Unraveling ‘Outer Banks’ Tragedies: What Really Happened to Big John and Sheriff Peterkin?

Outer Bank Character Deaths Explainer

In April 2020, Outer Banks season 1 aired on Netflix and fans of the teen drama have been obsessed ever since. That said, there’s a lot more to the show than meets the eye. Sure, it’s about love and friendship, but it also features a considerable amount of mystery, death and crime. In the case of John B’s dad, Big John, it might just be all three!

*Warning: spoilers ahead.* Early in the season, John B (played by actor Chase Stokes) is convinced his father (played by actor Charles Halford) is missing at sea. However, in episode 8, “The Runaway,” Ward Cameron (played by actor Charles Esten) admits he killed Big John while the pair was on the hunt for the Royal Merchant treasure.

After Big John suggested he and Ward split the gold 80/20, Ward became enraged and physically violent. At one point, he accidentally pushed Big John too hard, causing him to hit the back of his head on the boat and bleed out.

Naturally, Ward panicked and decided to throw him overboard. The last time viewers see Big John is in a flashback in which he washed up on the shore still alive. In his last moments, he carved John B a message on his compass.

Some fan theories suggest that Big John isn’t actually dead and he’s hiding out in The Bahamas. Would that be an awesome plot twist? Yes! Is it likely? No. Ward sent his associate Scooter Grubbs (played by actor David Ury) to find Big John’s remains and he was very much deceased.

Unless Outer Banks turns into a series about the supernatural, we don’t think anyone is coming back from the dead. Sadly, Big John wasn’t the only character to die in season 1. Sheriff Peterkin (played by actress Adina Porter) was shot and killed by Rafe Cameron (played by actor Drew Starkey).

Even if Rafe pulled the trigger, Sheriff Peterkin’s death was, once again, Ward Cameron’s fault. Scroll through the gallery below to learn more about who dies on Outer Banks

1 of 3

Outer Banks Cast Explainer

imageSPACE/Shutterstock

Sheriff Peterkin

Sheriff Peterkin eventually discovered that Ward killed Big John and was preparing to out him to the police department. Once Ward got word of this, he decided to flee.

Everything came to a head when Sheriff Peterkin intercepted Ward at the airport. At the same time, Rafe and his sister Sarah Cameron (played by Madelyn Cline) showed up. In order to protect his dad, Rafe shot the Sheriff. Ward later blamed her death on John B.

2 of 3

Outer Banks Cast Explainer

Richard Shotwell/Invision/AP/Shutterstock

Big John

It’s 99.9 percent likely Big John is dead, but we expect to see more flashbacks of him in season 2 (should Netflix give the series the green light). After all, if there was anyone who knew a thing or two about treasure hunts and dealing with bad guys, it was him.

Related Posts

That Opening Smile in Purple Hearts Season 2: Is Luke and Cassie Finally Getting Their Happy Ending?

The screen fades in on golden California sunlight spilling through the blinds of a modest Oceanside apartment. Luke Morrow (Nicholas Galitzine) stirs awake, his hand instinctively brushing…

Lucy and Stephen Are Back to Wrecking Lives in Tell Me Lies Season 3—Hulu’s Just Dropped the Date, and It’s a Chaos-Fueled Valentine from Hell!

The notification hits your phone like a sucker punch from an ex you can’t quit: Tell Me Lies Season 3 premieres January 13, 2026. Hulu’s not playing…

Kimmie faked her grave, Antoine sold his soul, and now Mr. & Mrs. Smith 2.0 are reloading for a blood-soaked honeymoon in Beauty in Black S3—Tyler Perry just turned betrayal into a vow renewal!

The screen explodes in a hail of glass and gunfire, and there she is—Kimmie, eyes blazing, lips curled into the smirk that fooled death itself. Season 3…

Sarah Snook swaps boardroom knives for suburban nightmares in All Her Fault—the 8-episode thriller that’s got viewers screaming “best show of the year” before the credits even roll.

The final seconds of the premiere episode fade to black, and your living room falls silent except for the thud of your own heartbeat. That’s the All…

Love. Lies. Revenge. Culpa Nuestra Brings Noah & Nick Back Together — But One Crash Changes Everything 😱🚗

On October 16, 2025, Amazon Prime Video unleashed Culpa Nuestra (Our Fault), the third and final chapter of the Culpables trilogy, and the internet hasn’t stopped buzzing…

At 13, She Lost Her Family to War — My Name Is Sara Tells the True Story of a Girl Who Survived by Becoming Someone Else 😢🕊️

A single photograph changed everything. It was 1992, in a war-torn village on the edge of the Balkans, and 13-year-old Sara Hadžić stood in the ruins of…