’s death. However, the series comes with a twist on the genre, as the My Lady Jane cast includes humans, called Verities, and Ethians, people who can alter their form to become animals.

Now, Reelgood has revealed that My Lady Jane has taken the Number 4 spot in the Top 10 streaming shows for the week of June 27 through July 3, 2024. The series came in just under streaming originals like Hulu’s The Bear and Apple TV+’s Presumed Innocent, but performed better than popular shows like House of the Dragon and The Acolyte. In addition, it came in at the Number 6 spot for Top 10 streaming movies and shows overall that week, showing how much potential the fantasy Bridgerton substitute has.

Top 10 Streaming Shows For June 27-July 3, 2024
Streaming Service

The Bear
Hulu

Presumed Innocent
Apple TV+

The Boys
Prime Video

My Lady Jane
Prime Video

The Acolyte
Disney+

House of the Dragon
Max

Your Honor
Netflix

Dark Matter
Apple TV+

Supacell
Netflix

Mayor of Kingstown
Paramount+

Why My Lady Jane Is A Massive Success For Prime Video

Jane from My Lady Jane is in front of a starry blue background.Custom Image by Dani Kessel Odom

My Lady Jane’s similarities to Bridgerton isn’t out of the ordinary, as streamers beyond Netflix have produced their own, similar period pieces since its success. One key example of this is Apple TV+’s The Buccaneers in 2023, which became enough of a hit to warrant a season 2 renewal the week after season 1 ended. The Prime Video period drama also has plenty of similarities to Netflix’s hit, including plenty of romantic drama and steamy love scenes between its core characters.

However, My Lady Jane differentiates itself by adding a fantasy twist to the story, the Ethians acting as a potent symbol of social disparities in the 1500s. While their addition helps bend the historical drama in a unique direction, their inclusion also helps the story tackle bigotry through a fantasy lens, aiding in giving the show a deeper meaning beyond its romance and historical reimaginings. It also keeps it from being too much like Bridgerton, allowing it to forge a different identity by blending genres together.

Given how much of an instant success the show has become, it wouldn’t be surprising if My Lady Jane season 2 were to be confirmed in the coming weeks. If it were to happen, then it could end up following an original story, as the book series it’s based on follows different characters named Jane with each new entry. However, with the show proving itself more popular than some of the biggest shows airing right now, it wouldn’t be surprising if a renewal were confirmed in the near future.

Related Posts

Peace Shattered: Queen of Tears Season 2 Trailer Drops – Hyun-woo & Hae-in’s Bliss Turns to Chaos with Takeovers and Divorce Threats!

The highly anticipated trailer for Queen of Tears Season 2 has finally arrived, pulling fans back into the turbulent world of Baek Hyun-woo (Kim Soo-hyun) and Hong…

Back-to-Back Sparks Ignite: Netflix’s Stunning New Poster for ‘Can This Love Be Translated?’ Teases Kim Seon-ho & Go Youn-jung’s Whirlwind Romance!

Netflix has dropped a captivating new poster for its highly anticipated romantic comedy Can This Love Be Translated?, sending fans into a frenzy as Kim Seon-ho and…

Maggie Smith’s Heartbreaking Final Bow: “The Miracle Club” Vanishes from Netflix Soon – Fans in Tears Over Her Graceful Goodbye.

As the holidays wrap up, Netflix subscribers are rushing to stream The Miracle Club one last time, Dame Maggie Smith’s poignant final screen performance that’s leaving the…

💔🕯️ Rest in Peace, Airen Andula: 13-Year-Old Kansas Boy Found Dead After Vanishing While Helping a Neighbor — Small Town Left in Shock 😢

The quiet Holiday Lakes community near Pleasanton, Kansas, is enveloped in profound grief this Christmas Eve after the heartbreaking confirmation that 13-year-old Airen Andula has been found…

Stephen Colbert’s Heartfelt Farewell: Auctions Priceless Late Show Items – Including Final Episode Tickets – to Fight Hunger!

As The Late Show with Stephen Colbert enters its emotional final months before wrapping in May 2026, the beloved host is channeling his signature blend of humor…

👀🚓 TWO MONTHS OF MYSTERY ENDS IN HORROR: Ashlee Buzzard Arrested for First-Degree Murder After DNA Confirms Utah Remains Are Her Missing Daughter 💔⚖️

A chilling case that gripped the nation for over two months reached a devastating conclusion on December 23, 2025, when authorities announced the arrest of Ashlee Buzzard,…